Paris. The city of art, museums, the French Revolution. Home to the Eiffel Tower, the Mona Lisa, and the Cathedral of Notre Dame. It’s the cultural center of Europe, if not the world.
But there’s a darker side to the capital of romance. It’s a small neighborhood known as Barbs in the northern part of the city. Described as the “South Bronx of Paris,” Barbs is a ghetto of poverty and desperation in a city of enormous wealth.
When I first walked through Barbs the summer before last, I rubbed my eyes in disbelief. I had been in Paris visiting my brother for about a week and during that time I saw all the glamorous sites: the legendary Eiffel Tower, the awe-inspiring Louvre museum, the grand Arc de la Triomphe. The filthy, somber streets of Barbs just didn’t fit with all that. “I must be dreaming,” I said to myself. “This is another world.” And it was.
It was the world of the underclass, the poor. Barbs is where most of Paris’ Arab immigrants live. It’s home to the thousands of Algerians and Moroccans who’ve tried to escape the poverty and hopelessness of their North African homelands. The city of luxury, however, could not accept them. They were a burden. So Barbs was created, and those who saw hope in France’s revolutionary ideals of “Liberty, Equality, and Fraternity” were swept into it, like litter swept under a rug, hidden from tourists’ prying eyes.
Parisians Jumping Turnstiles
As soon as I got off the train which stops in the center of Barbs, I immediately recognized the signs of the ghetto: Dozens of people (mostly young men) loitering under the elevated tracks, people jumping the train turnstiles, peddlers selling their wares throughout the streets, filthy sidewalks, crumbling buildings and a general atmosphere of helplessness.
Small cafes were overflowing with men; teenagers were hanging out along most street corners-common signs of high unemployment. The streets were filled with garbage and sewage from broken pipes. Squatters occupied vacant and run-down buildings. Dirty porches and window sills were brimming with clothes that were being hung out to dry. Under the elevated train station, someone had carelessly scribbled in Arabic: “Urination Prohibited Here.” There was a strong stench of urine.
People in Barbs speak mainly French with a few Arabic words thrown into each sentence. Both Frenchmen and Arabs have trouble understanding them. Their language too sets them apart.
Meanwhile…Up on the Hill
What’s even more shocking, however, is that Barbs lies beneath one of France’s premier attractions-Montmartre. The Paris equivalent of New York’s Village, Montmartre is an arts and cultural haven atop a hill overlooking the Arab ghetto.
At the peak of this hill is an architectural and religious landmark second to none in Europe: La Chaple de Sacre Coeur (Chapel of the Sacred Heart). Its ivory-white walls beam in the sunlight but cast an intimidating shadow over Barbs.
The small, narrow streets of Montmartre are also strewn with litter-a different kind of litter. Things like film wrappers, worn-out tourist maps and used admission tickets for the local craft museum are scattered along the otherwise sparkling sidewalks. Unlike Barbs, the high-class trash of Montmartre does not linger in the streets for days.
But the startling contrast between the two neighborhoods is most visible at night. That’s when Montmartre’s esplanades overflow with painters, street performers, puppeteers and other artists. The sidewalk cafes-Paris’ trademark-also burst with activity. Tourists sample dozens of different kinds of food from Chinese to Italian to Greek.
Smiling Faces
On the hot summer nights, people joke and laugh so hard atop Montmartre, it’s hard to imagine they have a care in the world. But they should, for right down the hill children go to bed with empty stomachs and rotting teeth that would probably ache if they dared to crack a smile.
The streets of Barbs are dark and desolate at night. There are very few sidewalk cafes or classy restaurants. It’s a tourist’s worst nightmare to wander in there at night.
One look into the thoughts of the average Frenchman and I began to see how such grave injustices could exist. About week after my trip to Barbs, I attended a birthday party for one of my brother’s French friends. After the food and cake, the conversation turned to immigration in France. Since my brother and I are both Lebanese, the discussion was mainly centered around Arabs.
“They’re coming here, having children and living off our taxes.” “They’re all criminals.” “They don’t respect our lifestyle.” These were some of the gripes expressed by my brother’s friends that night. Such comments-and the simplistic excuses behind them-are widespread in France (and much of Western Europe) these days. In Germany they’ve led to a revival of Naziism and the bombing of refugee centers. It seems America is not the only place where racism and intolerance are thriving.
The Paris Tourists Never See
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.