One day during my freshman year at Edward R. Murrow HS, as I passed the girls’ locker room on my way to gym, I saw that one of my school’s showcases had been decorated in a way that was causing tremendous controversy.
Members of a club called Students Against Animal Cruelty (SAAC) had taken an actual fur coat, sprayed it with red paint and put it inside the glass case with a sign about how this coat had once been a living creature.
Many people complained that the display was disgusting, but members of SAAC argued that the cruelty of the fur industry is a reality about which people needed to be informed.
A Wake-Up Call
When I passed SAAC’s display, I was disgusted too, but I had to agree with their point about fur. I have always had a pet and the idea that an animal not unlike my cat, Spike, or my dog, Sara, could be made into a coat was incredibly disheartening to me. I had already stopped eating most meat, but seeing that display made me take the issue of animal rights even more seriously.
I officially declared myself a vegetarian and stopped taking part in the cruel and unnecessary act of eating meat. I also became more vocal about my beliefs.
I never did become an active protester, however, even though a few of my friends have become very involved in animal rights causes both in and out of school.
The Animal Rights Cause
They hang posters up all over my schools’ hallways and hold club meetings on Monday afternoons at which they discuss issues and plan demonstrations.
Outside of school, they frequently distribute pamphlets and participate in protests all over the city to target stores that sell fur and people who buy it.
“Fur is not fabric! No blood for vanity!” This is what you will hear animal rights protesters shout when they picket in front of a store.
But why do they protest against fur? Why not go to supermarkets or McDonald’s and picket, yell and petition against meat?
No Meat, No Leather, No Jell-0
Many animal rights activists are vegetarians and try to avoid buying anything made from any animal products or byproducts (such as leather, Jell-O, etc.). They don’t eat meat because they believe it is unnecessary.
Other foods, like legumes (like beans or lentils) are a great source of protein, are inexpensive and grown relatively easily. Most restaurants offer vegetarian options and restaurants such as Vegetarian’s Paradise (VP) are popping up all over Manhattan.
But, the main reason why people become activists is not because of meat, but fur. Adam Watson, an active member of my school’s SAAC club, told me that many people are against the use of fur not only because warm, cheap, cruelty-free alternatives are readily available, but because of the way in which the animals are treated. He is horrified that animals, living creatures like you and me, are raised and slaughtered for their fur.
Cruel and Unusual Punishment
In the United States, most of the fur used for coats comes from either fur farms or trappers. On fur farms, the animals live in cages that are just about the size of their bodies. Some animals, such as minks, are fed animal byproducts which are not even suitable for dog food.
The worst of the fur trade is the manner in which the animals are slaughtered. Both animal rights groups and the news media have documented a variety of immensely cruel methods that are used to kill the animals, such as electrocution, gassing, neck-breaking (especially with smaller animals), poisoning and even drowning.
While the United States does have some standards for the treatment of animals raised for fur, they are minimal and seem to be seldomly enforced.
Some European countries have much higher standards for fur farms. These standards cover everything from nutrition to living space and veterinary care. In fact, the Austrian government has made fur farming so expensive that the business is no longer profitable.
‘Fur is Murder!’
My friends who are anti-fur activists protest in many different fashions. On some days, they stand in front of fur stores handing out pamphlets and holding signs, while shouting slogans like, “Fur is Murder, fur is death. Free the animals!”
Sometimes the more radical protesters participate in what is called a “lock-down,” chaining themselves to the offending store in order to show their dedication to their cause.
Others go to Macy’s, take a bunch of the store’s credit card applications and return them by mail (Macy’s pays the postage) with slogans such as “Fur is death” and “Stop the sale of fur” written inside. Macy’s is often targeted by protesters because it is the largest fur retail store in the world.
The activists believe they are having an impact. According to a pamphlet from Friends of Animals, “Polls show that three-quarters of the American public oppose the killing of animals for fur.”
Are the Protests Working?
A pamphlet from the New York City Animal Defense League claims that fewer than 200 fur manufacturers remain in the United States, a big drop since the 1980s.
This left me wondering, if this is all supposedly true, why did the runways last fall have models wearing clothing made of fur or with fur trim? Is fur’s popularity really declining?
Walking around Manhattan’s fur district, you would not think the fur industry is “hurting.” Many of the stores appear to have a constant influx of new merchandise and they usually have a few customers inside.
While animal rights activists argue that fur is on the decline in terms of popularity, the merchants feel that fur is still very popular and even on the rise.
A Fur Merchant Speaks
“For a while people were scared mainly because of the animal rights/politically correct movement,” said an employee of Konstantine Furs, a fur store on West 29th Street in Manhattan. But he said sales are picking up again.
According to the Fur Council, the amount of money made from sales of furs in the U.S. grew from $800 million in 1979 to $1.8 billion in 1987. Since then, sales have gone down some, averaging around $1.2 billion per year.
The man from Konstantine Furs also told me that the conditions on fur farms are not as bad as animal rights groups claim. It’s “not as protesters would have you think,” he told me. “Animals are not skinned alive.”
He seemed to think that animal rights advocates are hypocrites. “Big dogs in an apartment are kept in the house all day and are only let out to pee for five seconds, but no one talks about it,” he argued. “Minks are better off than most animals.”
Give Me Gortex
I wondered whether he had been in any households where pets are starved to death, electrocuted or skinned alive for their fur.
When I told Adam Watson about this conversation, he was furious. “I cannot believe how ignorant and heartless people can be,” he said. I have to agree.
Thousands of years ago, people had no choice but to wear fur if they wanted to stay warm. But times have changed. We live in an age of alternatives-we have polar fleece and Gortex.
Wearing fur is completely unnecessary and I can’t understand why people continue to do it. Do they really think it’s all right to sacrifice other living creatures to make a fashion statement? Well, it’s not; it’s disgusting.
Only Finks Wear Mink
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.