Race to the Top

I’ve always had mixed feeling about affirmative action.
When I applied, I wanted colleges to accept me because of my grades, talents and community involvement.
I didn’t want it to be because of my race or my gender.
When I applied to “White” colleges, people kept saying that I’d get in and I’d get a scholarship because I was a “triple minority”: I was female, Hispanic and Black.
This would always anger me because it was like saying that they would accept me because of my race and gender rather than for my grades and all the hard work I’d done in my school and my community.
It felt like their comments took away from all my hard-earned accomplishments.
More Students of Color On Campus
On the other hand, I would like to see more students of color on campus. And I know that affirmative action policies may be the only way to increase the number of students of color at elite colleges.
The way education is set up in this country, White students tend to go to better high schools, have more access to extracurriculars like band, drama clubs and sports teams, can more often afford SAT-prep classes or tutors, and are more likely to attend private high schools, so Whites have a better chance of getting into Ivy League and other top-notch private schools.
Hard Work and Discipline
Many minority students go to lackluster city schools, may not speak English as a first language, and don’t have parents who can help them with homework and applications.
This makes it harder for people of color to get into top colleges; it also makes it is harder for the many minority students who are not used to the competition, hard work and discipline required in majority-White high schools, to adjust to top colleges.
For example, my high school offered five advanced placement (AP) courses, but I have a Black friend whose parents sent her to a mostly White private school where they offered 34 AP courses.
Every class she ever took in high school was an AP class! Of course, like many of her White classmates, she ended up at Yale University (an Ivy League school).
I can honestly say that if I was sitting next to her in her Yale classroom, I’d be at a disadvantage.
My level of thinking would not compare to hers, because she has been trained to analyze and think critically throughout her high school career.
Playing Catch-Up
I’m not saying that she’s smarter, just that she’s had more resources available to her-the same resources available to many White students.
For many Black students who come from less rigorous high schools, catching up academically and adjusting to the higher level of learning can be a painful process that can lead to a stressful, disappointing freshman year in college.
Still, it may be better for students of color to play a difficult game of catch-up for one year than for us not to get into top colleges at all.
Public schools that educate Black and Hispanic children should be as good as the schools White kids go to, but this isn’t a perfect world.
So while I don’t necessarily like affirmative action, I do think we need to have more minorities taking charge-in politics running the country, and in business working on Wall Street, and as teachers in our schools and universities.
If helping more minorities get into elite colleges through affirmative action will help minorities into positions of power in all of America, then it may be worth it.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.