If a teenage girl turns on the radio after school to a pop station like Z100 FM, chances are she will hear either Britney Spears screeching out one of her three Top Forty hits (“You Drive Me Crazy,” “Sometimes,” or “Baby One More Time”) or Christina Aguilera’s pseudo-sultry voice crooning her one-hit wonder, “Genie in a Bottle.”
The song will end, and the radio announcer might say, “And now, a message to teens from the stars.” Sure enough, the listening girl will hear Britney Spears’ peppy voice saying, “When guys pressure me to have sex, I say, ‘NO.’ Why should I give my life away? I don’t want to get pregnant. It’s my life. So I just say, ‘Not me, not now.’ You’re worth it!”
Britney will punctuate her “advice” with a high-pitched giggle, and another commercial will come on.
Some teenagers will shake their heads, mutter, “Ditz!” or, in some cases, “What an inspiration!” and then go back to the music. However, some, like me, will be disgusted by the contradictory messages the media is sending out to gullible audiences.
Preaching ‘Girl Power’ in a Tube Top
Teen stars tell girls to be themselves-and then set a terrible example.
Take the Spice Girls. I’m sure everyone has heard the phrase “Girl Power!” used mostly when talking about the Spice Girls. When the Spice Girls made their first splash in the music world, it was their motto. By now, girl power has become such a cliche that it’s a joke.
Basically, girl power means, “Be proud of being a female! Do what you want, and don’t let guys tell you otherwise! Stand up for yourself, because women have been oppressed for far too long!”
Call me crazy, but I think that girls can figure that out without five miniskirted pop goddesses spelling it out for them. Ironically, while the Spice Girls are on stage preaching girl power, they’re dressed in short skirts, tube tops, halters, and so on, and are strutting around like they’re on the runway, trying to get guys to drool over them.
It seems to me that the Spice Girls’ way of dressing and acting really contradicts their whole “Girls shouldn’t depend on guys to feel attractive!” message.
‘Baby, These Lyrics Are So Dumb’
Like the Spice Girls, Britney Spears and Christina Aguilera also preach girl power, then contradict that message with the way they act.
Christina Aguilera appeared on The Tonight Show to sing “Genie in a Bottle” wearing a belly-baring halter and pants that no teen would be caught dead in. She slunk around on stage, singing throatily into a microphone, trying to give off a sexy image.
The songs don’t make them seem too bright, either. Let’s take a look at some lyrics of popular songs by Britney and Christina: “Oh baby, baby, how was I supposed to know?” “If you wanna be with me, baby, there’s a price to pay.” “Baby, thinking of you keeps me up all night.”
Maybe you think that these lyrics have a deep, intellectual meaning, but chances are, you’re probably rolling your eyes along with the rest of us.
Libby, a 10th grader at the Lab School, laughs as she says, “Is it just me, or does practically every single pop song by anyone under 25 include the word ‘baby?’ “
Ditzy Interviews
It certainly seems that way. And please don’t make the mistake of thinking that teen pop stars may be more intelligent than their songs suggest.
In a recent Rolling Stone interview, Britney Spears was quoted as saying, “I don’t see what the big hoopla is [about her revealing Rolling Stone cover photo]. What’s the big deal? I have really strong morals, and just because I look sexy on the cover of Rolling Stone doesn’t mean I’m a naughty girl. I’d do it again.”
She also says she loves to read. “I focus on my books! Isn’t that crazy? I like Jackie Collins.”
Bubble headed Stars Are Not Role Models
Spears isn’t the only one who doles out ditzy interviews. Jennifer Love Hewitt was recently quoted as saying, “My breasts are the perfect accessory. Who needs a necklace when you have these!” Her giggly demeanor and vulgar comments strongly contradict the way the media holds her up as a role model for teenage girls.
That’s the typical bubbleheaded teen star. They express beliefs that they think will make an audience respect them, and end up looking even more foolish when their actions in everyday life contradict what they’ve been telling the world.
A recent issue of Details magazine showed a cover photo of teen star Denise Richards (who practically every guy has lusted for ever since her role in Wild Things) wearing some sort of black underwear and grabbing her own breasts. Inside the magazine, she states, “I don’t always want to be the girl in the sexual situation, taking her clothes off. I think it’s sexier not to show anything.”
