Student Elections at My School: Not Just a Popularity Contest

One day a couple of years ago, two guys came into my social studies class. “Hi, I’m Kamal Latham,” said one of them, “and this is Conrad here. We’re running for the S.O. [Student Organization] for next year because we believe Cardozo needs change.”
He talked about the lack of “school spirit”: how no one shows up at sport games to cheer on the Cardozo teams, how very few participate in Pajama Day, Cardozo Colors Day, or Sex Reversal Day. But he didn’t mention what he was going to do to get rid of this problem.
“If you vote for me, there will be more dances,” he promised. That was the last I heard of Kamal and Conrad.
There were a few campaign posters taped to the walls but the hallways weren’t exactly buzzing about who was going to win the elections. Everyone knew the candidates’ speeches were bullsh-t. In my mind, I had a lasting equation: SCHOOL GOVERNMENT ELECTIONS = POPULARITY CONTEST.
The only people who were going to benefit were the officers-elect, who wrote it on their college applications. The bottom line was simply that nobody cared!
Election Day was pitiful. My homeroom teacher passed the worthless pieces of paper down to each row. The girl in front of me turned around and asked, “Who you voting for?”
Eeny Meeny Miny Moe
“I have no clue,” I told her. I stared at my blank ballot. I then looked around the room and saw everyone playing the “eeny meeny miny moe” game, running their pencils up and down the ballot boxes and waiting to see where on the page the pencil point would land.
Others were peeking at their neighbor’s ballot and voting accordingly. Most of us were sophomores. None of the candidates were popular with us because we didn’t know who any of them were.
I looked back at my secret ballot, folded it, and passed it up to the front of the room blank. “May the most popular candidate win,” I said to myself.
The new school year of 1991-1992 flew by as I had predicted. The only worthwhile thing the S.O. tried to do was establish Student Forums after school once a week, where the students would have the opportunity to speak out and make suggestions. Unfortunately, only a few people came to the first one and we didn’t hear any more about it.
Once again, it came time to choose a new student government for the next school year. This time it was announced that the elections would be totally different.
A Whole New Ballgame
Hoping to improve awareness of the democratic process, the R.J.R. Nabisco Company had awarded Benjamin Cardozo HS a grant. This year’s candidates each had to write an essay on the role of teens in school government or a related topic. They had to attend afterschool workshops on the democratic and campaign process. They were taught all types of strategies and tactics in order to receive the most votes.
Ultimately, five political parties were formed: the Alliance, Genesis, Noo Power, One Gray Matter, and Renaissance.
The campaigning began almost immediately. Parties started to recruit students to help make posters and flyers. Candidates campaigned whenever they had the chance. Some did it during the four-minute class change, early in the morning, after school, and/or during club meetings. By the end of the day, a couple would even start to lose their voices.
On May 5th, they held a “Junior Breakfast” to officially introduce the candidates. Each party talked about how they were formed and why they were running. Although the speakers weren’t allowed to reveal their platform, there was orange juice, cereal, bagels, and plenty of entertainment.
The Renaissance party had a court jester, dressed in a red costume with a colorful hat with bells. He jingled his way to the front of the cafeteria and then Elizabeth Levin, their presidential candidate, announced, “This campaign is no joke.” She informed the crowd that her party was already making things happen. They had supplied the bathrooms with their own toilet paper.
Real Issues
A few days later, we heard each party’s platform. Noo Power said they would “fight for the creation of additional classes and internship programs.” They also wanted to install a salad bar for the vegetarians. Alliance wanted to form a “school court,” where students could protest against rules that they thought were unfair.
The candidates also took a stand on breaking the ethnic barriers that exist at Cardozo. I, personally, was sick of seeing only Koreans hanging out together on the same corner every single day after school. Black students always met near the lockers during class changes and the Chinese only talked among themselves and only in Chinese.
In order to eliminate such scenarios, Alliance wanted to create a “Multi-Cultural Relations Committee” where presidents and representatives of various ethnic clubs would convene, and discuss racial problems. Another party proposed “Ethnic Night” with a combination of food, dance, and different exhibits.
June 2nd was the big day. I received my ballot in my American History class. This time it wasn’t just a scrap of paper. It was a scantron. The votes would be tallied up by computer.
I’d been watching the campaign like a hawk for more than a month. This time I knew who I was going to vote for and why. I turned my ballot over and looked around the room, just like I had a year ago.
The Power of the Vote
Most people were filling in the scantron with a look of confidence. Others held their heads in a pensive manner, trying to decide. It was invigorating to see students actually using their power to vote for what the candidate stood for and not who she was or what she looked like.
The results were announced toward the end of the day. It had been a very close race and the winners came from different parties. Morgan King of the Genesis party was to be the next president.
I couldn’t believe my ears. Although I knew Morgan personally, when it came to public speaking, he seemed to have laryngitis. During the campaign all I heard him say was “I’m Morgan King and I’m running for President. Here’s Kathie (his running mate) and she’ll talk to you now.” But Morgan was the star of the volleyball team and well-liked amongst the many Asians at Cardozo. It seems, after all that, he won due to his popularity.
Other candidates won because of their positions, however. The election didn’t eliminate the popularity factor but it did reduce it. And many more students got involved this time than in previous years. But there are some things that could use some adjusting.
For one thing, freshmen and sophomores weren’t allowed to run for S.O. positions even though the Student Organization makes decisions for the whole student body, including them. When the time came to cast their votes, the majority of the 9th and 10th graders had voted on the basis of who had the most appealing campaign posters.
Not everyone got to meet with the candidates either. There should have been panel discussions or debates to help inform a larger portion of the school.
The elections weren’t perfect but they were definitely a first step in erasing that old equation that had been etched in my mind. As for the newly elected officers, we’ll just have to wait and see.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.