Students React To ‘Curriculum of Inclusion’

“Page one, page two, page three, And still no signs of me.”
This line from a very stirring song by the Jungle Brothers tells about the alienation many students feel when they are not represented in the history books.
I know what the feeling is like. I was offered a class in African-American studies as an elective in my senior year, and then had it dropped without explanation. When I asked my guidance counselor about it, he simply told me that not enough students were notified that there was going to be such a class, so it couldn’t be offered.
Hopefully, this might change in the future if the State Education Dept. revises the entire state curriculum to include the contributions of all non-European cultures.
Strong Support For Changes
In interviews with students and teachers, I found strong support for the inclusion of non-European cultural studies into the curriculum.
“I’m not satisfied with the history curriculum that I’ve encountered in schools that I’ve gone to, especially in elementary and junior high school,” said Faith Kirkland, 18, from Christopher Columbus HS in the Bronx. “I’ve had to study independently to find out about my own history.”
Teddy Abner, 16, from Adlai Stevenson HS, said that he wasn’t satisfied at all with the African-American courses that he received in school. He was resentful that the state had taken so long to make the curriculum more inclusive.
“None of my schools ever had the course and I think that sucks,” said Lara Gunn, 15, from LaGuardia HS, speaking about African-American studies. “It doesn’t help the kids enter high school with a full knowledge of history.”
Barry Berk, who teaches history and social studies at Stevenson HS, said the state had taken a long time to propose the changes because revising a curriculum is a difficult process.
A revised curriculum “has to be a survey of each of the groups and their historical backgrounds,” Berk said.
What Should Be Taught?
Students had specific suggestions on what the new curriculum should include.
“I want all the real leaders in the African-American community to be spotlighted, such as Marcus Garvey and brothers that were involved with the Black Panthers and the Black power movement of the 70s,” said Abner.
Kirkland said she wanted the new curriculum to include “African-American history, not only on the Civil Rights movement, but also on the Black Power movement of the 60s and 70s, along with important women like Angela Davis and Joanne Chesimard.”
She would like to see slavery discussed, she said, but with emphasis on “the accomplishments made by slaves and the steps they made to free themselves.”
Berk, the social studies teacher, said, “To really appreciate the true worth of each culture, you would really need about two years to teach it. We really need time to examine the roles that cultures have played in our society.”
Does the Teacher Matter?
Students also had suggestions for how classes on cultural history should be taught.
“I don’t want lectures,” said Faith Kirkland. “I would like films…and only books written by people in the movement and no books from the Board of Education.”
Gerard Brown, 18, from James Monroe HS, said that he wanted the class taught “from an angle that explains in detail every culture’s full history.”
When questioned on whether the race of a teacher matters when it comes to classes involving cultural heritage, students gave a variety of opinions.
Aretha Perry, 17, of Brooklyn Tech HS, said a Black teacher would be a little more sympathetic in teaching African-American studies.
Faith said she didn’t care about the teacher’s race “as long as he wasn’t biased.”
“I don’t think that it would matter if he’s Black or White,” said Lara. “It does matter if he had the wrong attitude.”
But Eric Ferrar, 16, from Humanities HS, said he would want a Black teacher to teach African-American studies “because he would know how to break things down in a more personal way.”
Everyone Will Benefit
Every student interviewed said that a more inclusive curriculum would benefit all students.
“I think that it is important for all people to know each other’s culture, so that we can better understand and respect each other,” said Faith Kirkland. “I feel I’ve learned a sufficient amount about White cultures and I’ve benefited from that.”
Lara Gunn said she would be more enthused about school if the curriculum was better balanced. “Being a White person,” she said, “I would be very interested in courses on the histories of other races and cultures.”
Teddy Abner said he’s been interested in learning more about African-American history “but the only way I’ve been able to find out up till now has been my independent study. Learning it in school will help because you get a different view from the teacher.”
Aretha Perry summed it up: “You’ll learn how to relate to other cultures better by studying their background.”
The question now remains as to what will be included in the new curriculum and how it will be taught. Students are well aware of what they want to be taught in class, and will be very offended if they aren’t represented truthfully and extensively in the textbooks-whether they be African, native American, Asian, or Latino.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.