Russian Pop Lesbians to the Rescue

I first heard of t.A.T.u., the “Russian pop lesbians,” when I saw an interview with them on MTV News. I was immediately interested because of their style of music-and their sexuality.
They held hands throughout the whole interview, looking cool and relaxed. There aren’t many gays or lesbians in the musical mainstream, and as a lesbian who’s thought about becoming a music producer, I wanted to learn more about them.
So I found their video, “All the Things She Said,” from the MTV website. Their music is hip dance rock-pop and I have a weakness for that type of music, so I had no choice but to like it. I searched for more songs and videos on the internet, and became a fan.
Are They Really Lesbians?
t.A.T.u. is made up of two girls from Russia named Lena Katina and Julia Volkova. Their album, 200 KM/H in the Wrong Lane, expresses their “lesbian” love for each other in a European pop style with synthetic beats and an upbeat feeling.
I put “lesbian” in quotes because it could all be an act. Perhaps the idea is to grab the attention of heterosexual guys and attract audiences by kissing on stage and on TV. If it is, I’d feel a bit upset, because I like the idea of lesbian teens making a way for themselves in the music business.
But I’d still like them because even if they’re pretending, the music still starts my day right and the feelings they sing about sound honest.
Controversial Video
In their first single, “All the Things She Said,” they sing about how hard it is to be together in society: “And I’m all mixed up feeling cornered and rushed/ They say it’s my fault but I want her so much.”
In the song’s video, Lena and Julia, dressed in school uniforms, are behind a gate looking for a way out while spectators of all ages look at them in disgust. The video became controversial because it shows them hugging and kissing each other in the rain.
Society may look at them like there’s something wrong, but to Lena and Julia, their relationship is normal. I feel it is, too. If two people like each other, whether they’re the same sex or opposite, and they have an intimate feeling between them, it’s perfectly normal.
Want Society to Accept Them
Continuing the theme of themselves against society, “Clowns” refers to society as, “Clowns that only let you know/ Where you let your senses go/ Clowns all around you/ It’s a cross I need to bear.”
They want society to accept them as they are, saying, “Don’t you hide your eyes from me/ Open them and see me now.” I can relate to “Clowns” because even though society can be cruel, and some people are unaccepting of gays and lesbians, it’s something I have to live with. But I want people to know I’m here too.
Getting people to accept me as a lesbian was hard because many of my friends thought I was just saying that to fit in with my male and female gay friends. But just because I didn’t tell anyone for so long doesn’t mean it’s not true.
They Remind Me of Madonna
The other songs on the album continue the theme of seeking love and acceptance while standing up for who you are. I like t.A.T.u.’s cover of a 1984 Smiths song called “How Soon is Now?” (A version by Love Spit Love is the theme song for the TV show Charmed.)
The chorus goes, “You shut your mouth/ How can you say/ I go about things the wrong way?/ I am human and I need to be loved/ Just like everybody else does.” I sometimes feel like that because I know that some people don’t approve of my sexuality. But I know that I should be loved like everyone else. My sexuality shouldn’t get in the way of society’s view of me as a person.
Even though t.A.T.u. don’t write their own music, the music fits them. Not only do the power pop beats suit their innocent and carefree look, but the lyrics sound like what teens might say, and t.A.T.u. sings with emotion.
t.A.T.u. are two young women forcefully expressing their sexuality, reminding me of how Madonna expressed herself with provocative, sexy videos.
I like that t.A.T.u. aren’t afraid to show female to female love in their music videos or in front of hundreds of people. They deal with the real life issue of being afraid to show your feelings toward someone of the same sex-but going ahead and showing your feelings anyway. I’m glad to see that.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.