Teen Magazines’ Message to Girls: You Can Be Anything…Except Yourself

Many teenage girls can’t relate to the images they find on the pages of Seventeen, YM, Teen, and Sassy. “All the models are perfect all-Americans with blond hair and blue eyes, they’re all tall and skinny,” explained Carla Hoff, 15, of Midwood HS. “I personally don’t know anyone that looks that way.”
The average fashion model is 5′ 10″ and weighs 111 pounds. That’s more than 30 pounds lighter than most American women and half a foot taller. She’s also White. Flipping through teen magazines you have to search to find a woman of color and, even when you do, she’s likely to be very light skinned.
Roberta Myers, Articles Editor for Seventeen, admits, “A lot of people write in and say ‘You use girls [as models] that don’t look like me, I don’t see myself in the magazine.”‘ But, according to Myers, “Models aren’t supposed to represent readers, they’re presented on fashion pages…showing clothing.”
Elizabeth Granfort, Beauty/Fitness Director for YM agrees. “Models are supposed to be inspirational…We as a culture, we sell a fantasy…people want to aspire.” Aspirations can include fixing our hair a different way or wearing a new shade of lipstick, but it doesn’t always end there.
You’re Supposed To Be Thin
Some girls take it to mean that the only way they can be beautiful and happy is to look just like the pictures in the magazines-even if that means hurting themselves in the process. Some starve themselves (anorexia), force themselves to vomit (bulimia) and have dangerous operations to remove fat and otherwise change their appearance.
“In teen magazines…and on TV [they’re saying] you’re supposed to be thin,” said Mackenzie Cadenhead, 15, of Stuyvesant HS. “I know a lot of people who have been hurt by all the pressure, they are obsessed [with their weight] and get sick.”
“Almost everyone I know has been on a diet and only one of them needs to be,” observed Tara Kilfoyle, 15, also of Stuyvesant HS. “Mentally they have some sort of warped view of themselves.”
A recent survey showed that two out of three women in the U.S. think they’re overweight. But over half of those who do are actually under the healthy weight for someone their height.
If it’s true that teen magazines help make young women feel self conscious and insecure about the way they look, the editors swear that’s not their intention. According to Myers, Seventeen is about “young women making their own decisions…It’s about making women happy.” Granfort feels that YM places “an emphasis on making the most of what you’ve got, [a] feeling of beauty on the inside that you enhance.”
Beauty On the Inside
Both editors point to a number of articles designed to help readers with their deeper problems-what Granfort calls “the service element.” Myers mentioned an article Seventeen ran about girls obsessed with their weight. The article talked about the danger of this obsession and how to overcome it. But she said they received many letters from girls with ads from the magazine attached. “This is the reason I’m obsessed by my weight,” the letters said.
The editors’ response was that the money received from those ads made it possible for the magazine to publish helpful articles like the one in question. The problem isn’t just the ads, however. The editorial content of these teen magazines is overwhelmingly beauty and fashion advice and tips on how to get boys to notice you.
The parts which contain advice about health and relationships; review movies and books; and feature articles on subjects that aren’t beauty-related take up only a few pages and they don’t have the exciting colors and pictures that make the fashion and beauty pages stand out. “They’re really hypocritical,” said Tara. “They have articles about being okay the way you are but none of the pictures look like me…it’s not just the ads…They must think we’re idiots.”
In addition to telling us what we should look like, these magazines also send messages about what teenage girls should be thinking about. Should our concerns about rape, birth control, and our future really take a back seat to the preoccupation with our looks?
“We know what teens worry about,” said Granfort. “They write and ask us about zits and hair trouble. It’s not hard to help them.” I asked Granfort why you never see or read about people like me and my friends in the pages of YM and she was skeptical about whether anyone would be interested in reading about us. But the young women I spoke to didn’t agree. Carla said she thinks it would be interesting “to see the difference between real people and models.”
“People would be able to relate to it,” said Tara, “which would make it more interesting.”

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.