Social Workers: The Good, The Bad, The Overworked

In all my years in foster care, I’ve gone through three social workers-Ms. J, Mrs. M and Mr. F. In my opinion, the first two were good social workers and did their job well, but this last oneâI don’t know.
My first social worker, Ms. J, was a wonderful person. She was a young, caring woman who was concerned about my needs. She came to my house at least once every two weeks, and she called regularly. Most of the time she called just to talk. She would ask how I was doing at home, in school, or see if I needed help with anything. I thought of her as family.
She used to take my sister and me out to dinner and sometimes she would come over to our house for dinner. She always said if we had any problems or needed her for anything, then all we had to do was call.
A New Worker
She was such a sweet lady, and it broke my heart when, after four years of being my social worker, she had to leave. I knew I would never have another social worker like her. Boy, was I right!
When Ms. J left, Mrs. M became my new social worker. She wasn’t Ms. J, but she was okay. At first, I didn’t like her. Now I see that it was partly because she wasn’t Ms. J. I thought she was way too nosy, though I guess she was only doing her job.
She came to my school like once a week. I’d be sitting in my elementary school class and look out the door. Guess who I’d see? Mrs. M waving and mouthing, “I’m just checking up on you!”
The Same Old Questions
And whenever she came to the house, the first thing she’d say was: “Can I please use your bathroom?” I don’t think she even had to go to the bathroom. She said that so she could take a quick look around the house. (You have to pass every other room to get to the bathroom.)
During her third and final year as my social worker I started to like her, but it was too late because as soon as I started liking her, she got pregnant and had to leave (darn!).
When Mrs. M left, that was it. I got stuck with the worst social worker ever, Mr. F. He’s been my social worker for years now and, if you ask me, he should have sought another profession-he’s not mastering this one.
Besides the fact that I can’t understand a word he says, here’s the list of problems I have with him:
1. He barely comes around for visits. You should see your social worker at least four times a month at your agency, if not more. I see Mr. F about once every two to three months. What’s that about?
2. He doesn’t listen. On those rare occasions when I do see him, he asks me the same questions: “What school do you go to? How old are you?” and, get this, “How do you spell your name?”
He’s been my social worker for a couple of years now and he doesn’t even know how to spell my name! Judging by his inability to listen, he’s definitely not someone who I would pour out my feelings to.
3. He’s L-A-Z-Y! Sometimes he’s supposed to come by the house to pick up papers that he needs, and he won’t show up. Instead, he’ll call my grandmother and ask her to mail them. And get this-he has a car! He could easily drive himself on over and pick them up!
4. He’s disrespectful of our time. He’ll call and say he’s coming over for a visit at a certain time, say 4:00 p.m. We’ll be rushing to get home from school to make sure that we’re there on time. And guess what? Mr. F will never show up, and he won’t even call to say he’s not coming.
Overworked?
Usually he’ll call the next morning and tell us we have to come down to the office. I remember one time he did that and there was about four feet of snow outside. My grandmother had to drag all of us, even my younger brother who has asthma, out of the house in the cold weather to go see him.
I don’t know what the problem is with him. Maybe he feels overwhelmed by all the work he has, or maybe he feels that he’s doing his job the best way he knows how. So I was curious to find out other foster kids’ experiences with their social workers. Did they have good ones, like Ms. J? Or bad ones? What do they like in a social worker?
Through interviews, I found out that I’m not the only one in foster care who believes her social worker is not doing a good job. Milagros, 14, who lives in a foster home in Manhattan, has a social worker almost as bad as mine. Milagros said she sees her social worker only once a month at her foster home, and her social worker only calls about once every two months.
Room For Improvement
Milagros said that she sometimes gets along with her social worker but whenever she tries to explain something to her, her worker will always argue. “She’s very busy most of the time and doesn’t have time to discuss,” said Milagros. “She got a grouchy attitude and she hardly knows how to communicate.”
Ivon, 15, who lives in a foster home in Brooklyn, has also had some bad experiences with workers. About her current social worker, Ivon said, “This lady is supposed to be sending me money and she never sends it and she doesn’t look out for me or make sure that my foster mother is doing what she’s supposed to.”
Ivon says she only sees her social worker when she goes to her agency for her independent living program.
Ebony, 15, who lives in a foster home in the Bronx, said that her current social worker is not doing such a good job because she’s not trying to help Ebony’s mother get her children back. Ebony says her worker is wasting time on finding the things that her mother does wrong instead of what her mother does right.
Good Experiences, Too
Although these kids have had bad experiences with social workers, they have also had good experiences and have had social workers like Ms. J. All of them have had more than one social worker and said that at least one of their workers did her job well.
Ebony has gone through two social workers. Although her current social worker isn’t doing a good job, her first worker, Ms. V, did. “If we did something wrong,” Ebony said, “she’d tell us to do better. Like if our grades were low, she’d tell us to aim higher. She always tried to help my mother get us back, and when she wasn’t there on visits, she would call an hour early to let us know not to come.”
Sound Advice
Milagros, who’s going on her fourth social worker, agreed that her first social worker, whose name she forgot, and her second social worker, Rafael, had done a good job. “They were nice,” she said, “they explained everything-the new neighborhoods, how it’s gonna be when you’re in foster care, what stages I’m a be going through with the foster parents, if there’s any problems to call them, and the [agency] regulations.”
