Our Lives Onscreen

Foster care youth review movies that reflect their lives

Movies are an escape, but they can also be a mirror. They can help us see ourselves and how others see us. Over the years, Represent writers have written reviews of movies about young people who lose their parents, including some specifically about foster care. Here we excerpt a few of those experts’ reviews. You can get all these movies on DVD or via the Internet.

Precious (2009)
By Virgen Nu–ez
The movie Precious , based on the novel Push by Sapphire, is about an African-American teenager named Clareece “Precious” Jones who lives in Harlem in 1987. Precious (Gabourey Sidibe) is overweight and lives in a poor neighborhood. Her mother Mary (Mo’Nique) doesn’t work and relies on the welfare check to support her and Precious. But there’s barely food to eat at home and they are living an unhappy life. We find out through flashbacks that Precious was raped by her father and had a child by him.
After the movie started, I looked at others in the audience and was surprised by the looks on their faces. Most seemed shocked-their eyes wide open as if they had never seen such a thing. It made me realize that Precious is the first movie I have ever seen that tells a story of surviving sexual abuse by a parent and other problems that put kids into foster care.
In the movie you see that parents can make huge mistakes. Mary let her husband rape her daughter, and then blames Precious. She screams at her, “You took my man!”
The movie shows how parents can be criminals. It also shows you how the child welfare system was before and how it’s different from now. I became really angry at how the school administrator sent Precious to an alternative school but didn’t guide her through it. But what shocked me even more was when the welfare worker had a session and confronted Precious’s mother but didn’t bother to help Precious leave her mother’s house and find her a safe home.
I wish the movie had shown Precious succeeding. I hardly saw success in the movie, just a lot of pain. From the beginning to the end, she had to face conflict: getting raped by her father and mistreated by her mother, getting picked on by boys because of her weight, being a teenage mom, finding out she has HIV.
The movie ends with Precious walking alone with her two kids; you wonder what will happen to her. I would have ended the movie on a more positive note-seeing Precious get a job, take care of the kids, find a place to live away from her mother, and take medication for her HIV. As someone who’s gone through some of those same things, I’d want people to leave feeling more hopeful and less sorry for Precious.

White Oleander (2002)
By Represent Staff
Four Represent writers discussed White Oleander , the 2002 film about teenaged Astrid’s (Alison Lohman) journey through Los Angeles’ child welfare system, and her conflicted relationship with her incarcerated mother Ingrid (Michelle Pfeiffer). All of us had also done time in care. Princess Carr and Christine McKenna recently aged out; Shannel Walker lives in kinship care with her grandmother; Anne Ueland lives in a building for former foster youth trying to become independent.
Shannel Walker: The movie shows that foster care’s not easy, that it’s not like,’Oh, you’re going to a foster home where they’ll love and adore you.’ What happens in the movie really is what happens. You get beat down. The movie doesn’t sugar coat nothing. It’s like what we do here-we write about what happens in foster care-but it’s on film.
Anne Ueland: I could relate to it a lot, how Astrid had to move all over the place to different environments with different people, trying to be brave about it.
Christine McKenna: She was a chameleon. With every foster home she put on a new skin. That was totally me in group homes and foster homes. I would adapt to what was around me. I wasn’t my own person. I was what everyone around me was. But there were some stereotypes in the movie, like every foster placement she was in had big issues. There are good foster homes, and there are good group homes out there.
Princess Carr: I loved the point of the movie where the mother says to Astrid, “Stop attaching yourself to anyone who shows you a little bit of affection.” And that is true. If you have not been loved or properly loved, anybody who tells you, “Oh, you know, you’re cute, you’re darling”-anybody!-you’re going to want to be with them. You don’t know what real love is. Some cases you might luck out and find someone who genuinely loves you, or you might fall back on the same situation you came out of, and end up with abusive love.
Christine: When I was in foster care, my mother signed away her parental rights to me. But she still held this power over me. That’s why Astrid reminds me so much of me-you’re trying to be good, and then your mom says one thing and it cuts you down.
Princess: The Russian lady told Astrid what was totally common sense and what no other foster mother had told her before: that you can’t go back. All you have now is yourself and your future. Your mother is not coming back. You’re never going to be 12 again, you’re not going to be in the house with your mother, sitting on the roof. You’re not going to be Mommy’s little girl anymore.

America (2009)
By Te-Li Shu
America is about a teenaged boy growing up in foster care. The movie, based on a novel by a therapist named E.R. Frank, was produced by actress and former talk show host Rosie O’Donnell. O’Donnell was so inspired by the book that she wrote a draft of the script in three days.
I was intrigued when I heard about America , because there really aren’t a lot of good books or movies about foster care. I was pleasantly surprised. We first meet America (Philip Johnson) at a residential treatment facility, in the office of a therapist called Dr. B. (Rosie O’Donnell). America has been in and out of many RTFs and wants nothing to do with another therapist.
During the opening credits of the movie, O’Donnell says in a voiceover that there are half a million kids in foster care in the United States, many of whom age out into the world at 18 (or 21) without any support. Even though this is a kind of dry way to begin a movie, I liked that she made sure people focused on the bigger picture and not just the story of one troubled teen.
Some of my fellow Represent writers who watched the movie with me said they could really relate to America, and felt that the movie was very accurate in showing what life is like in a residential facility. The story reminds us that teens in foster care need to face and deal with their problems like America did. It also shows how important a good therapist is.
Go to bit.ly/rosiepart1 to see Represent staff’s interview with Rosie O’Donnell about America .

More Movies We Love
Half Nelson (2006)
Love and Diane (2002)
Moonrise Kingdom (2012)
Great Expectations (1946)
Antwone Fisher (2002)
The Blind Side (2009)
He Got Game (1998)
Homeless to Harvard: The Liz Murray Story (2003)

Do you have a favorite movie (or book) about foster care or living without parents? Write us at [email protected] and tell us about it!

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.