In an early scene in the new film Philadelphia, Andrew Beckett (Tom Hanks) enters the law office of Joe Miller (Denzel Washington). The two men shake hands and greet one another. A few seconds later, Andrew tells Joe that he has AIDS. Joe immediately begins to clench his fist and look warily around the office at everything Andrew touches. He’s obviously worried about being exposed to the disease.
One thing I really liked about Philadelphia is that it’s the first major Hollywood film that deals with the prejudices against people with AIDS. You might expect a movie like this to be preachy, but I was relieved to find that it allowed me the chance to think about the problems myself.
The two main characters evolve naturally, with both Andrew and Joe fighting prejudices, internal and external. And Hanks’ powerful portrayal of the pain and suffering caused by the disease made me realize how desensitized I’d become due to the constant blur of TV shows, books, and articles about AIDS.
After Andrew explains that he has been wrongfully fired from a powerful law firm because he has AIDS, Joe tells him that he “doesn’t buy” his story of discrimination, citing “personal reasons”-a transparent excuse for not wanting a gay client with AIDS.
Confronting His Own Prejudice
Months later, Joe just happens to see Andrew in a law library hard at work researching his case, and an incident he observes changes his mind. Without Andrew seeing him, Joe watches as a librarian tries to persuade Andrew to use a separate room where he might feel more “comfortable.” Joe realizes that he is witnessing blatant discrimination and that Andrew needs his help.
Even though he finally takes on Andrew’s case, it isn’t easy for Joe to overcome his bias against gays. When a colleague questions whether Joe might be gay, he responds, “[Those people] make me sick.” Later on, he gets violently angry when he is asked for a date by a young gay law student who mistakenly assumes that Joe’s gay because of his involvement with the case.
Joe is portrayed as a stereotypically opportunistic lawyer who advertises his 1-800 number on TV and hands out business cards and promotional pens whenever he can. Still, we see that at heart he’s a good guy who really cares about his family.
Andrew’s arrival in Joe’s life forces him to face up to his long held bias against homosexuals. Although they are so different, it becomes clear that Joe and Andrew have common values: They share a deep dedication to upholding the law and protecting people’s rights.
The movie’s most powerful and memorable scene comes when Andrew and Joe are preparing for the trial at Andrew’s house. Opera music plays softly in the background and Andrew asks Joe if he minds the music. Joe says no, adding that he is not familiar with opera. He tries to persuade Andrew to go over their case. Instead, Andrew begins to interpret the opera for Joe.
Sharing the Pain
At this point the lighting dims dramatically and the camera presents Andrew in close-up: thin-haired, thin-faced, weak, pacing the floor with a barely perceptible slowness, all the while wheeling around behind him the stand from which his IV drip hangs. The music swells and Andrew is caught up in the story of the opera.
His face is lighted from below with an almost blood red color as he explains to Joe that the opera character is singing about pain and death, and then about the will to live. I was overwhelmed by this scene. I began to feel how frightened Andrew is about dying.
Throughout the scene, the camera cuts to Joe’s face, and we see that he is deeply moved as he watches Andrew, who is really facing his own mortality. When the lights come up again, Andrew snaps out of his spell, and apologizes to Joe, who is extremely shaken up and only wants to return home to his family.
I don’t personally know anyone who has had AIDS, but watching this scene made me realize that reading or hearing about AIDS is not the same as sharing the agony of someone who has it.
More Than a Tear-Jerker
Andrew’s family members, who all accept his homosexuality, are very supportive and loving. He also has many friends who help take care of him, along with his devoted boyfriend. Their reactions made me think about how I would feel if a member of my family were to have this disease, or how my family and friends might react if I had AIDS.
I thought that the film presented the story in a very objective way. Without being too much of a tear-jerker, it made it very easy for me to sympathize with Andrew. By creating a character like Andrew, gay and with AIDS, the movie takes a big step in dealing with prejudices connected to AIDS.
Philadelphia is one of the best movies I’ve seen in a long time, with believable characters and situations in a story that addresses some very relevant social issues.
“Philadelphia”: Facing Up to AIDS
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.