Slum Village: Worth a Return Trip

“Experimentation” and “originality” are words not usually associated with most of mainstream hip-hop today. In an era of gold chains and ice, SUVs and easy women, few rap acts go outside the realm of celebrating their wealth and bragging about how hard they are and what record label they’re signed to. (It’s Murder!)
One of the few that do is Slum Village, a Detroit-based rap trio once made up of lyricists T3 and Baatin, and producer/rapper Jay Dee. With their first major label debut, Fantastic Vol. 2, Slum Village drew praise for their originality, despite some moments of sub-par lyrical flow. Jay Dee’s beat-making dominated that record, with his rhythms overshadowing the rhymes.
On their recent release, Trinity (Past, Present and Future), Jay Dee works on only a few tracks; RJ Rice and Timothy Maynor produce most of the album. And in place of Jay’s rhyming is lyricist Elzhi, who’s often a much better wordsmith than Jay Dee and the other group members.
Covers Record Industry and Ghetto Life
Trinity continues Slum’s trademark of going against mainstream hip-hop’s predictable samples and lyrics. Discussing subjects from the money-hungry ways of the record industry to the struggles of ghetto life, the album doesn’t cover groundbreaking territory; still, its themes are refreshing to hear in light of all the female-bashing, party-high-and-hard ways of other lyricists.
The album attempts to maintain a theme based on where Slum’s members have been, are, and will be. Yet the past, present and future gimmick only leads me to hope that the future holds stronger rhymes.
T3, Baatin and Elzhi have very diverse lyrical deliveries, with Elzhi’s sound having the most fluidity. T3’s rhyming feels forced at times, as if he has to make sure he’s being heard. Baatin’s voice is noticeably different, and he has a slightly slower, higher-pitched delivery.
On some songs, this mix of different MC styles works, like on the head-nodding “Get Live.” But in some instances, T3 and Baatin’s rhymings sound awkward alongside Elzhi’s more relaxed flow.
And sometimes the lyrics seem flat: “I was just chilling on my living room floor/ Looking at you, doing Tae-bo,” from “Hoes.”
Strength in the Beats
Trinity’s strength is in its original beats. RJ Rice and Tim Maynor keep heads nodding. From the catchy drum tempos of “S.O.U.L.” to the use of synthesizers and fade-outs in “Lets” to the touches of techno in “Trinity” and “One,” the album has distinctive instrumentation interlaced with looped drum beats and DJ scratching.
Other standouts include the fast-paced drum beat of “Disco,” the catchy, chanted chorus of “Harmony,” and the first single, “Tainted,” a smooth, head-bobbing ode to wanting honesty and real love.
Trinity isn’t the strongest work Slum Village is capable of. The album’s not for those looking for clever or deep, introspective rhymes.
Yet the group’s willingness to go beyond the predictable makes the disc worth a listen. Slum Village may not yet be the best of “alternative hip-hop” (see Common, Dilated Peoples and the Roots), but still offers a pleasant taste of what more of hip-hop could be.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.