Sticking With Your Own Kind

Even in diverse schools, cultures don't always mix

Here is a scene from a typical day at Brooklyn International HS: At each table in my classroom sits a small number of students from various countries-Mexico, Poland, Bangladesh, Yemen, the Dominican Republic-talking and laughing as they work and help each other.
The teacher yells, “Why am I hearing you talking? Shouldn’t you be working?”
“We work and talk at the same time,” they answer.
When the clock marks lunchtime, they run eagerly out of their classrooms and head for the cafeteria.

Staying With ‘Our Own’

But by the time they reach their destinations, most of the same kids who mixed happily in the classroom have left that spirit of unity behind.
At most of the tables in the cafeteria, you see faces of the same color. Most of the pupils enjoy this time with their own folks.
I thought racism was the reason for this, and part of me still does. But in interviews with students, most say it’s because they just feel more comfortable.
“Teenagers feel more comfortable with their own race because they share similarities and ideas. They don’t have to worry that someone of another race may feel hurt by their comments,” said Salomon Romero, a sophomore from Honduras.
So whoever arrives in the cafeteria first gets her food and spots some seats, then saves a place for others of her race.
Integrated School, Segregated Halls
After lunch, they leave together and spend the rest of the period in the hallways, or outside if it’s not cold.
A group of Polish kids settles on the floor near the main office chatting and gossiping. Sometimes other Polish kids play checkers or dice nearby.
Some of the Dominicans sit in the hall a couple of feet from the Polish kids. Most of the time they talk loudly and sing in Spanish or dance. A little further along some kids from Ecuador or Peru hang out.
The Bengalis gather in one classroom listening to Bengali music and talking. The Haitian girls-the group I am part of-convene next to our counselor’s office, while the Haitian boys assemble on the stairs.
In my school, the students are allowed to roam around freely because the school is small and generally there’s harmony.
People may have their personal disagreements, but groups rarely fight. That doesn’t mean that everybody’s friends, though-they aren’t.
Cyndia (not her real name), a junior from Haiti, never fights with White people, but she doesn’t hang with them either.

‘Why Should I Sweat Them?’

She thinks people should have interracial relations, but, she admitted, “not me, because they treat Blacks with no respect and I’m Black, so that means they’ll treat me the same way, too. So why should I sweat them?”
Of course, there are exceptions to this division. Some teens do befriend people from different races.
One Polish girl often hangs with a Filipina girl, and there are two Black guys-one from France, the other from Africa-who are friends with a kid from Mexico.
“I make friends with people I feel comfortable with, and this comfort can be felt with any race. It is the personality that counts,” said Thibault, the French guy.
I am also one of those people who doesn’t only stick to my own race-although this wasn’t always the case.
I Never Knew Any Whites
When I first arrived here, I had never spent time with any White people.
I lived in Haiti until I was 14. When I saw White people in Haiti, I hated them because I knew that Whites enslaved and mistreated Blacks.
I didn’t know any Whites who considered Blacks equal.
Also, some Haitians said, “Oh, the Whites are so smart!” whenever they saw great things like computers or cars, as if no Black person could invent things, and I hated that.
When I moved to New York, I began to experience being around people of other races. I sat in a classroom and saw all these different kinds of people. I wanted to talk to them-except the Whites.
My friends were Chinese, Honduran and Haitian.
But when I saw the White kids, I said to myself, “I am not going to address these people.” I assumed they were saying the same thing because I am Black.
Gradually my misconceptions changed.
The Beginnings of New Friendship
The White kids at school treated me nicely, and I saw that many Blacks were doing well at my school. It seemed like in New York, whether you are Black or White, you can do great things.
In class, I learned that we all had things in common, and I began to feel comfortable. My friends and I often discussed racism. We thought that teenagers should mix.
As Salomon said, “A lot of people feel uncomfortable because they don’t know each other. They don’t know other people’s culture and background. One way to feel comfortable is to learn about each other and get to share similarities by talking to each other.”
Our culture and skin color differed, but we ignored our differences and got along very well in class.
So it surprises even me that when I returned to school last fall, I stopped mingling with other races and stayed with two Haitian girls. It didn’t happen that way because I was racist, or at least I did not think so then.
My Honduran friend, Daysa, was not back yet from vacation, and most of my old Chinese friends were in other classes.
So every day during lunch, I started going with the Haitian girls.
A Cultural Bond
After Daysa came back, I still spent most of my time with the Haitians. Daysa was speaking with her friends in Spanish, and I was speaking Haitian Creole with my friends.
A shared language and culture are powerful bonds. Diana Xing, an 11th grader from China, said that although she has friends from other races, “I mostly stay with the Chinese, because we have the same culture and we understand each other when we speak our language.”
I didn’t see any problem with this until one day I got to the lunchroom before my two Haitian friends.

