The Burden of a Suicidal Sister

Names have been changed.
When the three of us entered the psych ward, I was struck by the quiet. The patients padded through the halls in their socks. You could see your reflection in the polished floor, and when sunlight hit the white walls, tiles, and ceiling, the place looked soft and gentle.
My mother, father, and I were led down a corridor. I glimpsed a very thin man whose clothes hung off of him; a pregnant woman in a patient’s gown waddled behind him.
The hallway widened into the visitor center and we spotted my sister Tina, my only sibling, eating alone at a table. She looked worn out. Her face was expressionless and her short hair was a greasy mess. On the sleeve of her sweater I noticed a red stain.
“I had a nosebleed,” she explained.
We kept the conversation light. Tina told my parents and me stories about her roommate, a grouchy elderly woman, and another patient named Robert, who nicknamed her “College Girl” and liked to talk about physics. She seemed to be chattering to entertain us. But then she told us about another friend she had made, a bipolar woman who had thrown herself in front of a train but survived.
At this, my mother muttered ” Poor youâ ” sarcastically, implying that Tina was complaining about being in here with these more disturbed people, as if Tina was spoiled and ungrateful. My sister looked down at her lap and didn’t respond. The fact was that Tina had told her psychologist just a week earlier that she wanted to kill herself.
“What are you eating?” my mother ventured, and my sister pointed to the food on her tray, from the peaches, to the chocolate milk, to the rice.
“I’m gaining weight,” my sister said with a smile. She has been underweight all her life. She often doesn’t eat because she’s afraid of getting fat.
“That’s great! Your face looks a little fuller too,” my mom responded.

Tina frowned, and looked at me.

“Why are you dressed like that?” she asked about my formal clothing.

I shrugged. “I had to look fancy for this ceremony.”

Earlier that day, I’d been accepted into my high school’s honor society. I smiled brightly when I shook the principal’s hand. I posed with my certificate, and ate celebratory bagels with my classmates, but all I could think about was the upcoming visit and how my sister was doing.

Tina nodded and then pulled the bottle of chocolate milk off the tray.

“You can have it. I don’t really like chocolate.”

We sat there while she ate the rest of her food.
Something Off
Tina is four years older than me. She has always had something “off” about her, even when we were little kids. She fidgets. She can’t cut her nails because she’s afraid of slicing her fingers, so she lets them grow out until they look like claws, then files them for hours. When she checks the locks at night, she throws her weight against the door to test the lock’s strength. This pounding noise will go on and on for about 20 minutes, and afterwards she often just stands worriedly at the door.
It’s one thing to have quirks and strange rituals. As a kid, I found it funny. Once when I was little, she heard about a burglary on the news, and asked me if I had checked the locks. I responded that I’d seen strange men in the living room the night before. Now I realize that’s mean, but we were younger and I didn’t realize her paranoia would get so out of hand.
By the time she entered her third year of college, about a year ago, Tina had developed more serious problems. She couldn’t handle the stress of her schoolwork. She had to get 100% on every test and would stay up all night skimming the pages of her textbook. The lights would be on until 5 a.m. During finals she began having panic attacks.
“It’s like my head is going to explode,” is how Tina described the panic attacks to me. We shared a room, so I could see how bad it was getting. She barely slept and when she did, she cursed and screamed because of nightmares.
Tina obsessed over things that didn’t matter, or else she spun fantasies about the future. She began to seem more and more disconnected from reality. She recently said to me, “When I graduate, we’re going to live together, and I’ll buy you a puppy!”
When she said things like that, I acted delighted, trying to show her it wasn’t that hard to be cheerful. “Yay!” I felt like a pet dog when I blinked at her, looking simple-minded and unconditionally loving, when inside I was losing my patience and would rather be somewhere else.
Though Tina is so open with me, her friends from school don’t know about her problems, and boyfriends don’t understand it. That isolation is making her increasingly dependent on me. Over this past year, every day begins with her begging, “Do you love me?” Then she watches me until I’m uncomfortable.
After the third time, I’m saying through my teeth and on the brink of screaming, “âYes.”

“Are you sure?”

