The Battle for Open Admissions

Before I attended a meeting about CUNY, I didn’t know much about open admissions (a guaranteed place for every high school graduate at one of CUNY’s colleges) or remediation, nor could I see their importance.
Then I listened, and later read, about how open admissions came about and I began to understand.
One of the first schools where minority students began to demand greater access to a CUNY education was City College, a senior college in Harlem.
Fighting For An Education
In the early 1960s, student demonstrators demanded that Black and Puerto Rican students, who made up almost half of New York City public school students, should be about 40% of the student population at City College, too not 2%.
They took their demands to the street; they even resorted to violence.
Students dropped smoke bombs in classes, dumped paint down stairways, and held the liberal arts campus gates shut for over a week, ignoring a court order to re-open them.
Those students saw the severity of being denied something crucial to their survival (education).
At the time, City College had very strict admissions criteria, and most Black and Latino students could not meet them. But the students believed City College should be open to them, regardless of their preparation. These were motivated students. They wanted more.
Still, this issue was very controversial because those who opposed open admissions believed that this policy would lower the reputation and standards of the school. But, in the end, the protesters won and CUNY changed.
I admire these people who desired something so much that they’d do almost anything for it. Love maybe, but education? Wow.
Remembering the Early Years
Many of the older people attending the meeting remembered the first years of open admissions; that’s what made them so passionate. Some of the professors shared their memories of those first years, as a diverse crowd of eager students struggled to achieve their goals despite inadequate preparation.
One recalled the first year being tough.
“Classes were held in temporary trailers, there was frenetic hiring of new faculty,” he said. The students were also overwhelmed by other problems, like multiple jobs and the responsibility of raising families, he explained.
Diverse and Determined
Despite the new challenges, these professors say the experience was worth it, because their students are diverse and determined-“young mothers, immigrants from Guyana and from the former Soviet Unionâstudents from East New York and Brownsville”-and are hungry for knowledge, said Professor Greg Donaldson.
Douglas Anderson, a professor at Borough of Manhattan Community College, who has taught at both public and elite universities, said that the most impressive difference between some of his students at BMCC and at places like Columbia-where the majority of students are middle class, and most have parents who attended college-is motivation. At CUNY, he says, many of his students are more motivated.
Excelling Where You Are
“At Columbiaâthey’re there because they’re expected to be there. Success in life is assured,” he said. But at CUNY, more students come from low-income families where older family members have not sought higher education. As a result, many CUNY students push themselves harder because so much rides on success in school.
I think maybe Professor Anderson was getting a bit carried a way with his praise. I’m sure there are students at CUNY who aren’t doing their best.
And I don’t think that all the students at Columbia take their education for granted. I hope to go there myself.
Still, I think what Professor Anderson means is that often the students who have nothing to fall back on-and for whom this type of rigorous education is exciting and new-put every part of their being into doing their best. It takes more from them, and when they’ve reached their goal, they know it was well earned.
His comments made me think about what I believe the purpose of CUNY is-to supply all students with education. Then it’s up to the students to use the opportunity to their advantage.
The students who fought for this right in the past-and those who are fighting for it now-know its true value.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.