“Oh, and send us post cards.”
That’s almost like saying punch me in my belly, not my face, Mr. Muscle Man. Save the scars and bring out the cars so the cop can be here quickly to arrest you.
Lou Diamond Phillips was supposed to be a tough guy character, yet in these times he would be classified as a NERD-spell it with capital letters. This movie (released a while back but recently shown on TV) was supposed to portray a strict teacher who comes into a high school faced with the obstacle of teaching a set of dumb, bad, relentless kids.
The Three Stooges were badder than these kids, who seemed like the type that would learn easily. What a smooth talking teacher Mr. Jaime Escalante was (as portrayed by Edward James Olmos.) But would he really be able to stand up in a public high school today?
Not Real
The movie was supposed to capture the essence of the school system and the tactics that can be used to change it. Olmos is good at acting, especially in the scene when he suffered a heart attack. But I didn’t see what was special about him as a teacher.
There was no real depiction of what goes on today. Where was our friendly neighborhood drug dealer and the kid with the gun or eight inch knife?
So what if he teaches them calculus? Any producer can make a movie with a script in which a teacher teaches kids to learn calculus.
But it takes a good filmmaker to make you see what’s happening today through a movie.
It could be made so real, so believable, that you would phone the principal of a school and tell her that you are sorry for blaming the school system and that it’s also up to you, the parent, to play a part in instilling values in the child.
In “Stand and Deliver” the teacher continually threatens to throw a student, (played by Lou Diamond Phillips) out of a class. Which student would love a class so much that he would practically beg to be in it? None I know. Unless they were learning about sex.
It still isn’t clear why Escalante was pushing so hard to teach all the time. The movie tried to reflect a real life drama that occurred. But it just didn’t capture it realistically. It could have been hyped up some more. “Stand and Deliver” doesn’t deliver.
`Stand and Deliver’ Can’t Hold Up a Stone Pillar
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.