Should I Stay Or Should I Go?

I'm not sure I need college for a career in music.

As a kid, my dream was to create my own sports or hip hop magazine. To do that, I knew I would have to go to college and get a bachelor’s degree. I wondered if I would be able to do that because I hated school.
But in my last year of high school I applied to two community colleges in New York City: LaGuardia, which had a journalism program, and Queensborough, which was known for business. I was torn because I wanted to learn the skills of marketing, distribution and promotion, but also journalism.
In late August, the choice was made for me. I was only accepted by LaGuardia, so I started there in the fall of ’02.
A Rocky Start
I didn’t get off to a great start. Because of my poor grades on the placement exam, I had to take remedial reading and math classes, and I failed the math class. But I passed all my other classes in the first two semesters, getting Bs in courses I was interested in, such as oral communication, critical thinking, and philosophy. I started to think, “Maybe college isn’t that hard.”
The next year, I took a class I really found inspiring called “Women in Society.” That course focused on women’s struggles during the 18th and 19th centuries. I never imagined women went through so much. They were unappreciated and seen only as housewives capable of cooking, cleaning and staying home. Thanks to the women’s rights movement, women won the opportunity to vote and work at jobs they wanted. Their struggle intrigued me. The course showed me that many people struggle for equality. It was a very deep course-one class I definitely don’t regret taking.
Journalism’s Jive
That semester I also took my first journalism course. Unfortunately, it didn’t excite me too much. I learned that it takes a lot of time to research articles and prepare to interview people. I found out that journalists have to cover whatever’s in the news: politics, war, and new weight-loss products that may change millions of lives. I realized I didn’t want to do journalism after all. I like writing about myself, but I don’t want to write about things that don’t interest me.
I still thought I could get a bachelor’s degree, but I started to worry. Now that I knew journalism wasn’t for me, what kind of career would I have? Would I have a career at all?
The Sophomore Slump
The next semester, everything started falling apart. My father was paralyzed by double strokes, my girlfriend got depressed and moved to Florida, and I got depressed.
I failed classes because of lateness and a lack of interest in requirements, like introduction to art. I thought, “How the hell does painting have anything to do with becoming a journalist?” Some of the assignments consisted of going to museums to draw statues on paper. Hell nah! I ain’t interested in learning how Picasso made paintings. I withdrew from that course.
Then, because I registered late, the only time I could take a required English class was at 7:30 a.m. This meant I had to leave my house by 6 a.m. I failed this course, but still managed to get a 2.0 GPA for the spring.
Dunned for Debts
Over the summer I took English again and failed it again (attendance problems) and also failed sign language (how you gonna learn when they don’t talk?) My overall G.P.A. fell to 1.8.
After I registered for Fall 2004, I received a letter from the college registrar saying I had to pay back the $3,000 I had received in financial aid for the summer because of my poor grades. Until I did that, I would not be allowed to continue in school past the fall.
I pulled out a 2.2 fall semester, but I decided not to work toward a BA and to take a break before I finish my associate’s degree. I didn’t have $3,000 and I didn’t feel like continuing anyway. College was just too much of a hassle, and I wanted to do something that I really loved-music.
A New Passion
At the same time I was failing school, I was falling in the “L” word with music. I found myself writing rhymes in my book again like I did in high school. I started to think maybe my real passion was music and wondered if I could have a career related to rap and be a business manager.
I began buying a lot of mix tapes and magazines like VIBE, The Source and XXL, and a book, “Everything You Need To Know About the Music Business.”
To become a successful manager, I would need to learn marketing, networking, and how to handle the politics of the business. So this past December, I volunteered to be a promoter for HustleUp DVD Magazine, a DVD issued every three months that contains footage of interviews and concert performances by popular hip hop artists. I distribute flyers promoting each issue and sell copies of the DVD on the street and outside clubs. (I keep $5 for every $15 DVD I sell.)
Becoming a Rap Flack
I work with three people who used to manage rappers and who teach me things about the business. They taught me that you have to get everything on paper because an artist may stab you in the back and go with someone else when he blows up. They also taught me to give advertising to people coming out of clubs because they pay for music.
I think music holds more promise for me than college because I am on the ground floor of something that could become huge. One of the HustleUp founders said I have what it takes to be a host interviewing rappers on the DVD. Even though I don’t have anything guaranteed on paper, I’m trusting him to promote me (or at least pay me) once (or if) the money starts rolling in.
I also became the manager for my friend Phlames, who raps. I’m trying to get him signed to a record company.
Money and Music
Social workers and family members tell me that finishing school right now would be the best thing for me. They say it’s a bad move to let two years free tuition go down the drain and to quit before getting a degree. Plus, I can receive foster-care related financial aid only until I’m 23. If I don’t use it soon, I’ll be passing up a free education.
I know college would benefit me in the long run. If the music business didn’t work out, I’d still have a degree to help me get a high paying job. But right now the only thing on my mind is money and music.
I aged out of care in February and my guardian is moving away. I need to find my own apartment and get a job. I want to know where I can make a buck, flip it, double it up and live comfortable.
It’s hard to get in the music business, but with Phlames and HustleUp, I have two opportunities to get my foot in, right now, and I don’t want to pass them up. I believe these experiences might help me more than sitting in a classroom. I want to focus on only one thing at a time and don’t want to regret not following my passion.
My Life and My Choices
When I finish my associate’s degree depends on whether the school forgives my debt and when I feel ready to face school again. I need only 10 credits (a few classes) to finish, but it will take me two semesters, because I plan to work at the same time I go to school. I’ve already filed an appeal to excuse my debt for the financial aid. If I win my appeal, I might re-register in the fall and finish up.
If I don’t win the appeal, I’ll have to work and save up money until I can pay off my debt. I’m not borrowing that money.
One thing I don’t want to do is give up this big music opportunity to go to school and fail again, or wind up dropping out. I’ve already spent three years trying to get a two-year degree and it hasn’t been easy. I have to do what feels best for me. It just doesn’t feel like school is the right place for me right now.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.