Joselyn, 17, who lives in a foster home in the Bronx, says that her social worker, Yudelca Mateo, who until recently worked for Talbot Perkins Children’s Services, was an excellent social worker who taught her and helped her a lot. But Ms. Mateo left her job as a social worker and Joselyn said she’ll miss her dearly.
Joselyn said, “She always had time for me and also she knew how to take her time with me. She had patience. She knew the way that I was, so she knew the things she could tell me. For example, when I had a problem or when I used to get stressed out, she used to give me advice like how to control my anxiety and also how to solve my problems.”
The teens I spoke with have had both good and bad experiences with social workers, and, therefore, know what it takes to be a good social worker. They would like to give some advice to social workers, so if there are any social workers reading this article, maybe you can follow some of these tips (if you’re not already doing so).
I feel all foster children would agree with Milagros’ advice. Milagros said that social workers “should be nice when kids are nice. They should start believing foster children, too. They always be like, ‘Oh, that’s not what your foster mother said.’ Me and my foster mother is two different people! Hello!”
Ebony also has some good advice. She said, “No matter what the parent did, [social workers] should always try to get the true story and then help the parents get their children back.”
Listen, and Be Heard
Jocelyn’s words to her social workers are, “I’ll always appreciate the way they helped me recover from my problem, and that the same way they helped me, I wish that they also could help others and keep up with the patience that they have for foster kids.”
Social workers are there to help the foster kids. That means they should listen to what the kids tell them, have patience with them and take the time to help them with their problems. When social workers take their time and listen to their clients, their clients take the time to listen to them.

SIDEBAR: A Social Worker’s Point of View
After writing about teens’ experiences with social workers, I wanted to get a social worker’s point of view. So I interviewed Yudelca Mateo, who used to work for Talbot Perkins Children’s Services and who was Joselyn Disla’s good social worker mentioned in the previous article. Talking with Yudelca, I found that she is the kind of social worker all foster children need. At the time of our interview, she had about 13 clients and was willing to listen to them and make herself available to them at all times. She’d sacrifice a stack of paperwork to listen to problems that her clients had, and tried her best to reunite families and teach her clients what they would need to know in the game of life. Since Yudelca has left her agency, I know her clients must miss her. Here’s what she had to say:
Shanikqua: How often do you have contact with your clients?
Yudelca: I visit them at their home every three months and they’re supposed to have visits at the agency four times a month. My clients come to the agency 14, 15 times in a month. I call each one biweekly, sometimes every other day.
Shanikqua: Do all of your clients know who you are?
Yudelca: Oh, yes, they do, very well. I make myself available to them so much that there’s hardly time for the paperwork. That’s why I have to work late. I make myself available to them by being at the office, by having access to a phone, by letting them know that I’m here. One of my clients, she calls me once in a while crying. She’s very frustrated and upset and I say to her, “I’m busy with paperwork, but I’m gonna see you anyway. What’s wrong? Where are you, so I can come and bring you down to the office.” I let my clients know they can come to the agency and talk to me. I won’t judge them, I won’t think bad of them, but I will support them. I’m more than a buddy, I’m a friend. I listen to my clients and show them that I’m a good listener.
Shanikqua: What are some of the things you do for your clients?
Yudelca: Whew, everything! I make referrals to counseling, to GED programs, medical places at times. I make them feel comfortable. They look at me as someone they can relate to, talk to, like I’m their older sister, I would say. I visit their homes, schools, talk to their teachers, prepare housing applications for them. We go on trips to places like Yankee Stadium and Shea Stadium. It’s so much that I do. I provide them with information on family planningÉSTDs, HIV, unwanted pregnancies and teen parenting classes. I also set up their treatment goals, help them plan for the future. I take them to welfare departments. I encourage them that education is a number one priority. Education is the key. Whether college, vocational program or any type of skill that you learn, education is the key to independence, to getting that job and to earning that income.
Shanikqua: What are some of the difficulties social workers deal with? How do you deal with them?
Yudelca: Having a child removed from their teenage mom. Having to transfer from one foster mother to another with all their belongings, boxes of shoes, boxes of books, 10 bags of clothes. Moving dressers, cribs, taking them apart. Oh, God, I’ve had the whole experience. You see some foster parents crying, some not. Foster children happy to be leaving the foster home but scared at what they may encounter at the new home. Another difficult thing is not having sufficient or enough resources to provide quality care for the children. I breathe heavily three or four times. Take a big breath. I deal with it by not giving up. I’ll continue to reach out. Make as many phone calls as I have to until I can find the service that will best suit my client’s need.
Shanikqua: What would you like foster kids to know about social workers?
Yudelca: That social workers like myself work very, very hard. Work overtime to plan on a daily basis for the lives, for the future of children who are in foster care. I would say that social workers are not valued as they should be and that we need lots of support from the people we work with, from the agencies outside. And we must all work together as a team in order to fulfill the first goal, which for me is to reunite families and provide them with the services they need to become independent from the system. Social workers need to be given more recognition and need to be financially rewarded for all the hard work and for their efforts in trying to save families.
Shanikqua: Are you leaving the agency, or are you leaving social work in general?
Yudelca: I’m going to be working for the New York State Department of Probation. You see, I graduated from John Jay College of Criminal Justice not realizing that my true call was social work. It was hard for me to make that move, to say goodbye to my clients now that I’m leaving the foster care system, but they’ll take with them all the good memories. A little piece of me is gonna stay with them.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.