Walk down the streets of New York, ride the subways and buses, go into businesses and even schools, and you’re bound to see signs or advertisements in Spanish and other languages.
But if a group called U.S. English gets its way, you may not see them anymore.
“We are working to make English the official language of the United States,” explains Julie Lutton-Owen, national field coordinator for U.S. English.
With over 200,000 members, the organization wishes to “preserve” what they feel is the only common bond between all Americans-use of the English language.
“Our government is starting to function more and more in different languages,” says Lutton-Owen. “We aren’t saying that people can’t use their own language or practice their own customs. It’s just that everyone should learn English.”
U.S. English has been somewhat successful-California, Michigan, and 13 other states have passed laws that forbid businesses and other groups from using languages other than English on things such as ads, voting ballots, and application forms.
The group is now concentrating on eastern states, such as Massachusetts, New Jersey, and New York.
But what effect would an English-only bill have in New York City, where 25% of the population is foreign-born?
Immigrant Phobia?
“There will be racial hysteria and immigrant phobia,” explains Elaine Ruiz, coordinator for the National Congress for Puerto Rican Rights and a member of the Committee for a Multilingual New York.
The Committee is made up of different cultural organizations in the city. It has united the Latino, Asian, and Caribbean communities in order to stop the passage of the bill.
The group helped defeat the English-only bill proposed by State Senator John Marchi (R-Staten Island) earlier this year. “But it will be introduced in the Senate again next year, and we intend to fight it all the way,” Ruiz says.
Ruiz sees the movement as racist and anti-immigrant. “Many of the people involved with U.S. English are members of groups that are seen as anti-immigrant,” she says.
She also dismisses U.S. English’s argument that most immigrants coming into the country don’t want to learn English.
“There have been studies done that show immigrants are learning English, including a Miami survey that stated 98% of the Latinos in the city believed it was important to learn it.
“In order to make a better life for themselves, they come here, and they know that if they don’t learn the language, they can’t make a living,” she explains.
Lack of Classes
Because there is a lack of English classes available for immigrants, many don’t learn it immediately. Ruiz fears that an English-only bill will punish those who haven’t learned English yet or are beginning to.
“Services provided in different languages, such as bilingual voting ballots and 911 emergency numbers, will be taken away. They are there to help those who don’t speak English well or are well on their way to learning it,” she explains. “How can one function if they don’t at least have services in their own language to help them along the way?”
According to the bill, if a business uses a language other than English, such as in advertising its product, it can be sued. This is part of the law now in force in California.
“Does this mean that a Spanish-speaking business can be sued because it doesn’t use English?” asks Ruiz.
Lutton-Owen argues that the movement is not racist or anti-immigrant.
“The founder of our organization, S.I. Hayakawa, happens to be a Japanese immigrant, and we have a lot of support from immigrants,” she explains.
Enforcing Use of English
“It is not true, what our opponents say about certain services being taken away. That is not our goal,” she argues. “We just feel that assimilation is important, and in order for that to happen, learning and using the English language has to be enforced.”
Preparing to fight the bill’s passage in 1988, the Committee for a Multilingual New York plans to submit bills that will make New York a “bilingual state” and guarantee funds to have more English classes given. They also plan to educate New Yorkers about the movement and its implications.
“We need the community to be involved, to let their elected officials know that they do not support the bill,” explains Ruiz.
Teenagers are one important group of people they are appealing to. “If the bill is passed, services young people need, such as bilingual education programs, may be eliminated,” explains Ruiz.
But are teenagers aware of this movement? Of the teenagers interviewed for this article, only one knew about it. But they all had a definite opinion about the movement once they were informed.
‘Definitely Discrimination’
“It is definitely discrimination,” says Ramona, 16. “It seems unfair to come up with this type of a law. I have friends who may be affected by it.”
“It doesn’t sound like such a bad idea,” says Mark, 17. “It [English] is something that links all Americans together. But it shouldn’t be used to take away services or programs that people who speak different languages rely on.”
“Everyone knows that they have to learn English if they want to go anywhere in this country,” explains Walter, 17. “But you don’t learn English in one day, so services in other languages are really needed.”
And Joe, 17, asks, “If these people are so worried about English, why don’t they just make up some more programs that help people learn it?”
Should English Be Our Official Language?
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.