A few months ago, when I went to see Gwar, a shock rock band complete with offensive lyrics, lots of stage props and overdone costumes, I was really excited.
OK, so most of Gwar’s fans are 12- and 13-year-old boys. And their lyrics say offensive things about almost anything you could think of.
They even joke about having sex with dead children (that is really horrible) in their biggest hit song, “Have You Seen Me.” The lyric: “Those dead kids, they make me feel almost hard.” Gross.
Still, I always thought that all of those things were just jokes. But toward the end of Gwar’s set, which was quite impressive, I wasn’t too sure of my theory anymore.
You Can’t Be Serious!
The lead singer approached the mike and asked, “How would you guys like to see all the girls that would never f-ck you stuffed in a meat grinder?!!!!”
The crowd roared, and I swear to God that I could feel the testosterone in the room surge.
The band started to play a song while a man carried women out from backstage and popped them into what was supposed to be a meat grinder.
Now, I like a good joke as much as anyone else, and I knew it was just Gwar trying to be shocking, but I couldn’t help feeling a little uncomfortable about the whole thing.
When I looked around, I realized that the 12-year-old boys were eating it up. I don’t believe that bands should have to censor their lyrics just because of a few crazy kids, but it scared me how seriously the boys seemed to be taking the meat grinder bit.
Uncool, Sexist Comments
“There are enough problems with men disrespecting women without boys learning this kind of behavior from their rock idols,” I thought to myself. “But maybe I’m over-reacting. Maybe these kids are just cheering because it’s a cool song, maybe they have total respect for women.”
But my fears were confirmed when the only girl in the band did a solo number. She had a really great voice and the song she sang was slow and soft-very different from most Gwar music.
The crowd got restless and instead of people saying, “You suck! Get off the stage,” like they usually do at shows, they were yelling really uncool, sexist comments like, “Get off the stage, you sl-t!”
Can Lyrics Change You?
Like I said before, I do not support censorship. But this experience made me think twice.
I started to wonder if kids should have to be a certain age to go to concerts. I also wondered how seriously people took bands with offensive lyrics and whether music really does affect its listeners.
My friend Camille, 16, who generally listens to “punk,” thinks music can affect people both in a positive and negative way. She said she’s learned a lot from a band named The Pist.
“They taught me to be myself, not to take any crap from anybody, and not to let people stand in the way of what I want,” Camille said.
Carla, 17, enjoys a variety of music. Two of her favorite bands are Marilyn Manson and Jack Off Jill (an all girl band), both of which write lyrics that could be interpreted as offensive.
Jack Off Jill has a lyric that says, “Call me a c-nt.” And Marilyn Manson is famous for offensive lyrics involving date rape, sodomy and other controversial topics.
Music Affects My Moods
Carla thinks people should not take the shocking antics of these bands too seriously, but she does see that some people do.
“Personally speaking, the band that had the most effect on me, even though this is really cheesy, is Marilyn Manson,” Carla said. “They brought me down to earth and taught me that there really isn’t any right or wrong. It’s all personal values.”
I know that music affects my moods. (When I listen to The Psychedelic Furs, an ’80s band with an unhappy sound, I definitely get depressed.)
So I find it hard to believe that lyrics have not changed me in any way.
I can’t be sure that I’d have as bad a temper if I hadn’t spent so much time listening to bands with violent lyrics and sounds. And who knows if I’d dress the way I do-in all black-if I hadn’t admired so many “goth” bands.
Don’t Blame the Band
Bands and their songs definitely have an impact on people. But is a band really responsible for the way a listener interprets its lyrics?
There have been several cases where kids commit suicide and parents later attribute it to a band.
And recently, a freshman in a Kentucky high school who shot five people at school said he got the idea of killing his classmates from a scene he saw in the movie The Basketball Diaries.
Of course, anyone who kills because of something she heard or saw is pretty troubled, but obviously there are quite a few of these people out there.
Because of many incidents, some people think a band should be blamed for its listeners’ actions, and that censorship should be used to keep kids from hearing things that might affect them adversely.
Setting a Limit
But others say it’s not fair to restrict most people from hearing music that only a few people may be too immature to handle.
“A band can’t plant the seed. If a band didn’t bring something out of someone, something else would trigger it. That’s reality,” says Carla.
When I talked to my mom, who is fairly liberal and let me listen to whatever I wanted at around age 13, she seemed to waver between two ideas: she thinks that a band can’t make anyone do anything, but she does worry about people who are easily influenced.
“I think you can’t blame a band itself, but if a kid has problems, it might push him over the edge,” she said.
But even people who don’t usually consider themselves censorship advocates sometimes wonder if there should be a limit to what kids can hear.
Should We Rate Concerts?
Some people have suggested rating concerts, like movies, to control which age groups see which shows. I think this would be a good idea, but only if the ratings are reasonable.
“Once you reach a certain age you should be able to listen to whatever you want. But some kids aren’t old enough to handle it,” says Carla.
Some of the kids at the Gwar show obviously weren’t mature enough to be there. It’s sad that kids who can handle music at age 12 wouldn’t be able to attend their favorite band’s concerts, but there is no rule that would be fair to everyone.
“Kids under 13 don’t belong at a concert,” my mom said. “Well, maybe at a Barney concert.”
Shock Rock: Can Lyrics Go Too Far?
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.