Before last spring, I wouldn’t have thought that the words “fun” and “garbage” could go together. But learning about garbage ended up being lots of fun because I got to make a film about it. I soon learned how connected garbage was to things I hadn’t thought about, like politics, jobs-and everyone’s life.
I go to City-As-School, where we have hands-on internships in different places. That semester, Andre Knights, my resource (internship) coordinator approached me with an internship at the Center for Urban Pedagogy (CUP), a nonprofit organization that produces educational films about New York City’s environment and the way decisions get made about the city’s development.
Garbage Is Cool?
Andre told me and the seven other City-As interns at CUP that we’d be working on a documentary film about garbage in Staten Island.
“It’s going to be real cool,” he said. “You get to use the mini-dv [mini-digital video] camera to film things. You get to interview a lot of people, do the editing and voice-overs.”
“Garbage?! We’re doing a documentary about garbage?!” said Justyna.
“Sounds stupid!” said Brandon.
I just smiled and nodded, because Andre was really excited about the whole thing. But I also thought no one would want to hear about garbage.
I love filmmaking, though. I’d already done film and video work in an internship with Global Action Project helping other teens make documentary films. And the more I learned about the garbage project, the more interested I became.
Looks Pretty, Smells Nasty
For more than 50 years, most of New York City’s solid waste found its final resting place at Fresh Kills landfill on Staten Island. The plan was to dump just enough garbage to fill the swamp so that the land could be used for housing and light industry. But the “temporary” dump stayed open, and grew higher and higher.
Diapers, banana peels, old math notes-you name it, it all went down to Fresh Kills. When we went to see it, I have to admit it didn’t look how I expected. It actually looked beautiful, a big rounded hill or mountain covered with lush green grass, even daisies popping up here and there.
But it smelled like left-over-month-old-Spaghettio-surprise in the back of the fridge. The people who worked around the dump, like at the local gym and car sales lots and the mall, hated it when strong winds came because they’d smell it. “It’s bad for business,” they told us.
Giuliani Shut the Dump Down
Staten Island residents complained. So when Rudy Giuliani campaigned for mayor in 1993, he told residents that if he was elected, he’d close Fresh Kills. They voted for him, he won, and the dump finally closed down under Mayor Giuliani in March 2001.
That left New York City with the question: Where will all the garbage go?
Currently, most of our gar-bage is being trucked to landfills in Virginia and Pennsylvania. But we found that the expense of transporting the garbage and paying other places to take our garbage costs New York City $323 million a year-more than three times the amount it cost to dump the garbage at Fresh Kills.
Other states, like New Jersey, don’t like our garbage going through their towns. And some Pennsylvania residents don’t want to have more garbage on their land.
Incinerators Polluted the City
A different option for dealing with New York City’s garbage is to use incinerators, which burn garbage. They can turn one ton of garbage into only a quarter a ton of ash. The ash could then be used to make concrete roads.
But people argue that burning garbage releases dangerous amounts of pollution. Scientists at Columbia University say that incinerators were the biggest source of air pollution in mid-20th century New York City.
Protests about the pollution led to the closing down of incinerators, starting in the 1960s. The last major incinerator in the city, in Greenpoint, Brooklyn, closed in 1994.
Newer incinerators, though, are cleaner. And modernized incinerators can be used to create energy. When garbage is burned and the burning makes steam, it’s called “waste to energy.” The steam goes into turbines that can make energy to power the city.
Incineration and landfilling are two ways to deal with garbage. Recycling-turning certain kinds of garbage into new products-is another approach. And a fourth approach is waste prevention: the less garbage people make, the less we have to deal with.
Too Many Trucks
We learned about these garbage issues by doing research on the internet and through newspaper clippings, and by talking to people involved in the issue. We spoke with officials at the Department of Sanitation, neighborhood activists, and even the mayor of Linden, New Jersey.
Everyone had different views. Omar Freiya, from Sustainable South Bronx, said the trucks going back and forth to the 26 transfer stations in his neighborhood cause air pollution. Garbage trucks bring their loads to the transfer stations, where other trucks then take the garbage to dumps.
Waste transfer stations are built on cheap industrial land-in other words, poor and working-class neighborhoods such as the South Bronx, Greenpoint, and Red Hook. Trucking the waste to other states, like we do now, means more pollution for these neighborhoods.
Freiya said that using marine transfer stations-where a truckload of garbage comes in but a barge takes it out-would be an improvement, though still not ideal. Updated marine transfer stations can also compact the garbage before it’s shipped out.
Use a Canvas Bag
John Gregorio, the mayor of Linden, explained that New Jersey residents didn’t like the garbage-filled trucks going through their state either. He favored a plan to build a waste transfer station in Linden, which is across the water from Staten Island.
Barges, not trucks, would take New York City’s trash there and then the trash would be placed on trains and sent to landfill sites in other states. And Linden would get money for providing the transfer station. (Later, the Linden plan fell through due to corruption.)
Maggie Clarke from the Citywide Recycling Advisory Board stressed waste prevention, like bringing a canvas bag for grocery shopping instead of taking a new plastic or paper bag each time. She said that while recycling is a good idea, it costs too much money to handle if no one buys the material-like paper, plastic, or glass-that’s been collected for recycling.
I Demanded Answers
Sometimes people didn’t give us the answers we wanted. I interviewed Timothy Logan, with the NYC Environmental Justice Alliance and Organization of Waterfront Neighbor-hoods.
“What do you think New York City could or should do to fix our garbage problem?” I asked. He replied that it’s not what he thinks New York should do that’s important, it’s what the mayor thinks New York should do that’s important.
“No, that’s not my question. I’m asking YOU what you think New York should do.”
He didn’t answer that question the way I hoped-he just explained the different ways of dealing with the garbage. I let it slide that one time. I just kept asking questions I’d written down in my notebook and asked many follow-up questions.
It was fun interviewing him because it made me feel important and professional. I felt in control of the situation, like I was demanding answers. If he went off topic or didn’t answer my questions, I’d ask more directly and with a stronger tone.
‘No Comment’
Some people at the Department of Sanitation-the workers who drove the trucks and steered the barges-wouldn’t speak to us. We weren’t even allowed on their grounds. I’m not sure why.
As a documentary filmmaker, I was disappointed at first, but then felt better because this is the kind of footage that can make a film more interesting.
Of all the roles I played in making the film, I enjoyed interviewing most because I was in control. Even if people said “no comment,” at least I wasn’t ignored. I also enjoyed using the camera, and learning the editing program Final Cut Pro.
But there are boring parts of making a film, like logging, where you have to note specific times from the footage when a person said something interesting and write out what they said. We all hated that part, but you have to do it in order to be organized.
The most important thing I learned, though, is to see things in a broader way. Because whether you’re aware of it or not, what’s going on in our city can deeply affect us.
In the end, we all had the same point of view about garbage-Stop making so much of it!
Show Me That Funky Stuff
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.