The Identity Experiment

How Much Are We Defined By What We Wear?

One morning last month, I curled my hair and tied a bit of it back to show my face. I also wore an excessive amount of black eyeliner and black eye shadow for a “smoky eyes” look. I wore my mother’s black shoes with tight blue jeans and a tight black T-shirt to show off my black hair. I thought I looked good and I felt confident.
When I got to school, I saw my good friend in the hallway. She looked at me and said, “I haven’t seen you in two weeks and you look good! Wow.” I told her I wanted the “dress to kill” look.
She smiled at me, looked me up and down, nodded her head and said, “Yeah, you’re definitely dressed to kill.”
Every time I went to the bathroom to check my eye makeup, I couldn’t help but think about my freshman year and how I never would’ve done something like this. Back then, I always wore plain clothing. I had fuzzy hair in a ponytail and I didn’t use gel or hair spray to make it less puffy. I looked like the stereotypical smart, quiet Chinese girl.
Recently I’ve started changing-tweezing my eyebrows, styling my hair. But I don’t usually wear makeup or shoes with heels, and I was surprised at how much people noticed the change.
A Girly Girl
Later that day, a guy in the hallway looked me in the face and said, “Hey, how you doing, Miss?” I was surprised because that doesn’t often happen to me.
When I walked into class, a classmate looked me up and down with a “What’s the occasion?” look. Before I knew it, the whole class was saying things like, “What are you doing after school?” and, “Do you have a date?”
I just blushed and looked away. I didn’t want to be the center of the attention. I knew I looked good, but to me it wasn’t something to talk or brag about. It was more of an inside kind of feeling for me, a confidence that I’d longed to feel all through high school.
It was amazing. All I’d done was add eye makeup and some tight jeans, and I felt completely different about myself. And other people saw me completely differently.
I wondered, “How much does our appearance affect how people perceive us and how we feel about ourselves?” If I got this big a reaction from a little eye shadow, what if I looked completely different? Would people react differently? Would I feel different? I decided to do an experiment to figure out just how much our appearance can shape how we think of ourselves.
I planned to try out different identities on different days-goth, girly, hip-hop and my normal look-to see if people would react differently. I’d take the same route home each day and stop at the same corner deli. The only difference would be my appearance. That way I could be sure that anything I was feeling, and any reactions I got, would be based on how I looked.
Day One: Goth
The next day, I came to the NYC office and a goth writer helped me dress like her. I wore a black lace collar, black Converse sneakers, huge baggy black pants with gold zippers everywhere, and a spiked belt and silver chains wrapped around my hips. I also wore three huge necklaces, including a heavy back cross on a chain. I wore a massive amount of black makeup-eyeliner, eye shadow, even black lipstick and nail polish. I drew a black star on the bottom of my left eye to enhance the dark look.
When I looked at myself in the mirror, I saw myself as the same person, just wearing a different outfit. I didn’t feel different until I was out in public. As I walked along 34th Street, a middle-aged guy looked at me. After we crossed paths, he turned his head and continued to stare. I knew from his eyes that he wasn’t looking at me because I was beautiful, but because I looked different.
More heads turned as I continued down 34th Street, and I could see people giving me this “what-the-hell-was-she-thinking” look. Their stares seemed to say I wasn’t like them and I didn’t belong in this society. I was starting to hate being dressed like this.
After being stared at and even laughed at on the train home, my stomach felt queasy and I was crying inside. I wanted to get out of this outfit now. I didn’t want to look like this anymore. I couldn’t handle the stress.
I Hated the Attention
I have friends who are goth and they tell me that people often give them stares and they don’t care at all. Their attitude is “screw what everyone thinks-normal people suck.”
I think these friends dress goth because it’s a reflection of who they are and their own taste, but I don’t fully understand it because I’m not like that. I found that I hated the attention. I also think for me it was a little different because I’m Chinese and people aren’t used to seeing a Chinese girl dressed this way.
That evening, I went to a corner deli store near my friend’s house in Harlem. I’d gone there the day before in my “girly” outfit, and the deli guy had given me a horny, turned-on look. But this time he didn’t pay any attention to me. He wasn’t even looking at me as I bought my M&Ms. I knew right then that people do treat you differently depending on how you dress.
I was relieved to get home that night. Though I liked the comfort of the black baggy pants, I hated people’s mean reactions and that they couldn’t just accept my style. This was not an identity I’d try again.
Day Two: Downtown Club Girl
For my next outfit, I went for a “downtown, clubbing in the Village” look. After my miserable goth experience, I was excited to look feminine again. I was ready to walk around in my short skirt and I looked forward to people’s reactions.
As I was applying my makeup, I thought about how long it was taking me. And even though I don’t normally like the idea of being hit on, I found myself thinking, “Someone has to hit on me-all this hard work has to pay off!” I had no idea what I was in for.
Dressed in a green top, a short gauzy black miniskirt and heeled ankle boots, I felt so naked. More naked than I’d ever felt in my entire life. Walking from the train was embarrassing and I wanted to walk faster to get away, but I couldn’t. Not in these shoes. I felt everyone’s eyes on my bare legs. I wished I’d brought a pair of jeans with me to hide my legs.
