Speak Out On Immigration

FRITZLINE VICTOR, 16, Brooklyn International HS
Born in Haiti
Has lived in the U.S. for six years
Congress is considering a new bill that makes it a felony to be an illegal immigrant. What’s your opinion about that?
“I think that bill is ridiculous, because basically this country was built by immigrants. [Except for Native Americans,] you can’t find somebody who is full-blooded or 100% American in the U.S.”
How would the bill affect you if gets passed?
“It’s going to be hard to have my whole family together. My cousins are in Haiti. We have to fill out a lot of papers, and now it’s going to take longer for somebody to get a chance to come to the U.S.”
Are you happy with the current immigration laws?
“No. Immigrants are the backbone of the economy of this country and have worked really hard to get here. They have sacrificed so many things to be here. I would change the law to include additional help for people who need papers, and I’d also shorten the time for them to get their papers.”
What rights do you think immigrants should have in the U.S.?
“I think they should all have the right to a higher salary, housing advisors to help them get off the streets and, most importantly, they should be treated as humans.
To me, it seems like we haven’t evolved from years ago. First there was segregation of African-Americans. Now there’s discrimination against immigrants.”
JOSE GUEMBES, 17, International HS at LaGuardia Community College
Born in El Salvador
Has lived in the U.S. for six years
Congress is considering a new bill that makes it a felony to be an illegal immigrant. What’s your opinion about that?
“It sucks. Immigrants are like Americans. We built this country.”
What rights do you think immigrants should have in the U.S.?
“I would give immigrants permission to live and work legally in the U.S. so they can feed their families.”
What could you do to help improve immigration laws?
“Attend boycotts and tell people about the bills.”
LUDNIE JACQUES, 16, Brooklyn International HS
Born in Haiti
Has lived in the U.S. for six years
Congress is considering a new bill that makes it a felony to be an illegal immigrant. What’s your opinion about that?
“I don’t think it’s right. As they say, the U.S. is a free country. Everyone should have the right to live their dreams. I don’t think it’s fair to punish somebody who is trying to do that.”
How would the bill affect you if gets passed?
“I have a lot of relatives in Haiti who are suffering. They all dream of coming to the U.S. It’s not right to get punished if you are trying to make your own family dream come true.”
What rights do you think immigrants should have in the U.S.?
“They should have the right to go to school and have an education, which would happen with the passing of the DREAM Act.”
What could you do to help improve immigration laws?
“What I can do is send a letter to Congress to express my opinion about the laws that are being passed.”
IBRAHIM DIALLO, 17, Brooklyn International HS
Born in Guinea, West Africa
Has lived in the U.S. for four years
Congress is considering a new bill that makes it a felony to be an illegal immigrant. What’s your opinion about that?
“I think it’s wrong. People should consider every aspect before making a law. Also, they have to look at how these so-called’illegal’ immigrants benefit the country.”
How would the bill affect you if gets passed?
“It will mentally and emotionally affect me in many ways. And there will be extra security.”
Are you happy with the current immigration laws?
“They’re OK as of now. People can live with or without papers and make a living. But I think the U.S. should not close the borders. Apply a form of security that helps protect Americans and helps outsiders.”
What rights do you think immigrants should have in the U.S.?
“Immigrants and non-immigrants should all have the same rights.”
PRIYAMBADA PARAJAULI, 16, International HS at LaGuardia Community College
Born in Nepal
Has lived in the U.S. for 11 months
Congress is considering a new bill that makes it a felony to be an illegal immigrant. What’s your opinion about that?
“I don’t think that’s right. The government needs people to work for them on their farms and in their factories.”
How would the bill affect you if gets passed?
“It’s not going to affect me, but I respect immigrants and I love them.”
What rights do you think immigrants should have in the U.S.?
“Health facilities, houses, jobs and the right to stay here.”
JIN LONG LING, 18, Brooklyn International HS
Born in China
Has lived in the U.S. for five years
Congress is considering a new bill that makes it a felony to be an illegal immigrant. What’s your opinion about that?
“I think that the bill should not be passed.”
How would the bill affect you if gets passed?
“It will affect my friends and family, but it won’t affect me.”
Are you happy with the current immigration laws?
“I’m not really happy because people who come here are just trying to make money. The government should give them a chance.”
What rights do you think immigrants should have in the U.S.?
“The same rights as U.S. citizens.”
CAROL HURTADO, 16, International HS at LaGuardia Community College
Born in Colombia
Has lived in the U.S. for six years
Congress is considering a new bill that makes it a felony to be an illegal immigrant. What’s your opinion about that?
“It’s worst for those who are introducing it, if they think that being illegal is a felony. They need workers to work for them. I think immigrants should have minimum wage. we’re asking for the same rights and respect as an American worker.”
Are you happy with the current immigration laws?
“No, they don’t have respect for immigrants. [Employers] are taking advantage of undocumented immigrants by paying them too little money. [The government] should make those who pay taxes legal.”
What rights do you think immigrants should have in the U.S.?
“Benefits like insurance, minimum wage, and if they’re paying taxes, they should get tax refunds.”
What could you do to help improve immigration laws?
“Have an active presence. I’ve attended conferences and rallies. I’m teaching everything that I know, see and learn. I know it’s a very small contribution, but it’s important.”

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.