Oh My God…What If I’m Gay?

Note: The names of teens in this story have been changed.
Have you ever really admired another guy or another girl so much that you wanted to be around them all the time, to look like them and to do all the same things? Did you ever wonder if maybe that meant you were gay or bisexual? How could you tell for sure? And would you even be able to admit it to yourself if you were?
Most of us feel attraction for the opposite sex. “If it’s the same sex you feel weird,” said Joe, 14, of Urban Academy HS.
Society brainwashes us into thinking that heterosexual is the only way to be, anything else is wrong. So when we feel something-anything-for someone of the same sex, we immediately deny those feelings.
Eliza, 16, was confused because she couldn’t explain the feelings she was having for another girl. “I told one person and she told me she didn’t think I was [gay] but that I hang around with too many bisexual and gay people.”
Later on Eliza went to a party and “I [don’t] know how it started but I found myself kissing a girl, and we went further.” In spite of what her friend had said, it turned out those feelings weren’t only her imagination.
This Can’t Be Happening
Eliza’s confusion isn’t unusual. “Many young people don’t think it’s possible that they could feel this way,” said Andy Humm of the Hetrick Martin Institute for Gay and Lesbian Youth. “They have no context…everything in their life is heterosexual.”
Humm says they tell themselves, “I must not be feeling this way because I’m a normal person.” If they do acknowledge it they tend to feel bad about themselves-immoral, sick.
To figure out your sexual identity, you have to ask yourself honestly, “Who would you rather love?” said Mike, 16, of Harvey Milk HS. “That’s all it really is. Being straight, gay, or bi, has to do with emotions.
“Don’t let anybody press you into thinking that you’re something that you’re not,” he continued. “Ask yourself, who would I be happier with, somebody of the same sex or the opposite sex? And when you ask yourself, don’t think about other people, think only of yourself.”
What Do You Want?
Before you can answer these questions you have to know the difference between sexual behavior- what you do-and sexual orientation-what you want to do.
“You could be married but still be gay,” Humm pointed out. On the other hand, he said that in prison a lot of men have sex with other men, then when they get out they go back to sleeping with women. “It doesn’t mean [they’re] gay.”
Humm told the story of a 20-year-old woman who called once from Alabama and said, “I’ve slept with every man in this county but they don’t know I’m a lesbian. I’ve never slept with a woman but I know what I am. I know who I’m attracted to.”
But what should you do if you’re not sure? For starters, try imagining yourself with someone of the same sex. Kerry, 15, of Graphic Communication Arts HS, wasn’t sure what she was feeling for a while, but when she imagined having sex with a girl “the thought of it disgusted me,” she said. “I can’t picture myself with the same sex.”
What about experimenting, is that going too far?
Having experiences with the same sex won’t turn you into a homosexual or bisexual if you weren’t one to begin with.
“If you’re a woman and you’ve had a couple of experiences with women, you might decide you’re not comfortable,” said Valerie, 16, of Graphic Communication Arts HS, “so you might turn to men. It’s natural to experiment just as long as you know where you stand.”
Vinnie, 17, also of Graphic Arts HS, had a different experience. When he was 14, he and his friend Julio “started off as buddy, buddy.” Then they began spending more time together. Vinnie knew how he felt. Eventually Julio admitted to him that he was gay. “Later on I admitted to him I was bisexual,” Vinnie said “We had safe sex. It turned into a relationship.”
But some teens believe it’s wrong to have gay sex. “The creator made Adam and Eve, not Adam and Adam,” said Tina, 16, of Graphic Communication Arts HS. “I don’t feel [homosexuality] is natural because natural instinct tells you to prefer the opposite sex.”
Force Yourself?!
Tina says if you have those kinds of feelings you should “force yourself to try to like the opposite sex, go kiss a boy, or [have] some sort of intimate contact.”
Hold it right there! If you have to force yourself to do it, then your true orientation should be clear to you.
More than anything else, it helps to talk to someone you trust about it, to explore the feelings. Hetrick Martin has a free hotline you can call to speak to a trained counselor. They’ll help you analyze yourself-it’s not like a test where when you’re finished they say “you’re gay” or “you’re straight.”
“We don’t tell [young people] who they are,” explained Humm. “We try to give them information.”
If you find out you’re gay or bisexual, the next thing you’ll discover is that it’s hard to meet people. Gay teens tend to feel pretty isolated. Hetrick Martin can help you with that also, by putting you in touch with organizations where you can meet other teens like you.
Whatever you discover and whatever you decide to do about it, it’s better to know who you are and not to have to spend your whole life wondering about it.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.