Flattering…At First
When I was switching trains in Brooklyn before coming to the NYC office, a teenager said to me, “Hey Sweetie,” and I felt his eyes roam all over my body. I actually smiled in my head because he was the first to really say something about my outfit, and I found it flattering.
But when I got out of the train, a grown man in his 30s looked at me from head to toe and said, “Mmmm,” like I was food and it looked delicious. As I made my way across the street, a man wearing a huge fur coat and handing out fliers said, “Nice legs.” I was starting to wish I’d never walked out of the house like this.
As the day went on, I found that I didn’t like the attention after all. I felt like my butt was hanging out of my skirt. I felt like people thought I was a slut or a hooker and I hated looking like one. I got comments from three more guys (all grown men) in one block. A guy in a white van even stopped and waved for me to come over to him.
I Felt Like a Hooker
After a while I put on this sad, long, depressed face so people would leave me alone and not think of me as a slut. I told myself, “I’m returning this skirt tomorrow.”
When I stopped to buy a soda, a man coming out of the store said, “Look at you looking all sexy.” In the store, another man said that I had “this innocent face that burns all.” I said thank you because I thought it was a compliment, but after I left I wasn’t so sure.
Later, I went into that same corner deli where I’d gone the previous two days. This time, the guy behind the deli counter (who’d looked at me hungrily in my girly outfit and ignored me in my goth outfit) looked at me from head to toe as if disgusted. He gave me a dirty look like I was a prostitute. I couldn’t wait to get home and change into a pair of jeans.
What surprised me most about dressing in this outfit was that I liked it, at least at first. I liked that it made me feel-and I hate to admit this-pretty inside because of the compliments I got. But after a while, the looks from people on the street made me feel like I was a tramp.
Day Three: Hip-Hop
For my next outfit, I wore a huge, sleeveless basketball jersey and a flat-brimmed baseball cap to go with it, both of which I borrowed from my boyfriend. The jersey was like a dress on me, but I tucked the bottom into my jeans, and with my puffy black down jacket over it, it wasn’t too noticeable.
But I felt miserable because I thought I looked boyish. I hated the hugeness of the shirt. And I hate wearing anything on my head because I wear glasses. The cap kept falling on my glasses, which made my glasses keep falling down my face. But most of all, I felt I looked like a fake, trying to look cool.
When I walked the same streets as I had in all my other outfits, the looks I got weren’t surprising. People’s eyes clung to my face until I passed them, and girls gave me a weird “Who is she trying to be, dressing that way” look.
Feeling Like a Fake
When I was in the deli, a teenage girl looked at me up and down and breathed in my entire outfit. I could tell she thought I was trying too hard to fit in and that made me feel angry because I would never wear something that’s not me just to fit in. Plus, I felt like I was trying too hard too, and it was annoying. Even the deli guy looked at me from head to toe with a smirk on his face.
At the end of the day, there was nothing I liked about my hip-hop outfit. I didn’t look or feel pretty. The shirt was too long, the cap was huge on my small head and the entire look was way out of my league. I’d never wear it again.
Day 4: The Real Me
After that experience, it was a relief to dress as my regular self the next day. I wore a plain black T-shirt and jeans, with no makeup or accessories. I liked the simplicity of the outfit. I didn’t have to worry about whether my eyeliner was smudged or if my earrings went with my outfit or if my hair looked right. I felt so laid back and relaxed, like this was the real me. The quiet, innocent me.
And not surprisingly, I didn’t get any reactions the whole day. No looks or “Hey Sweetie” or muttering. It was as if they didn’t see me at all. But I saw the real me in that outfit, and I liked it. I’m just another ordinary-looking girl, and I’m happy with that.
Judged by Our Clothes
This whole experience has taught me a couple of things. It confirmed my idea that we’re judged immediately by what we wear. Our clothes are windows into our identities. When strangers see us, they make assumptions about who we are based on our appearance, and they react accordingly.
I also learned how much my feelings about myself are based on other people’s reactions. In the goth outfit, I didn’t feel one bit different until I went outside. When people started staring and laughing, it really hurt and made me want to take off the outfit right away.
And when I wore the short skirt, I felt flattered by the compliments I got. I’d never thought I was pretty, but those reactions gave me a little hope that I might not be bad looking after all. At the same time, when people looked at me like I was a slut, I felt naked and uncomfortable.
Who I Am
When I look in the mirror, I want to see myself in what I wear, and I want other people to see who I am. This experiment gave me a better idea of who that is. I found that I was afraid to wear outfits like goth and hip-hop, but I was excited about wearing the girly outfits. Maybe that’s who I am-maybe I’m more of a girly girl than I’d thought.
I think I never admitted that to myself before because I was ashamed of it. I didn’t want to be one of those girls who has to buy the latest trends and cries when she breaks a nail. But I actually like wearing girly clothes and a little makeup, and I like getting compliments (as long as they’re from guys my age).
I like feeling comfortable too, though. For now, I’ll probably keep my same look and just wear a little eye makeup occasionally, and maybe even a skirt. One that covers my legs though-I’ve already returned the miniskirt.

View the lessons based on this story

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.