Teenagers in the System Interview: Robert Little, Commissioner of C.W.A.

Interview by Rick Bullard, Wunika Hicks, and Cartford Wadley
Q. What was your foster family like?
I was in a very special family and that was just the luck of the placement no one could have predicted. The difference in my situation was that my family, my foster family, were friends with my biological family. And so they were able to raise me and help me understand early on that I was a part of a very big family.
As a youngster I used to lord it over the other kids-“You ain’t got but one mama, I got two. Therefore, I’m better than you are.” And when you talk about a large family, there were five foster brothers and sisters in my home, plus my older sister and I…But I also had seven other brothers and sisters who were in other places. So, when I started telling people about my brothers and sisters, I could go on for days…
I was always raised, from the time I was a little kid, to love my biological mother and also to love my foster mother, because I remember [my foster mother] telling me, “You have two mothers who love you. Always remember that your mother is a good woman, she’s my friend.” They didn’t run down my mother or talk negatively about her or anything of that sort…
And both my biological family and my foster family ’til this day are still considered one family… So I feel that I was very fortunate…It’s a little different than how many of our youngsters feel today.
Q. Do you have foster children of your own?
I have a young man who I am very, very proud of. He came with my wife and me when he was about 14, in trouble and all that. He stayed with us through high school. And then he enlisted in the service, he’s a career military man…He’s married, and I have four grandchildren by him.
So, I’m very proud of him. I feel like my wife and I both played a part in helping him get his act together. He was a victim, like many, most, of our children are victims of adult problems…And for a while he blamed himself…
Q. Do your experiences as a foster child influence your work as Commissioner?
Every day.
Q. How?
I find that there are a lot of people who misunderstand foster care and how it feels to be in care. And so when I’m dealing with people who do the budget and the legislature and stuff like that, I can speak with more authority than people who’ve not had that experience.
That’s also one of the reasons that causes me to say, whenever possible, that foster care should be only as short as possible. Now in my personal situation, I didn’t have much choice, because my mother was in a mental hospital and couldn’t get out. But that’s not the case with many families. With a little bit of help, we can get them back together.
And that’s one of the reasons I’m so insistent that we try to provide more work with families. There was very little work done with me around my biological brothers and sisters. I used to hear from the social worker, “If you don’t act good, you’re gonna be in prison like your brother,” that kind of stuff. Not, ‘Hey, your brother is part of you and, regardless, that’s your brother”…They tended sometimes to use biological family problems and situations to try to force you to conform…I think that we can do better than that…
This isn’t just a job…This is part of my life and part of it is to try to give back to the system that I was lucky enough to have gotten through myself. There are a lot of young people that aren’t as lucky as I have been. And the system helped me, even though I didn’t know it was helping me.
Q. What made you choose to be a social worker?
Part of what interested me in social work was the opportunity to help other people…I didn’t feel I was helped by many of the social workers. They treated me like a number. Some of them weren’t on the case long enough to even know who I was. Others, when they were on the case, weren’t doing nothing. When I would complain about what was $10 a month allowance, they said, “Well, that’s the rules” and so on. They wouldn’t try to figure out any way to help me get more.
I had some who were nice, but I don’t remember them. I probably remember those who weren’t so nice more. And I do believe that you learn from both good and bad in life.
So to me, social work is an opportunity to help people. You’ll never get rich in this field because it’s a low paying field. But there’s more to life than getting rich. Every once in a while I have contact with people that I worked with years ago as young people, and I’m the godparent to some three or four of the young people that I had in care. And I feel like I had…something to do with helping them move forward.
