When I first heard bands like the Strokes, the White Stripes, the Hives and the Vines on MTV and K-Rock, I thought they were a welcome change from Limp Bizkit and Papa Roach.
I’d rather listen to the lo-fi production and stripped down guitars of these ’60s garage rock bands then the low-tuned, repeated heavy metal riffs of the nu-metal bands. But in historical context, there’s not much new about these new ’60s-inspired bands.
Take the Strokes, from New York City. The Strokes’ signature sound is their stripped down jangly guitar and the voice of their lead singer Julian Casablancas, which sounds like it’s coming out of a static-filled amplifier.
Casablancas’ nasally voice can easily be compared to Lou Reed’s, especially in his Velvet Underground days. The Velvet Underground, who put out their first album in 1967, also had a jangly sound and used the same chords over and over.
But the Strokes are much more conventional than the band that inspired them; they don’t venture into the extreme distortion and feedback that the Velvet Underground is known for.
The Hives, from Sweden, have the same stripped down sound as the Strokes, but they’re more riff-heavy punk. The Hives’ garage sound borrows directly from the Stooges, who released their first album in 1969. Both use loud, abrasive guitar riffs and lead singer Pete Alvmquist might as well be a young Iggy Pop, the Stooges’ crazed lead singer who later went solo.
Lack of originality is the same problem with the Vines, from Australia. I picked up their album, Highly Evolved, after hearing them describe their sound as a cross between the Beatles, the Beach Boys and Nirvana.
But while the CD’s rockers, such as “Get Free,” have energy, the boring ballads, like “Homesick,” seem to drag on forever. The Vines reveal that despite having pop melodies like the Beatles and Kurt Cobain-like vocals, being influenced by great bands is not enough to make a new band worthy of the same attention.
The most original of these new rock bands is the White Stripes. The Stripes take their sound not only from garage rock, but from the blues men of the early and middle 20th century, like Blind Willie McTell. The result is a mix of blues-derived picking added to a loud guitar crunch.
And when Jack White sings his introspective lyrics, like, “Well I’m finding it harder to say/ That I need you twenty times a day/ I feel comfortable, so baby why/ Don’t you feel the same way/ Have a doctor come and visit us/ And tell us which one is sane,” there’s so much emotion in his voice that I can feel what he’s saying.
I’m glad to hear these new bands on the radio, but I can’t help being disappointed that it’s really not anything new. Is rock coming full circle and starting itself over from ’60s garage rock? Does that mean we’re in for ’70s heavy metal, glam rock and psychedelic funk, which followed garage bands 30 years ago?
I hope not. As much as I like the bands of the past, I keep hoping for something new that will make me feel as excited about rock as Led Zeppelin or Nirvana do. Rock and roll needs a fresh sound in order to carry on the excitement it’s earned over the last 50 years.
Same Old Song
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.