“Yes.” I have to answer her with conviction, over and over, or else she looks sad.
I’m Not Her Mother
Tina’s doctor had already diagnosed her with OCD, depression, and anxiety. Then her psychologist told my mother that Tina said she wanted to kill herself. She was put on suicide watch in the mental hospital.
“Your sister’s a drama queen,” was my mom’s response to Tina going to the psych ward. I can’t agree with her, because I don’t understand what’s going through Tina’s mind. To me, Tina is just sick and can’t be blamed for her own strange behavior.
I think my mother switches between shame and guilt for having a mentally ill child, and there’s no doubt the financial burden has taken a toll on her. My dad doesn’t work, and my mom has been working the night shift as a nurse for the past decade. She’s tired and overworked, and I think that Tina’s neurotic behaviors, like stressing out over the locks or talking about her fears, are too much for her to bear.
The two of them often just grunt at each other. I act as messenger between my parents and my sister. A typical exchange with my parents goes like this:
“Tell Tina to be nice. She only listens to you,” my dad sighs.
“I lose sleep over her,” my mother says. She scrubs her face with a hand, and there are dark circles under her eyes. “Take care of your sister when you get older, OK?”
“Why? I’m not her mother.” I say this often, but because I smile when I say it she doesn’t catch that I’m annoyed.
“I know, but she’s your sister,” is her response. Family comes first, but what about my future and my life?
My family expects so much from me. I’m supposed to provide boundless affection; I have to radiate joy and cheer Tina up. My job at home is to be very happy and grateful. I have to be an excellent student because I have no reason not to be. The result is me feeling empty when I’m providing the companionship my sister needs and guilty because I feel like I shouldn’t complain.
If I try to keep the peace, things stay delicately OK, but if I step back, they argue and fight, and Tina wants to kill herself. I try to be friendly and agreeable with both my parents and sister, and I wish that were enough. But my family really needs openness and acceptance. My parents need to be patient with Tina and acknowledge her fears without dismissing them as drama.
I’m sort of stuck. If Tina is paranoid, having panic attacks and suicidal episodes, then what about me? There’s nothing I can really do, and the effort only overwhelms me. I’m afraid that being around a depressed person will drag me into depression, and I don’t want to have to nurse her for the rest of my life.
wouldn’t it be healthier for the both of us if she tried to take charge of her own life? Though extremely difficult, through therapy, medication, and determination, I think it’s possible for her to cope with her mental illness. That would leave me room to worry about my own future. But until that happens, how am I supposed to balance my family’s needs and my own?
Trapped
I want my own life, but on the other hand, Tina needs to know she isn’t alone. As her sister and her friend, I want to be kind and understanding in a difficult time.
The night after my visit to the psych ward, I talk to Tina on the phone. The house is very quiet. The kitchen is dark because I’ve shut all the lights off, and I’m pacing as I listen to her. She’s whispering because she doesn’t want to disturb the other patients.
“Do you miss me?” a tiny voice on the other end asks.
“Yes. Of course.”
“I wanted to kill myself,” Tina says.
I can’t imagine how a person can be so horrified at the thought of living. I wonder how Tina can be so calm about this. Maybe medication and a week in a hospital have numbed the memory for her, but the solution is temporary. Outside, my sister’s life is still waiting for her.
I don’t know how to respond.
“My English teacher’s an ass,” I blurt out.
Tina laughs. The sound is faint through the telephone. “Well, you don’t have to major in English. You can do whatever you want. You’re very smartâ” she trails off. “You’ll have a better future than me.”
“Are you sleeping?” I ask.
“I just take my meds, and after 10 minutes, I’m knocked outâ. I’m hoping I can get out of here next week.”
I’m still alone in the kitchen, pressing my ear against the phone.
“OK, butâ You have to try to get better.” I honestly don’t believe this will happen.
“OK,” she mumbles.
“We’ll visit you again tomorrow.”
“Goodnight,” she says, and I hang up the phone.
I love her, but it’s not my job or responsibility to keep Tina together. I’m still in high school. I have my own future to get excited about, plan, and enjoy. If I could let go of my family’s problems, then surely I could get started. If I don’t, I worry that I could end up trapped and afraid—like Tina.
For more information on dealing with a mentally ill sibling, see our interview: Coping with a Mentally Ill Sibling .
This story is part of the health literacy series, which is generously supported by the Cigna Foundation.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.