Q. Is it ever a burden being the brother of Malcolm X?
Sometimes. And the reason I think it’s sometimes a burden is because…there are a lot of people who didn’t like Malcolm and what he was about and some of the things he said…
And I run into people who expect me to be Malcolm and I keep saying, “I am me.” Malcolm is my brother, but don’t just assume that I’m going to be everything he was or think the way he thought, etc….People expect me to be leading the charge, being out there trying to organize, etc. And again, I have to tell them, look, that’s my brother’s business, I have my own agenda for this life. I respect everything he was about because he was my brother. I didn’t always do everything he did. I didn’t choose to become a Muslim, although Malcolm and four other brothers of mine were all involved with the Nation…
I don’t get any special favors because of him, nor do I expect any. I expect to be judged based on what I do in this life…
See, I don’t view Malcolm as a mythical figure like a lot of people do. He was one of my brothers and I’m glad he did what he did…I miss him, because anytime you experience a family member being killed, it hurts. But I’m glad to see that people are now taking another look at what he was about, because much of what he had to say in 1960 is as true in 1990 as it was then…
He went through a lot of changes. When he was in the street, he was 100% in the street. That was his thing. When he joined the Nation, he was 100% in the Nation. When he left the Nation, he was 100% about what he was doing outside the Nation.
So the lesson that I learned from him is, first of all, you can change if you choose too. Secondly, change is hard, and you can’t expect the things you’re trying to do to be easy, because if they were so easy, somebody else would have already done it.
And the third thing I learned from him is that you got to stand for something in this life, ’cause if you don’t stand for something, you’ll fall for anything…
Q. What are your goals for changing and improving the foster care system?
One, I want to see more children placed with family as opposed to [being placed] with strangers in foster care…I think it makes more sense to keep children with families…and provide support in that situation, rather than sending children all over the place and losing contact with families…
And secondly, increase the number of children who are getting support and services within their own family situations.
I think that foster care is not just keeping a child, it is helping a child develop and grow and explore and learn. And I’m not comfortable with foster care programs that just keep people. You gotta see each person coming into foster care as a gem, not just as a case number…
Q. If you could change one thing about foster care, what would it be?
I would make the length of time children stay in care much shorter…Where there is regular visitation between parents and their children in care, the length of stay is usually shorter…So one of the things that I was concerned about in visitation is that some agencies appeared to discourage a lot of active parent involvement. They had visiting in an office, no privacy.
I felt that visiting ought to be evenings and weekends. Many parents just cannot do all the things they have to do and then schedule a visit for an hour or two in the middle of the day. And for the youngster in foster care, that sometimes requires him to be removed from school in order to do a visit…That s part of why children stay so long [in foster care], is because sometimes the parents get discouraged in trying to work with the agency and the system…
Q. What can be done to improve independent living programs so that kids can leave the system quickly and well-prepared?
I understand that some young people must be prepared to live independently of the family for various reasons. Do we do a good job of that? No. I think that we have got to re-think how we go about preparing people for independent living.
One of the things that I’m trying to do is to develop…what is called supervised independent living situations, particularly for youngsters who do not have families to rely on…I think we got to do a better job preparing people for the work world, not just preparing people to go to college.
[The independent living stipend] we give through the various agencies, a couple of trips to McDonald’s and the movies and it’s gone. There’s really not enough money in that part of the program.
And I think that…independent living has to start earlier~ not just at age 15. Because independent living becomes a way you think about things, not just things that you do, and I think that that is a program area that’s going to require much more input from the young people themselves…
Q. What could be done to improve the quality of staff in group homes?
[Many] of our childcare staff are not well prepared, nor well paid, to do what we’re asking them to do. And so the first thing I would do to try to fix that would be to up the requirements for the people who have the most direct contact with young people. And when I say up the requirements, I’m not talking just about academic, I’m also talking about doing a better job with screening people to know what their attitudes and their beliefs and their ways in interacting with people are…To do good work with young people, you got to be about more than just getting paid, because getting paid is not going to do it.
On the other side, I have to say that…we expect the people who work with our youngsters to be superhuman. In the course of the day, you’re gonna be called everything but the child of God…Somebody is gonna challenge you to control them, or they’re gonna front you, or they’re going to provoke. So…it requires a certain temperament to do the job. And we are in the situation, unfortunately, where we can’t pay the people enough for what we ask them to do…
Q. Many gay and lesbian youth in foster care face hostilities from residents and staff. What can be done to see that their needs are met in placement?
One of the things that we’re trying to do is to develop specialized support services, so that a youngster who says, “Hey, I’m having trouble,” can get help, especially confidentially if they’re not out. And we’re also working with a number of community programs to try to get special services available, so that youngsters can work out problems if they’re running into them…
This is not a problem just in foster care, it’s a problem in every sector in our society. Right now the military has a problem, Clinton’s trying to open up things, and the old military types don’t want to deal with it. And I think our society generally doesn’t want to deal with things like homosexual behavior, etc. They get uncomfortable, maybe because they’re not comfortable with their own stuff.
