I’d always wanted to get up and read my poetry in front of a group of sympathetic fellow poets. I’d read about poetry readings and I loved the idea of being able to present my work in a supportive atmosphere where I could also meet fellow writers. But I didn’t know where I could do it and besides, I didn’t know if I had the nerve: there was always the possibility that the audience would boo me off the stage or that I would finish and there would be dead silence.
Then I met Michelle, a fellow poet who seemed to know where everything was happening. She had been to quite a few readings and knew where to find them. Through her, I found out that there are readings almost every night in New York. They are listed in the Village Voice, small downtown papers and poetry calendars, available free at certain bookstores. We also found out about places devoted to poetry, like Poets’ House in Soho and the Nuyorican Poets Cafe in the East Village.
My First Reading? A Disaster!
After I discovered that Michelle also wanted to read her poetry, we decided to go together to give each other moral support. Our first reading was last July in the basement of a small cafe in the West Village. It was sponsored by a poetry magazine called the New Press and it was a disaster.
We arrived early and signed up to read first. We then sat around for half an hour nervously waiting. Michelle took out a Gameboy and started playing. I tried to read, but my mind kept asking the question, “Why am I here?” Five or six more people, all at least in their late 30s, showed up. I was disappointed: I’d been hoping for people in their early 20s, if not my own age, because I didn’t think that older people would be interested in my work. The obvious age difference intimidated me.
I was the first to read since my name had been first on the sign-up sheet. With shaky hands and fluttering in my stomach, I read a poem I named “Rapture,” (“I slash my wrist/Watch the blood ooze out…I suck the wound/Letting the blood dribble down my chin). The poem was inspired by a recurring image I’d had after reading a book about Charles Manson, which had put me in a sadistic mood. It was greeted with one woman groaning, “Oh no,” followed by polite applause at the end.
Michelle was next, reading a poem about a girl who killed herself, which was also received with polite applause. But then, we didn’t like their poetry either. The featured poet, Gonzo, half-sang and half-recited some poems about being a chicken-hawk and selling his soul for gum. The host-the person who organized the reading-read what seemed like 50 poems about how much he hated New York. Michelle and I now boycott New Press readings.
After that first attempt, I wasn’t especially eager to humiliate myself again. I’d expected feedback-if not outright enthusiasm and encouragement-from sympathetic fellow poets, not polite applause from an audience who couldn’t relate to my work. I didn’t stop writing or change my subjects, but I never wanted to read in public again. Michelle, however, looked at our first reading as “an experience” and urged me to try again. After all, what did we have to lose?
Our second reading was a week later at a little communal garden in the Village. There was a stage with a mike and wooden benches facing it and it seemed very bohemian and unintimidating. The reading had been canceled earlier in the day because of the rain, but two of the featured poets had shown up anyway. Since we didn’t have enough people to merit using the stage, we decided to do a round robin, where we went around in a circle, each reading a poem.
A More Receptive Audience
Remembering the response to “Rapture,” I chose to read a different poem, one I wrote while sitting along a highway in the middle of nowhere, waiting for my bus to leave. (“I could be sitting anywhere/What does it matter?/Every place looks the same/With the same nothingness…”). I had tried to convey my feeling of depression and sense of “Is this all there is to life?” by describing the bleakness of the place. Although the other four poets were at least in their 40s, they praised it and told both Michelle and me to keep writing. I got the feeling that they actually meant it and that I could find sympathetic fellow poets, not like the people I’d encountered at the first reading. I felt encouraged by this and decided to continue reading.
A few weeks later, we went to our third reading, also at the garden. We wanted to try a formal reading again and I had loved the supportive atmosphere we’d found there last time. We signed up second and third. Our friend Allen, feeling daring, signed up for the first slot. The crowd of about 20 people, whose ages ranged from their early 20s to their late 60s, seemed friendly and open.
