Sugar Ray: More Than a One-Man Band

Every time I tell people how much I like Sugar Ray, all I hear in response is a chorus of “Yeah, Mark McGrath is great.” That annoys me a lot because Sugar Ray isn’t a one-man band.
Don’t get me wrong; I think McGrath is amazing. On many of Sugar Ray’s songs, I can hear a yearning and longing in his voice that makes me feel what he’s singing about. But I don’t think it’s fair to the other band members that McGrath gets all the attention.
Listen to the Blend
In fact, what I like most about Sugar Ray is the way the band members complement each other. Each one makes an important contribution to the group’s sound, whether it’s a strong drum beat, a cool sounding guitar riff, a fast bass pattern, a hot sound made from scratching or a sweet-sounding voice.
What makes most of the songs on the Sugar Ray album as good as they are is that Rodney Sheppard, Stan Frazier and Murphy Karges blend so well-with each other and with McGrath’s vocals.
Karges is sensational on the bass guitar. On many songs, it’s the deep bass sound that melds the rest of the instruments together and makes me want to dance.
Give the Drummer Some
Frazier, the drummer, doesn’t just set a beat, he sets a tone that at times evokes emotion. Towards the end of “Sorry Now,” for example, it’s really Frazier who carries the song. His drumming is key and I can’t fathom what the song would sound like without him.
And Sheppard is an excellent guitar player whose riffs give the album an extra edge.
The album Sugar Ray covers a lot of musical ground. You can find rock, alternative, pop and a few songs that don’t fit into one genre. It even has two country-sounding songs, “Just A Little” and “Disasterpiece,” that actually made me start to rethink my immense dislike for all things country.
A Little Bit Country
To me, country music is harmonicas, acoustic guitars and lyrics that don’t completely make sense. “Disasterpiece” fits this basic definition. Take the lyrics, “Ask the devil how he’s been/ And my angel asked me/ Why do you always have to give in?” Am I the only one who has no clue what the lines are supposed to mean?
But it doesn’t matter. Once McGrath starts singing, it’s over, it’s a wrap, and I don’t really care about the country sound or the meaningless lyrics. (I mean, some of the biggest hits on the charts make absolutely no sense.) It got me thinking that maybe, just maybe, country music isn’t so bad.
Regrets Without the Whine
Although the musical styles on the album vary, most of the songs have the same underlying theme. They deal with guys who didn’t know what they had until they lost it or gave it away.
On many of the songs, McGrath sings about wanting an ex-girlfriend back, but he doesn’t carry on about how much he needs her, and can’t live without her. The album’s tone is more reflective than whiny.
My favorite songs are “Answer the Phone,” which has McGrath telling a girl’s answering machine how he wants another chance with her, even though he broke up with her; “When It’s Over,” which is about how, every time he tries to cut himself loose, he sees how much he still loves the girl he’s trying to leave; and “Ours,” about a cheating girlfriend who he thought was so wonderful, and treated so well, only to find out she was cheating on him.
‘You Can Have Her’
By the end of “Ours,” McGrath finally doesn’t want the girl anymore. My favorite part is the line: “She’s mine/ But you can have her/ She’s yours/ I’ve already had her.” I think that anyone who’s ever been cheated on can really identify with this song. In fact, I’m pretty certain everyone can identify with one or more songs on this album.
My biggest problem with Sugar Ray is that it’s too short. I was a bit annoyed when I first realized that the CD was only 11 tracks and 40 minutes long. When I first listened to it, I was in my room, singing along, and could hardly wait to hear the next track, when the CD was over! I wanted more.
Next Time, Include the Lyrics
Another thing that annoyed me is that the lyrics aren’t included in the CD. I hate that and don’t understand why artists do it. I mean, the lyrics are no big secret; eventually people will figure them out. So why not just tell us what they are upfront? Don’t they want us to get them right?
When I first got Sugar Ray, I was singing along to “Answer the Phone” and I thought that one line went, “I remember the way you cut your toes/ On the side of the stage at all our shows.” The line really is, “I remember the way you curled your toes/ On the side of the stage at all our shows.” Oops.
As you’ve probably figured out by now, I think that Sugar Ray is a great CD. In fact, I think it’s one of the best albums I own. I’d recommend it to anyone who likes rock or pop.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.