I know when I was a teenager coming up, there was a youngster, I’m not convinced he was ever gay, because I don’t think he had a lot of experience, but we were on his case every day in one way or another. Walking like he walked, talking like he talked, that kind of thing. And I’m sure we made his life miserable. We were too busy trying to be macho dudes. And I think we were all probably a little bit scared maybe we could be him or something…
We got to make people more aware of what the different sexual preferences and orientations are. And I think we got to also make people more tolerant of differences. See, a lot of people believe that you must think and believe like they do, or something’s wrong with you…
Q. Do you have any advice for residents who want to try to organize to change the system?
First of all, you can speak with more expertise…when you’ve been through something, than when you’re just on the outside looking in. Second thing is, the key is organization. Nothing is more futile than trying to fight a battle without a plan. And without organizing, how you gonna go about it?…
If you’re gonna be thinking about organizing, you also need to understand that foster care is a business, it’s a very large business…Each agency is a business, they get money for providing services and care and all that. But the children in their programs are what generates the money…
When I say that I’d like to reduce the length of stay of every child in care one year, some people say, “Well, that sounds good.” But from a business standpoint, those who run these programs see this as less money. And so they have their ways of resisting trying to do these things…You picked on probably one of the most difficult systems in the world to fix quickly, because of the nature of the thing…
Q. How can policies be changed to help young people in the system?
I don’t believe we ought to remove a child because the family lives in a raggedy apartment. I think it would be money better spent to try to find a way to help that family move into a better apartment, than to just remove the children. If we remove the children, we’re gonna pay $20,000 a year, at least, to keep a child in foster care. And for probably an additional $300 a month, we could relocate the family into a better situation …
Q. If I feel I’m being mistreated by group home staff, what can I do?
I’m glad you asked that. We have within C.W.A. an organization called the Children’s Rights Unit…that number is 212-266-2500…There’s supposed to be a poster talking about the Children’s Rights Unit in every facility…
I have staff who will take your complaints. They will investigate it, they will talk to the agency people, and require the agency to take necessary action.
Let me give you an example of something that came to our attention in a particular facility. The residents in this group home noticed that [allowances] appeared to be short…And they suspected that a staff member was pocketing money that was intended for them. They called the Children’s Rights Unit, the unit investigated by going to that house’s boss and talking about what the issue was, and we required them to start monitoring and watching how the money was being spent. And sure enough, they found out that this individual was misusing the money…
Any child who feels they have been physically mistreated by staff has a right to call this unit. And we have some very strong policies around mistreatment. But if we don’t know about it, we can’t do nothing about it…
Q. Would hanging a kid by his ankles off the second floor of a group home’s fire escape be considered abuse?
Definitely! And the person who did it ought to be fired. That is dangerous, plus it’s unnecessary. And if such a report were to come to me, I would say to an agency, “You have a choice, you either get that person out of there or I’m gonna question whether I want to put any more children in your agency.”
Q. The writers for Foster Care Youth United have been very honest about their situations. Some people in the system might feel threatened or be a little angry about the honesty of the articles. What would be your response to that reaction?
I think any article you do about a problem is always going to upset somebody. That don’t mean you don’t do the article…
You want to be a constructive voice for change and improvement…where people who are having experiences can present them. That’s what making things better is about…
The other thing that I would hope you would encourage, is to think about foster care as something that is. It’s neither good nor bad. I would often not tell people that I was in foster care…’cause I wasn’t sure how they felt about it. They may tease me or whatever, or they may think I did something wrong. And none of the young people in care come into care ’cause they did something wrong. And I think you got to continue to emphasize that fact to your readers-don’t blame the kids! This is not where the problems start…
Many of the kids in foster care are much stronger than the average kid because they’ve been through so much. If you can go through the foster care system, you got some strength just having gotten through it…A lot of people who go through things that are not real positive look back and all they see is the negativity, and sometimes…I have to remind myself that all of my experience wasn’t all bad…

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.