A couple months ago, I was reading an Associated Press article on CNN.com (“Texas tries to ease polygamist kids’ culture shock”) about the state of Texas removing about 400 children from a polygamist compound on accusations of sexual abuse. (The children have since been returned to their parents, but a criminal investigation continues.) I was shocked to hear about teenage girls being married to men in their 50s. But I was just as outraged at the author’s view of kids in foster care.
In attempting to highlight the contrast between modern foster kids and these children, who had lived a sheltered life full of prayer and homegrown food, the reporter wrote:
“Many other children in foster care have a certain worldly swagger, and are there because they have used drugs or committed other crimes.”
What?! This is just the latest example of the kind of harsh stereotypes that foster kids face. The thousands of children who are in foster care across the United States are there because their parents were unable to care for them, not because the kids did something wrong. When did the youth in foster care in America become symbols of criminality and drug abuse?
I say this with full awareness that many foster children, after suffering abuse and neglect from the people who were supposed to care for them, do have serious issues. While some of us have overcome our obstacles and triumphed, others haven’t been so lucky-especially when the system has failed to do its part in helping to establish a permanent family and a plan for us. Sadly, the stereotype of foster youth as homeless, runaways, drug abusers and criminals exists because too many of us do face these outcomes.
It’s great that child welfare officials in Texas wanted to try to maintain the “wholesome” lifestyle that the polygamists’ children were used to. But that same concern should be extended to all kids in foster care.
I hope that some day the new stereotype will be the foster youth who has gotten the help they need to find permanency, and has graduated high school and college. I’ll know that change has happened when I can go to a conference and, as a college student, not be described as the cream of the crop. I want to be just another example of a foster care success story.
In the meantime, it would help if reporters could report the facts, not the stereotypes.
-Merli Estime
That Worldly Swagger
Another Media Stereotype of Youth In Care
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.