After their favorable reaction to Allen’s poetry, I felt more confident so I read “Rapture.” It got a better response than it had the first time. No one groaned after they heard the first line and when I looked out into the sea of faces, they all seemed interested.
I also read two others. One was called “A Walk” (“I took a walk/Down a deserted road/With myself/To clear my head”). The applause sounded more encouraging than what we had gotten at the New Press reading, but that may have been because the audience was larger.
‘Well, I Don’t Like Your Stuff Either’
Then, in early September, we went to one at a small cafe called Jane’s. Again, Michelle and I were the youngest in a middle-aged crowd. One of the featured poets didn’t show up, so our reading time was extended to 15 minutes. Because I had so much time, I read four poems (including “Rapture”) and a short story/monologue about a girl whose boyfriend is constantly in and out of jail. I hadn’t looked up while reading my poems, but I noticed the host fidgeting during my short story.
I wasn’t thrilled that the host hadn’t cared for my short story/monologue, but Michelle told me that I was overreacting and that we hadn’t really paid attention to most of the other poets either. Usually we do, but that day, I couldn’t relate to most of the other poems, which referred to unfamiliar names or events. At other readings, I’d listened to almost all of them, only tuning them out if they seemed too long or boring.
Hoping To Get Applause
Doing readings hasn’t changed my poetry. I don’t write to please an audience; I write for myself. If I think a poem is too personal, I won’t read it, but I don’t think of my poetry as performance pieces while I’m writing.
I haven’t fully gotten over my shaky hands and fluttering stomach when I get up to read, but I’m not as nervous as I used to be. Maybe the applause compensates for my failed attempts at getting published. Or maybe it’s my way of sharing a part of myself with a group of people who won’t judge or criticize me and whom I’ll never see again.
Although we’ve gone to fewer readings since school started, we don’t plan to stop. I like hearing other people’s works and I sometimes even get inspired at readings, writing down bits and pieces which drift through my head while I’m listening. I keep hoping I’ll find my ideal reading: one where the poetry is great and the audience is totally open-minded and supportive, with lots of people my own age.
SIDEBAR: Why I Write
I’ve been writing poetry since fourth grade. My style and my subjects have changed over the years, but my reason for writing hasn’t: it’s an outlet for my negative feelings. After the words are down on paper, I don’t feel quite as sad or angry or alone as I did before. No one taught me how to write poetry. I read it both for and outside of school, but I never tried to emulate any particular style (except the one Allen Ginsberg used in Howl-when I went through my obsession with Beat culture). Although I’ve studied rhythm and meter and everything else the English teachers crammed down my throat regarding poetry, I never felt the need or the desire to apply them to my own work. I disregarded form in favor of trying to capture my emotions on paper.
But Not When I’m Happy
In junior high, I wrote all my suicidal fantasies out on paper, which probably saved me from actually going through with it. As a freshman, I wrote about love and heartbreak (“Your voice lingering in my ear/And a desperate loneliness…Why do you haunt me so?”) which I seemed to experience continually that year. I never write when I’m in a good mood because I have nothing worth saying, or at least saying well. Nowadays, I can’t produce anything when I don’t feel on the brink of some form of insanity or outraged by something. I try to write every day, but I usually write about two or three poems a week. I write whenever inspiration hits-whether in class, on the subway, or at home. I still write about my feelings, which aren’t as angry and bleak as they used to be, but aren’t happy-go-lucky either. I would have thousands of poems by now if I didn’t go through my collection periodically and destroy the ones I can no longer stand. I know that I’m not supposed to do that, but I feel less restrained if I get rid of embarrassments. I’ve also submitted my work to several literary magazines in hopes of recognition, but so far all I have to show are a bunch of rejection slips. But even if I never make it as a poet (and so few people do nowadays), I won’t stop writing. Or, to be more truthful, I don’t think that I can. Writing is more a part of me than my arms and legs are (I’m not exaggerating) and, if I didn’t have it as a catharsis and an escape, I think I’d be in a straitjacket for life.
