My Rating: * * *
You know, just recently the papers were raving about how so many new movies are being filmed in New York City all of a sudden. Now look how the movies repay us. In Deep Impact, New York City gets demolished.
Of course, considering the $41 million box office take Deep Impact received during its opening week, it looks like we love watching Manhattan get trashed. And we can look forward to seeing similar action in the extravagantly hyped Godzilla.
But even though I haven’t seen Godzilla yet, I think it’s a safe bet that Deep Impact will emerge as the more meaningful and less popcorny of the two.
The Characters Make the Movie
Let me explain. The film, directed by Mimi Leder (The Peacemaker), spins a grimly triumphant tale around the devastating worldwide threat of an approaching comet. But it succeeds more on the strength of its characters than on the action.
So first, the cast. An unlikely ensemble, it includes Tea Leoni as a lowly news reporter who stumbles upon the biggest story of her life (obviously), and Robert Duvall heading the astronaut crew that’s supposed to stop the comet.
Morgan Freeman plays the inexorably cryptic but reassuring president of the United States, and Elijah Wood is Leo Beiderman, the ambitious high school student who discovers the comet with his telescope.
You Can Grab a Few Laughs
If you’ll notice, I not only described their roles in the plot, but some of their personality traits, as well.
That’s the biggest thing about this movie: You get to know and experience the lives of the individual characters and see how they deal with the situation.
For example, we see the reporter reuniting with her estranged father, who happens to be over 50, which makes him ineligible to live within the immense network of caves constructed to salvage some human life.
And we see the famous comet-kid marrying the girl next door in an effort to get her and her parents into the caves. The film oozes with tragedy.
The film also manages to grab a few laughs with its comet-disaster jokes. Like when the reporter meets with her dad and his new, young girlfriend, he says, “Life goes on,” in an attempt to bring up her spirits.
“We’ll see,” she says, laughing wildly.
A Movie With Meaning
But most creepy of all is the president of the United States, Morgan Freeman, whose reassuring “We will prevail…life will go on” speech at the beginning of the movie is replaced at the end by this scientific explanation of the world’s predicament:
“The landing of the second comet will be nothing less… than an Extinction Level Event (E.L.E). The skies will darken for two years…all plant life will perish within a couple of weeks…animal life, a couple of months.”
The comet itself is interesting because it is just this large piece of rock that’s going to end everything every human being has ever worked for, yet it doesn’t have any feelings and it doesn’t care where it lands.
In other words, the movie is not about the comet. It’s more about irony, the meaning of humanity, and the value of life.
It’s about what we would do if we finally realized how easily our whole society could be wiped out in a glance, by something as useless as a simple chunk of space rock.
Why Trash the Big Apple?
Pretty cool, huh? Of course, all compliments aside, I do have a few bones to pick with our little comet-disaster flick. Like, for instance, why only Manhattan is shown getting trashed and not the rest of the world.
We’re told at the end that the tidal wave created by the first comet also washed over Europe and Africa, yet the only things we get to see washed over are the Big Apple and a jammed interstate.
And though the special effects are quite impressive (like the very scary space scenes with the astronauts, and the Twin Towers getting flooded and then washed away), this actually undermines the “worldwide disaster” mood that was being set up at the beginning of the movie. It just seemed like a New York City disaster.
Better Than Godzilla?
And I didn’t really like that they saved all the action- Manhattan being washed out in a couple of minutes by a 1,000 foot tidal wave going at 1,100 miles per hour-for the last 20 minutes.
Most of the movie is not about destruction. So I think the promo might be somewhat misleading when it says: “Oceans rise. Cities fall, etc.”
Although the emphasis on real characters is a nice trend, action fans will be somewhat disappointed.
Despite this, however, Deep Impact is a fairly good flick. And, perhaps, a little more believable than a giant lizard stomping over New York City? In any case, watch both and then decide.
But whatever you do, don’t turn into that guy next door who didn’t go see Titanic until it swept the Oscars.
These are the summer blockbusters, watch them while they’re hot.
The Big Apple Gets Trashed
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.