“The people’s patience is not endless. The time comes in the life of any nation when there remain only two choices: submit or fight. That time has now come for South Africa.”
-Nelson Mandela
South Africa is a land rich in gold, diamonds, and other natural resources given as gifts from nature. The sun glistens almost year round over its fruitful ground. The beauty of its exterior might lead one to see it as a paradise.
The painful irony is that South Africa is a country with racism enshrined in its constitution, whose government policy for the past 35 years has been in a word, genocide: the annihilation of a race of people. It has used deliberate, systematic measures to oppress South Africa’s non-White majority, which comprises more than 83% of the population.
The imprisonment, torture, and execution of fighters against apartheid, the jailing and torture of Black children, curfews, pass laws, and detention camps have all been used or continue to be used by the South African regime in its effort to keep alive its system of White supremacy.
Mandela’s Role
In light of the recent release of Nelson Mandela after 26 years of imprisonment, a renewed sense of hope has come over the people of South Africa and the rest of the world about the prospects of freedom for all South Africans.
Speaking with young people about Mandela, I found that many did not know why the South African government sentenced him to life in prison in 1964.
With his release, it is important to reflect back on the reasons for his imprisonment and on the struggle against apartheid.
Mandela was arrested on July 11, 1963 on a farm in the town of Rivonia, a few miles outside of Johannesburg. He and 10 other men were accused of conspiracy to overthrow the government and other trumped-up charges. Mandela faced 193 counts of security violations.
A practicing lawyer, he refused to be represented by counsel or be cross-examined. As he took the stand on April 20, 1964, he made the following statement:
“During my lifetime, I have dedicated myself to this struggle of the African people. I have fought against White domination, and I have fought against Black domination. I have cherished the ideal of a democratic and free society in which all people live together in harmony and with equal opportunities. It is an ideal which I hope for and live to achieve. But if need be, it is an ideal for which I am prepared to die.”
Two months later Mandela, along with seven other co-defendants, was convicted and sentenced to life in prison. Mandela served 26 years of his sentence until he was released Feb. 11.
“It [Mandela’s release] has been a crucial moment, a high point of our liberation and struggle,” said Feluk Phirwa, an assistant to the chief U.N. representative of the African National Congress [ANC], an anti-apartheid organization, which was recently legalized for the first time by the South African government.
“Reaction of the democratic majority has been one of jubilation and celebration. However, the reaction of conservatives has been negative…not as positive as would be expected,” said Mr. Phirwa.
Violence vs. Nonviolence
Phirwa said that the goals of the ANC are “a united democracy, a non-racial, non-sexist South Africa.” He said much more needs to be done to make South Africa free.
“The ANC demands the release of all political prisoners,” he said, “the removal of police from the townships, pardons for people on death row, normalization of the political situation so people can mobilize opinions freely…We insist that the state of emergency be lifted…and that police brutality and other oppressive measures be stopped. We think that they [the South African government] have no choice.”
Although the ANC has been legalized, the South African government has insisted as a prerequisite for negotiations that the ANC renounce violence and abandon its demand for majority rule.
In a letter to former South African president P.W. Botha, Mandela made the following statements from prison last July:
“It is perfectly clear that the refusal of the ANC to renounce violence is not the real problem facing the government. The truth is that the government is not ready for negotiation and for the sharing of power with Blacks. It is still committed to White domination…This is the real reason for the government’s refusal to talk to us, and for its demand that we disarm ourselves while it continues to use violence against our people.”
Mandela has said that the ANC is against any action which may cause loss of life. However, the organization believes that armed struggle is the only form of self-defense against a government which does not even allow peaceful forms of protest.
In his statements, Mandela concluded: “A government who has used violence against Blacks many years before we took up arms has no right whatsoever to ask us to lay down arms.”
Sharpesville Massacre
The debate between armed struggle and nonviolent struggle is a legitimate one. The ANC believes that despite recent changes made by South African president de Klerk, armed struggle is the only way that Blacks in South Africa will be free. Nonviolent methods have not been proven to be effective or have been crushed by South Africa’s military.
“Armed struggle is what got us here and we are not about to abandon it now,” said Phirwa. “We have waged a nonviolent struggle…from 1910-1960. We know the commitment and consequences of nonviolent change. Nonviolent struggles are still being conducted-strikes, rent boycotts.”
But we should be reminded of the nonviolent protests in Sharpesville in 1960 and Sowetoin 1976.
Robert Sobukwe, the man who planned the march through Sharpesville, appealed to the demonstrators that they conduct themselves in the spirit of absolute nonviolence as they protested pass laws. Pass laws required Black people to carry passes or i.d. cards.
(In South Africa, Black people are still required to carry identification at all times. These papers state whether a person is allowed to live with their family, and where she is permitted to work. If a person is unable to produce the identification upon police demand, she will be arrested on the spot).
Nevertheless, the police opened fire on the large crowd of peaceful protesters. It was later discovered that most of the victims were shot in the back as they fled. The final toll: 69 dead, 180 wounded.
The Sharpesville demonstration had no impact on changing the pass laws. It was instead a “massacre” of innocent Black people by the police.
Soweto Protests
The march through Soweto occurred June 16, 1976 at seven a.m. Hundreds of students attended the march, which was organized to protest their being taught in Afrikaans-the language of their oppressors. They wanted to be taught in their own native languages.
The children carried slogans, and pamphlets were given to parents which read: “You should rejoice for having given birth to this type of child…A child who prefers to die from a bullet rather than to swallow a poisonous education which relegates him and his parents to a position of perpetual subordination.”
Before the march was two hours old, the students had been informed that the police were coming. Within minutes, a contingent of police cars and vans had arrived and blocked the crowd. The students began to sing “Morena Boloka Sechaba sa heso” (God Save our Nation).
Many students were killed and injured by the police, and hundreds were killed in the violence that continued for days.
After the incident, South African Justice Minister Jimmy Kruger accused the young people of being communists. “Surely this is the sign of the Communist Party,” he said, speaking of the protesters’ upraised fists.
Role of Youth
Phirwa said that the young people of South Africa have continued to be a force in the movement for freedom.
“They are the engine of the struggle. They…act as leaders in many aspects of the movement. There is no activity that does not involve the youth,” he said.
When I asked Phirwa what people in the U.S. could do to help in the movement, he said support of South African democratic movements in the U.S., and of community groups and organizations that support the anti-apartheid cause would be helpful.
According to Phirwa, there are currently close to 1,000 political prisoners, 4,000 people under detention (house arrest), and about 60 opponents of apartheid on death row in South Africa.
So we must understand that the release of Nelson Mandela has not meant the end of apartheid. The struggle for freedom continues. Although the ANC has been legalized, Blacks are now allowed on some beaches, and interracial marriages are no longer banned, Mandela still does not have the right to vote in his own country.
We must continue to keep pressure on the South African government so that other political prisoners who are vitally needed in the struggle can be freed, so that we can, once and for all, see an end to apartheid.
South Africa Is Not Yet Free
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.