“Would you like to super size that?” is a question most of us are familiar with. Filmmaker Morgan Spurlock heard it nine times during the making of his documentary, Super Size Me.
The film was inspired by two obese girls who had sued the fast food companies for allegedly making them fat. The companies argued there was no proof that their products alone led to the girls’ weight gain.
To put their defense to the test, Spurlock decided to eat nothing but McDonald’s for a full month, do as much physical work as the average American (not much), and see what happened.
Before starting, he was checked by three different doctors. They all said he was in excellent condition, and also warned him not to go through with his experiment. Their warnings were well founded-right from the start things went south.
He threw up on Day 2, after trying to finish a “super size” meal. Weeks later he had bouts of depression when he wasn’t eating. His blood pressure and cholesterol skyrocketed. By the end of the month, one doctor said he was pickling his liver. Maybe worst of all, his girlfriend reported that his performance in the bedroom suffered from the “diet.”
Spurlock also looked into youth nutrition. Reading a school’s lunch menu in one scene, he saw that most meals were made up of junk food.
We here at New Youth Connections watched the film and discussed the issues it brought up about fast food in our own diets. Here are some of our thoughts.
Danielle Morganstern:
I have a love/hate relationship to fast food. It tastes good, but it goes straight to the trouble spots. I eat it fairly often-chili from Wendy’s, fries from Burger King, salad from McDonald’s.
I think Morgan Spurlock made the film because he was sick and tired of turning down a street and seeing a line-up of fast food joints. It’s a bold, informative film that speaks the utter truth.
I knew McDonald’s was harmful to your health, but I didn’t know that you can go through withdrawal from its foods and get depressed when you stop eating it. Ironically, we were all eating fast food while watching the film.
Stephanie Perez:
The scene that stood out the most was when they showed the man getting surgery on his stomach. That was so disgusting!
One thing I learned from the film is that McDonald’s salads aren’t as healthy as they seem. They have sugar in them and they’re more fattening than a Big Mac!
Anna Yakir:
I eat fast food every day. I like the taste and the sugar in these products is addictive.
I think Morgan Spurlock made this film to prove that fast food causes heart disease, liver problems, depression, and weight gain. I like how he was so curious about the ways fast food affects a person that he had enough courage to do a 30-day McDonald’s-food-only experiment.
Tania Morales:
The scene that stood out to me the most was when Morgan Spurlock started to ask the McDonald’s workers about the nutrition of the foods there and most of them didn’t know anything. I was like, “Wow.” Since they didn’t know anything about what they were selling, the customers wouldn’t be able to find out what they were eating.
Miranda Thorsen:
I rarely eat fast food. This past year, I’ve eaten it maybe six times. On the occasion that I do get fast food, I order along the lines of chicken sandwiches only. The whole red-meat thing grosses me out. I think fast food is popular because it’s so convenient. There’s a McDonald’s everywhere you go.
I liked the fact that Morgan risked his health to prove a point to viewers. The scene that stood out the most? When Morgan puked out the car window, and the cameraman took a close up of the vomit. It stands for everything McDonald’s does to you!
Amy Lu:
I think Morgan Spurlock made this film to make more people aware of what they’re eating because obesity is killing people. I like that the film was funny and the songs were catchy. The film has a story so it’s not just a regular documentary.
But I think the movie should have compared the price of eating in McDonald’s with eating a vegan meal, because McDonald’s is so much cheaper. That’s why teenagers go there. One of the McDonald’s in the movie is the one I hang out at with my friends.
But I also love going to Taco Bell. I would literally walk a mile to go to the closest Taco Bell and get a chicken fiesta burrito.
Stephanie Hinkson:
I didn’t really like the film. Although it did give me some vital information about what is really in McDonald’s food, I thought it was irrelevant for Morgan Spurlock do this experiment. It’s obvious that if you go to McDonald’s three times a day for a month, you’re going to gain weight and have health problems. What if something really serious had happened to him, like a heart attack?
Miranda Neubauer:
At one point, Spurlock interviewed a doctor who told a story about a friend at a restaurant who was trying to convince another man at his table that it was unhealthy for him to smoke. However, at another table nearby, a heavy-set woman was sitting, and the doctor wondered what would have happened if his friend had gone up to her and given her a hard time, telling her to stop eating fast food and to not even think about having dessert.
While I’m also very much against smoking, I thought it was interesting how one form of criticism is more socially acceptable than the other.
I think there’s a horrifying lack of education about fast food. With the relentless advertising by fast food companies, people know the jingles for McDonald’s commercials, but can’t say the Pledge of Allegiance.
Zaineb Nadeem:
I think Spurlock made the film because he wanted to make a change in people’s mentality about fast food. I liked the message at the end saying that only we, working together, can put McDonald’s in the graveyard before it puts us there.
But the movie could have done a better job by interviewing other people belonging to different age groups. And instead of making it a documentary, it could have been an actual Hollywood movie where Morgan Spurlock is a character.
Adam Wacholder:
I love fast food, or at least I did. Over the past five years or more (or at least since I’ve been “dietarily” aware), I’ve eaten fast food about once or twice a week. Then I noticed the weight I gained and have since tried to stray away from the stuff.
Morgan Spurlock is a funny guy and he kept the film cute and humorous without sacrificing any of its compelling informativeness. Super Size Me shows that besides being the fattest country in the world, the U.S. is rapidly becoming the stupidest-we’re a bunch of foolish, money-driven jerks.
Actually, it’s the folks spearheading the whole “world domination by way of fast-food” who are the money-driven jerks. The folks inside McDonald’s are the fools.
Kenneth Douglas:
Fast food is popular because of this generation’s values-we want what we want when we want it, and that’s usually right now. we’re always going somewhere, or pretending we are, and handheld food packages are easiest to carry.
A scene that stood out to me was the debate Morgan Spurlock had with his girlfriend. He said he ate meat because he liked it and she tried to show that this was a dumb argument, responding, “Well, I love heroin so I should be able to do it.”
The scene with the liposuction of the guy who drank like 64 ounces of Coke a day also stood out. It was just so real and serious.
Dayan Perez:
I worked in a fast food restaurant called Chipotle. When I worked there, I ate their burritos, tacos and chips along with soda all the time.
Fast food is popular because this is a high-speed country. People are always running around. And because of the advertisements-Americans eat what’s popular, and what they see sells the most.
What I liked about the film was how it showed the real dirt and truth about McDonald’s and what it does to your body if you eat it all the time. The scene that stood out to me the most was when Spurlock threw up after eating his first super size meal, because it showed how they overload you with food that you can’t really eat.
Adrian Nyxs:
What did I like about the film? It was a rude awakening. What did I dislike about it? It was a rude awakening.
Sadia Jahangir:
One scene that stood out to me was when Spurlock showed some children pictures of historical figures like George Washington and Jesus Christ, and they didn’t know who they were. But they recognized Ronald McDonald and the Wendy’s girl. It showed me that most children spend more time eating fast food than reading history books.
What I disliked was Spurlock’s experiment-I was afraid he was going to die. He really risked his life and I don’t think he should’ve done that.
Super Size Me’s McDonald’s Experiment-Gross, Funny, and for Real
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.