Singled Out

Singled Out

“Fear and insecurity are the biggest challenges that I have to face because of my immigrant status,” said Ibrahim (not his real name).
Ibrahim, 18, came from Yemen at age 12. Ibrahim overstayed his visa, and doesn’t have a green card to live in America legally. Yet he has managed to hold down a job at a grocery store to help support his family.
Ibrahim isn’t sure how long he’ll be able to stay here because of a U.S. government policy that requires immigrants from certain countries to register with immigration offices.
Certain Countries Singled Out
Starting in November 2002, people from 25 countries thought to be the highest terrorism risks have been required to go to immigration offices to be fingerprinted and photographed. Most countries on the list have a majority Muslim population, like Pakistan, Bangladesh, Indonesia, Algeria, and Saudi Arabia.
Male immigrants with U.S. visas (including international students) or whose permanent resident status is pending are required to register. So are undocumented immigrants. Women, green card holders, naturalized citizens, children under 16, and those who were granted political asylum are not required to register.
Once immigrants have registered with authorities, they must wait to see if the government will allow them to stay or send them back to their countries. According to an April New York Times article, more than 2,300 illegal immigrants have been held by authorities.
Having to Wait
Ibrahim went to immigration offices at the beginning of January. Once there, he felt weird and scared because he didn’t know what was going to happen to him.
“They asked me personal questions, like how long I have been in this country. With who? Why?” he said. Then they took his passport and told him that they’d send him papers which would tell the date that he should return to their offices.
Ibrahim knows other members of the Muslim community who are waiting to hear what the government’s decision will be. “They are scared about what’s going to happen next and how they are going to support their families,” he said. “This program is violating our human rights.”
Ibrahim feels that law-abiding Muslims are being singled out and that the real terrorists are not going to voluntarily show up at immigration offices. “I wonder if I stay any longer, if I’ll have to wear a sign on me that says, ‘I am a Muslim and Arab,'” he said.
Considers Himself an American
Still, Ibrahim wants to remain here because he’s lived in New York for almost seven years, and considers himself an American. He has many friends here and wants to take his GED. He has dreams of being a mechanic. “I want to be able to fix cars and air conditioners,” said Ibrahim.
Ibrahim’s faith has helped him deal with the uncertainty of his status. “I fear no one except God,” he said, and is proud to be a Muslim.
Even immigrants with proper documentation have experienced fear about living in the U.S.
“Sometimes, I feel insecure because I am Arab and Muslim,” said Nasser Almasri, 18, who came here from Yemen when he was 16. “But I feel more comfortable to ask for help [from police] than Arabs with no papers.”
Legal Immigrants Worried Also
Although none of Nasser’s family had to go to immigration offices because they either have green cards or are citizens, he thinks that the registration law is unjust.
“The new registration law makes many difficulties for the immigrants who came here to have a better life, to support their families, and gain more education,” said Nasser. He fears that government action could soon be taken against immigrants who are here legally.
“I am afraid that Arabs and Muslims with papers could be kicked out from this country any minute,” said Nasser. “Since September 11, Arabs and Muslims with papers and with no papers are the same in Americans’ eyes.”
As a result, Nasser feels that his life in the U.S. has changed. Before 9/11, he considered America his second country. But after 9/11 and since the registration appeared, Nasser, who teaches 5th graders in an after-school program, feels like he can’t think about his future career and dreams, which I can understand.
I’m originally from Yemen as well. Although I am here legally, I fear that I won’t be able to fulfill my dream of becoming a pharmacist because there’s no telling what new policies may arise that could single out Muslims even more.
“I know some people who have papers, but they left this country since the registration law appeared,” Nasser said. Rather than getting kicked out by the government, “they said they wanted to leave this country by themselves, with their dignity.”

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.