The Gaming World: CDs vs. Cartridges

In the video gaming world there is an on-going battle between CDs and cartridge media.
From the days of the first Atari systems, such as the 2600, 5200, and Coleco Vision (4-bit systems), cartridges ruled. They started out at about $5 and the systems were about $50. Cartridges were the first way to play games without buying a PC.
Now game cartridges do what people of the Atari days could only dream about. Companies such as Sega and Nintendo rule with their 16-bit systems. Their games cost, on average, about $49.
Access Time
In 1982, Sony invented the CD. CDs were not only good for recording music, but for storage of graphics and other large files on PC’s, as well as video games.
One of the first CD game systems was made by Turbo Grafx. It didn’t sell because the $399 system was plagued by crappy access time (you had to wait five minutes for the game to start up).
Since then, both cartridges and CDs have been incorporated into almost every game system, but the war between the formats rages on.
Here are the plain facts on the upside:
Cartridges are what most gaming companies use, and you can get almost any game you want on a cartridge. You don’t have to worry about access time between stages, so you don’t have to pause your thumb-busting-action while blasting enemies or saving the damsel in distress.
Most cartridge games use compression to make the extra space needed for special effects and graphics, such as Donkey Kong Country from Nintendo, which has 172 megabits compressed into 32 megabits. (It’s like taking a two-liter soda and squeezing it into a 16-ounce can.)
CDs, on the other hand, have enormous storage capacity-about 500 megabytes, which is equal to about 500 eight-megabit cartridges. (Imagine a game like Starfox, but only 500 times bigger.) This space allows for full-motion video (actual movie footage like in Night Trap on the Sega CD) and superb graphics.
Thanks to the digital sound CDs have, you can produce music with real instruments, along with surround sound and Qsound (surround sound with only two speakers).
The 3-D sound effects range from ear-rocking explosions to effects that make you feel like you’re in the game itself!
Now the downside of both:
Cartridges are getting outdated because of their limited storage space. The memory chips used in cartridges are expensive, so the more memory, the more expensive it is, like Super Street Fighter from Nintendo, which is 32 megabits and costs about $70, in contrast to Shadow Dancer from Sega (a great game I might add), which is four megabits and costs about $19.99.
You can get a whole lot more memory on a CD for about $10 to $20 less. Also, the bulkier cartridges don’t fit in your pocket too well.
CDs: If you are playing a CD game and bump your system or shake the table, the game will freeze and you’ll have reset and start from scratch if you didn’t save it. Also, in order to save your game on a CD, you have to buy a ROM cartridge for about $49. (This allows you to save your CD game to a blank cartridge so you can start where you left off.)
Or imagine you are up to the last boss and all of a sudden the game freezes because your laser lens is dirty or there’s a fingerprint on the CD (I’d be pissed).
So CDs take extra care, while you could throw a cartridge down the stairs and it would probably still work.
So both media have their ups and downs, but who’s to say which one will reign in the 32 and 64-bit future?

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.