Interviews with Omiyinka Doris, 15, of Brearley School for Girls and Christian Rutherford, 15, of Poly Prep Country School-both of the Prep for Prep program.
Interviews by Aimee Pohl and Irma Johnson
How is private school different than the school you went to before?
Christian: It’s a lot more organized. Private schools have a lot more money and are able to hire quality teachers. Private schools have more resources, more books. My school has a campus-tennis courts, a football field, a theater…The quality of education is much better. I don’t think enough kids get the opportunity to get this kind of education.
Omiyinka: The classes are smaller at Brearley, my whole grade is smaller. The highest amount of people I would have in a class would be 13. It’s all girls, and you get a lot more attention. The curriculum is very strenuous. The requirements for graduation are a lot higher. It’s expected that you’ll go to college, an Ivy League college.
What do you like better about it? What don’t you like?
Omiyinka: I loved going to public school. Public school helped shape my character. It was mixed racially. Private school isn’t as mixed. It’s not as economically diverse either. I appreciated being around different kinds of people.
At private school I really appreciate learning how to write well, we are always reading and writing. I didn’t get that in public school. At Brearley, you’re expected to read and write all the time.
I don’t like the elitist and racist attitudes. It’s not that bad at Brearley, I mean a couple of girls are a-holes, but it’s not as bad as other schools. I’ve heard horror stories from people who go to other private schools [about] being called ‘nigger’ and things like that.
Private schools think they’re better, that public schools are inferior. There are people who use drugs and alcohol and they look down on poor kids who use drugs. It’s chic to be on cocaine if you’re rich but not if you’re a crackhead. The boys all want to be homeboys, they want to do drugs and graffiti.
Christian: I’m a little more comfortable now in terms of safety. But socially, I would probably do better at a public school. My school is predominately White.
I don’t like the fact that there are so few minorities. It’s getting better every year, but I still feel outnumbered. The fact that there are so few minority teachers is another thing I really don’t like.
A big difference is the amount of attention and guidance each student receives. It’s a lot harder to fall off the track because you get so much personal attention.
What stereotypes did you have about the kids who went to private school?
Christian: I really had no preconceived ideas because I had interacted with kids like that before. But the kids I went to school with before were more on my economic level. In this school I met rich kids with big houses, big cars, who were in the school because their parents could afford it. I hadn’t really encountered racism until I got to private school. When I did encounter it, it hit me like a brick.
Omiyinka: I thought they’d be snobby, materialistic, and self-centered. There are people like that, but it’s not everyone.
Do you think they had any preconceived notions about you?
Omiyinka: Because I had gone to public school, teachers thought I wasn’t capable of handling the work. Kids thought I had just stepped out of a gang, and that Brooklyn was a ghetto. They realize now that I’m intelligent…When I first got there, they were more prejudiced than they are now. They hadn’t been exposed to Black people.
Christian: Yeah, I think they did. I disproved them with my actions. I tested them by saying I was a good basketball player when in fact I suck. They expected me to be a great athlete and bad academically. I’m a terrible athlete and good academically.
Private vs. Public
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.