School Uniforms?: No! We’re Not Clones

School Uniforms?
NO! We’re Not Clones
By Osei K. Edwards
In the January/February issue of this magazine, Lenny Jones wrote an article protesting the rule in his school that forced male students to take their hats off in class. “If we let them take away our hats,” he asked, “what’s next-ugly, no-name, old-fashioned uniforms? Booty hugging, shiny high-waters…no-frills white shirts, ties, sports jackets that have the name of the school on them [and] cheap-looking, tap dancing shoes that you can get at Fayva for $2?” Well, guess what Lenny, that terrible future is here.
In February, President Clinton said he wants to encourage public schools to require students to wear uniforms. He feels this will reduce crime and “[put] discipline and learning back into our schools.” I agree that our schools have problems, but the president’s method of dealing with them is unjust and won’t work.
Blame the Thugs, Not the Clothes
The policy is supposed to prevent students from “killing each other over designer jackets” and jewelry. What the president doesn’t seem to understand is that those kinds of crimes are just symptoms of much larger problems. Anyone who would stab someone for a measly Tommy sweater or a $300 Guess jacket is sick, heartless and has a thug mentality. As long as people like that exist we’ll encounter crime and violence no matter what we are wearing.
When my mother went to school in Guyana, everyone was required to wear uniforms. She told me that the thugs in those days used to steal books and candy. Clothes weren’t important to them; they found something else to steal.
Mr. Clinton made his announcement outside the Jackie Robinson Academy in Long Beach, California where, since 1994, students have been required to wear blue or white polo shirts and either blue pants or plaid skirts. According to an article in The New York Times, after one year school officials said crime had dropped 36%. Sure, it looks good on paper, but there’s something fishy here.
The Dropout Rate Will Climb
I know a lot of people who wouldn’t be caught dead in a uniform, who would get up and leave school altogether before they’d put one on. I’d like to see the dropout statistics for this Jackie Robinson Academy. Of course, the crime rate will go down if the criminals drop out or go to some other school to wreak havoc. That’s not solving anything, it’s just taking the problem somewhere else.
Making students wear uniforms isn’t going to stop the murders or the robberies, but it is going to reduce us to a bunch of clones decked out in geeky, uncomfortable outfits. I used to go to a private school where they made us wear ties. Once on a hot day, I took off my tie and unbuttoned the top two buttons of my shirt and I got in trouble for it.
To me, uniforms represent curfews and restrictions and a world where everyone is the same. In public school we interact with people from all walks of life. People of different races and sexual orientations, people with different attitudes-we all eat at the same lunch tables and play in the same gym. That’s the way the real world is and wearing different styles of clothing is a part of it.
How Will You Recognize Your Peoples?
Suppose you like hip-hop music, and you see some guy wearing baggy jeans with a huge Onyx madface on his T-shirt. Hey, you could possibly have a new friend here, someone who likes the same music you do. People look for similarities in each other. The way you dress can express those similarities. With everyone wearing uniforms, it’s a lot harder to outwardly notice them.
President Clinton says that uniforms will teach students to evaluate themselves based on what’s “on the inside, rather than what you are wearing on the outside.” Does he think that we are that stupid? We don’t need clothes to tell us who is and who isn’t cool. Obviously, that potential friend with the baggy jeans and the Onyx T-shirt could turn out to be a total jerk. In the end, most of us judge people by how they carry themselves and by their character, not by what they wear.
I believe that we should say “no” to uniforms and “yes” to freedom. After all, the First Amendment gives us the right to express ourselves however we see fit as long as it isn’t obscene and doesn’t hurt anybody. America is a land of diversity. We should celebrate all our differences, including style, because that’s what makes this country special. First it was the hats, now here come those nasty uniforms. What’s next on their list-no TV?!

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.