Rap music has evolved from an underground fad and sub-culture into a true art form and growing worldwide industry. As with any popular art form, the music is changing and its artists are finding new ways to express themselves.
The greatest change has been in the conscious lyrics of today compared with the lyrics of the past.
“I grew up on that stuff,” said Ice Cube, former member of NWA. “It was more party orientated back in the days compared to now.”
“I think that back in the days rappers were just chillin’ and just making records,” added Mpenda, 16, from Art and Design HS. “Nowadays, rap’s been coming on crazy hard and saying things, so I think there’s been a real change.”
A Double Standard?
Change is a topic that’s always been related to rap, whether bad or good, and the change that a lot of people are talking about is the resurgence of Black pride and afrocentricity and how artists’ lyrics reflect these attitudes.
“That’s cool, as long as it’s not done as a fad,” said Ice Cube. “If you believe in what you’re doing, then do it. If not, then don’t, because there’s brothers out there dying for what they believe in and if you feel that strong, then that’s all you need to know.”
What’s really come under a lot of fire lately is the newest wave of rappers, whose lyrics have really deep and motivated messages in them, some positive and some negative.
For example, NWA got a warning from the FBI for their very intense songs, such as “F– Tha’ Police,” and Public Enemy’s Chuck D has been confronted with accusations of anti-Semitism.
“Backstabbed. Grabbed the flag from the back of the lab, told the Rab get off the rag.” -Chuck D (Public Enemy)
When rappers get involved in controversial areas, the question surfaces as to whether there’s a double standard used to judge rap music as opposed to mainstream pop music. One reason why many of these rappers come under fire may be that rap itself is becoming more mainstream, and, with that, more people are looking closely at it.
“I wrote some rhymes with a positive message, In case some head in the crowd might tape this.” – Jungle Brothers
“They [the record companies] put a lot of pressure on rappers to convey positive messages, but they never put the same pressure on singers,” was Ice Cube’s reaction to the double-standard issue. He added that rappers shouldn’t have that kind of pressure on them and that the final decision should be up to the kids whether or not to buy the records.
Influence on Audience
Rap artists have started positive campaigns, such as the Stop the Violence Movement and Ndodeyamnya (Artists Against Apartheid), to name two, which do not get the attention they deserve or demand.
Gerard McCarthy, 16, from LaGuardia HS, said, “The reason why they don’t get it, is because the media feed off the negativity and focuses on the messed up lyrics instead of the positive lyrics.”
Jennifer Stern, 15, also from LaGuardia, claimed that the media only want to show Blacks being violent to one another and never show how they are actually trying to make things better for the community.
This also brings up the question whether rap music (and music in general) brings out certain behavior in people and whether it has a connection to violence.
“There is a connection, but not the one everybody thinks of,” said Gerard. “Everyone thinks that it’s cause and effect, when actually the music is just a trigger to something that’s already there.”
Mpenda said that music does have an impact on its audience. He said kids feel compelled to wear a lot of jewelry and have the best car because they hear it on wax and see it in the videos.
As for the violence, Mpenda simply said: “If rappers talk about violence, then kids are gonna do it.” The example that he gave was NWA, with their constant rantings about violence and their disrespect toward women.
“What about the girl that got shot? F– her! Who gives a damn ’bout a b–, I ain’t no sucker!” -NWA
Jennifer Stern said that violence was not the fault of the artists, but of those who “mess up the message.”
“People who want to be violent are going to be violent,” she said. “People are always trying to blame it on the music that [the kids] listen to.”
When questioned about the content of his lyrics, Ice Cube said that the only thing that musicians owe their public is music the audience likes, simply because nobody makes you do anything you don’t want to.
‘What They See Every Day’
“What I try to do is give them what they see every day,” he said. He added that he doesn’t try to preach, but wants to be known as an underground reporter, an artist who speaks on controversial issues.
“Roamin’ through Hollywood late at night, Red and blue lights, what a common sight. Pulled to the curb getting played like a sucker, don’t fight the power (gunshot) the motherf—!” -Ice Cube
After listening to lyrics such as these, one has think about what exactly do the rappers owe their public. Some fans feel that rappers should get involved in international affairs, such as fighting apartheid in South Africa.
“I know that’s a pressure point,” said Ice Cube. “But on the home front, brothers are more worried about where their next meal is comin’ from, and a topic like South Africa is very far away from them. I only talk about what I know.”
Some rap groups, such as the Miami-based group 2 Live Crew, constantly have problems with the authorities due to the sexual and degrading content of their songs, like “Me So Horny” and “Doo Wah Diddy.”
“You can call me nasty, or even call me perverted, But you call me a dog when I leave you f–ed and deserted.” -2 Live Crew
In some southern states, 2 Live Crew has been accused of violating obscenity laws.
Does the Artist Have an Obligation?
What is the obligation of the artist, if any, to the listener?
“The only thing that [musicians] owe is music that their public likes,” was Ice Cube’s outlook.
“No music or art form is under obligation to convey positive messages, just true ones,” was Gerard’s feeling on the topic.
Many believe that what keeps rap so fresh is the fact that rappers have freedom of speech at their disposal. Many teens feel that if you take away that right of expression, you’d also be killing rap.
So exactly where is the rap industry headed with so much of its music constantly in the spotlight of the press and the government?
One direction that rap might go is toward more afrocentric rappers, such as A Tribe Called Quest, De La Soul, and Jungle Brothers. Teens who listen to these rappers get a strong message of peace and unity, not to mention good music.
Overall, though, it should be up to individuals to decide what should be the obligation of the artist to listeners. As Gerard puts it, it’s up to the record producers, the radio stations, the stores, and people if they’re going to make, buy, and listen to the records.
As for the artists themselves, Ice Cube summed it up thoroughly: “They [artists] should be themselves, regardless of what their public standing is, because the more real you are, the more the public respects you.”
Rap Lyrics: More Controversial Than Conscious?
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.