‘You’re Buying the Spanish Face’

A friend of mine from the Dominican Republic asked me to sit with her, so I did. When my friends came, they looked at me strangely, but I didn’t react and just said, “Hi.” Then I ate my lunch and talked to the Dominican girl.
Later, when my friends were leaving, they passed and said, “Oh, yeah, Cassandra, you’re buying the Spanish face.” (“Buying someone’s face” is a Haitian expression. It means that you ignore your own race and stay with another one because you think that the other race is superior, and even if that race is disrespectful to you, you still stick to it.)
I laughed and said, “What do you mean I’m buying the Spanish people’s face? Sitting with someone has nothing to do with that.”
Later I talked with one of the girls and I told her that what they did was not fair and that it did not make me happy.
“OK, girl,” she said, and that was it. We were again at peace.
Not Just Jokes
I didn’t take these things too seriously; they sounded more like jokes to me.
But soon I realized they were not jokes.
Later in the year, I began to be friends with a Russian girl named Natasha. We were in the same group in class; she was very nice to me and we became friends.
In class, we always talked to one another, and she often called me on the telephone, but we never stayed together at breaks or lunchtime.
One day my Haitian friends were sitting at our table while I was still standing in line. After I got my meal, I saw Natasha, and she called to me.
“Come sit with me!”
“Oh…I’m sorry. I have to sit with the Haitians or else they would say that I’m buying your face. You know…”
“What?” she said, confused. I explained to her the expression and she said, “OK, I’ll see you later.”
I left her by herself and went to my other friends.
I didn’t want the Haitians to say that about me, so I stopped hanging with people of other races.
Taking a Hard Look at Myself
Sometimes in the morning I still walked around with one of the Chinese guys who was my friend my first year at Brooklyn International.
My friends from Haiti never said anything about that to my face, but another Haitian girl told me, “Cassandra, you love the Chinese too much. You’re buying their faces.”
I laughed and told her that she was wrong. Still, my relationship with other people of other races remained inside the class, because I hated what my Haitian friends said.
The Haitian students mean a lot to me, and I always try to get along with them because they are my people.
And I hadn’t really talked with them about how much what they said bothered me. Because they said it in such a funny way, it was hard for me to see how important it was.
Then I started to write this article, and I began to focus on how we were all acting.
This is how I realized I had become another person, not mixing when I wanted to. And when I realized that, I changed back to who I really am. (Plus, I had a disagreement with one of my two Haitians girls, not related to this, so right now I do not sit with them.)
From Segregation to Integration
Now I stay with Natasha and we are good friends again. In the cafeteria, I sit with her along with my Honduran friend, Daysa, and the Haitian girl I stood with the first year.
Daysa and I are hanging together again after we had a talk about our little division.
This is how I passed from integration to segregation, then back to integration.
I started to mix, but when my own people were there I stuck to them because I felt comfortable, but also for fear of being told, “You’re buying her face.”
I stopped mixing because I was scared of what my friends would think and say.
It’s good to stay with your people sometimes. “It is a way to continue your culture,” Salomon said.
But at the same time, if you only stay with your people, I think you’re being racist (though maybe I am wrong).
We need to break the walls of language, culture and bad past experiences if we want racism to stop. Then we’ll see how hard it is to break an interracial friendship.
Our color, language and culture may differ, but we do share common things that we can only know when we mix.

View the lessons based on this story

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.