Slammin’ Poetry at the Nuyorican Cafe

The Nuyorican Poets Cafe was not what I expected. I imagined it would be a small room, with lots of tables and a small podium, where people would just leap up and spout out bursts of spontaneous poetry.
I had also heard that they did something called a poetry “slam.” I didn’t know what that was but I figured that it would be thoroughly disorganized and entertaining.
Boy, was I wrong. The cafe turned out to be more like a club than a coffeehouse and it was super organized. It was fun, though.
My friend and I paid the big bouncer the $5 cover and walked past the bar to an area where there were tables, some open space, and a narrow stage against one wall. Loud club music was playing. We got ourselves settled, and I checked the place out. High ceilings, brick walls, abstract Picasso-type paintings on the wall and, over the bar, a multitude of Cabbage Patch dolls dressed as homeboys and homegirls. The crowd was very mixed in terms of age, race, and personal style, although at this point (about 10:30 p.m.), it was mostly adults.
Rating the Poets
This guy in a red blazer came over to us, introduced himself as the host, and asked if we wanted to be judges in the poetry slam. We said sure, if he would tell us what a poetry slam was. He explained that a slam is when a few poets get up, read poetry, and a bunch of pre-selected judges from the audience rate their work on a scale of 1 to 10 (decimals are allowed). After a few rounds, the person with the most points wins. Simple concept-even we could handle it. The host gave us a stack of index cards and a magic marker. We squealed in excitement and anxiously awaited the chance to be literary critics (mean b-tches).
Before the slam started, there was a 15 minute reading and a dance break. The lights went down, club lights started flashing, and the music was cranked up. I was not in a dancing frame of mind and went to get a drink. We had coffee-a dollar a cup, no refills.
And then the moment arrived. It was time for the slam. We started getting nervous. What if we didn’t get what they were saying? We needn’t have worried. One of the poets did a funny piece about fingers, and how not to lose them, but where was the poetry? (He was out by round two.) The second was a feminist who expounded on the topics of rape and Barbie dolls, but where was the meaning? The last poet appeared to be reading from a book, but he would start singing and adding sounds (like moans and grunts) that couldn’t possibly have been written down. We thought that he was far too simplistic.
We didn’t think much of any of the poems, and began suffering from an acute case of guilt, because we were scoring them so low. We were giving scores no higher than 8, whereas other judges had already given out several 10’s. But we had a great time judging, even if we didn’t love any of the poets. The place had gotten really crowded and there were a lot of other teenagers by this point.
Anyone Can Take the Mike
The slam ended and Ms. Rape and Barbie Dolls walked away with the Grand Prize-$10. We decided to stick around for the Open Mike, when anyone can just get up and read their poetry without being judged. You just have to sign up that night, and you can only read one poem at a shot.
This was more like what I had expected the whole night to be. The atmosphere changed; it seemed to become more serious. A lot of people left after the slam, and the people who stayed seemed to be “regulars.” The poetry that followed was, for the most part, excellent-much better than the slam poetry. Then the New York Hack Poetry Society, a group of cab-driving poets, sent one of its members to the mike. He was wearing a mask, and called himself “The Prince of Cabbies.” His poem was all about (surprise!) being a cab driver in New York. It was amusing and really, really long. And then another guy got up and did the same type of thing. We were halfway out the door by the time the third cabbie got to the mike. There’s a limit to how much rhyming whining you can take from a cab driver.
I was surprised by the Nuyorican Poets Cafe, but I still had a really good time there. It’s a good place to go for a unique night. And if you’re a poet, you might get discovered.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.