Does anyone see some sort of a contradiction here? (By the way, Richards’ latest role is the hundredth James Bond girl in 007: The World Is Not Enough. Yes, I’m sure everyone realizes that the film’s star, Pierce Brosnan, is old enough to be her father. And that Bond girls never do much except clutch the hero’s arm and whimper. What kind of “strong” teen idol is that?)
It’s a Girls’ World
Stars know what sells. They spew out their supposed beliefs and convictions on important issues because they know that is what the American people want to hear. But these stars are fooling themselves if they think that people don’t see through them.
Boy teen stars are also portrayed extensively in the media, but there is one difference. A lot of boy bands like the Backstreet Boys and N’ Sync are not intended to be role models for teenage boys-they’re for girls to have crushes on. Do you think guys go around saying things like, “Oh, I wish I could be just like Rich from LFO and Jeff from 98 Degrees!”
If a guy admitted that he liked N’ Sync or LFO, he’d probably be called “gay” and be taunted by all his friends. However, if a girl admits her fondness for Sarah Michelle Gellar, she’ll receive comments like, “Oh my God, she’s sooo pretty, and I love her show!” When it comes to teen stars, it’s a girl’s world. That sounds like a good thing, but it’s not.
Turning Yourself Into a Clone
What kind of message is sent to the world when teenage girls are synonymous with midriff-baring, squealing female pop stars? Teens see these stars everywhere, so they think people like Britney Spears set the appearance and dressing standards for teenagers. Teen People has put Jennifer Love Hewitt on the cover so many times you’d think she was the editor-in-chief!
No wonder so many girls feel bad about the way they look. The November 1999 issue of YM magazine has a cover headline that screams, “Look like Love and Britney!” (Love refers to Jennifer Love Hewitt, and Britney obviously refers to Spears.) The article is all about how to fix your hair and makeup to look like, among others, Keri Russell, Jennifer Love Hewitt and Dawson’s Creek’s Michelle Williams.
Airbrushing Away Imperfections
There’s no denying that these girls are beautiful, but I can’t believe YM is telling the teenage population, “You guys aren’t as beautiful as these stars, so we’re going to give you tips on how to make yourselves look attractive.” And yet girls are also hearing that they should be happy with who they are! Who to believe? Unfortunately, teens most often believe the magazines.
What teen girls don’t realize is that these stars aren’t even that beautiful themselves. They spend hours in the hair and makeup departments before a performance or a photo shoot. Of course they look excellent! So would anyone, if they received the lavish beauty treatments that stars are accustomed to!
As a character on the WB’s new show, Popular, says slyly, “I sometimes wish I looked like the girls in magazines. But they don’t allow airbrushing in real life.” Airbrushing refers to “fixing” photographs in magazines so that the stars look as great as possible.
For example, maybe the magazine cover photo of Drew Barrymore doesn’t look quite right. One of her ears looks too big, perhaps. There’s an easy solution! Simply find a computer image of a similar ear, and graft the picture onto the real ear! Or reshape the organ, maybe. Use the computer mouse to elongate or condense the ear, until it is “suitable” for the magazine cover.
Conformity Isn’t Everything
My mom works in the magazine industry, and she says the amount of airbrushing that goes on is insane! “In a world where Julia Roberts’ nose isn’t good enough,” she says, “you know there must be something wrong.”
Obviously, young girls feel the need to conform to standards set by teen stars. And lack of intelligence or talent usually doesn’t dissuade girls from idolizing a particular star. But stars are not like you or me, and teenage girls have no obligation to conform to standards set by Christina Aguilera, Britney Spears, or Sarah Michelle Gellar.
Believe me, nothing positive can result from having teen clones of celebrities scattered around the country. There are enough idiots in the entertainment business, and that’s where they belong.
SIDEBAR: From the Mouths of Babes
Here’s the kind of typical magazine interview I’ve read way too many times:
Interviewer: So, Random Teen Star, how do you think your fans see you?
Random Teen Star (giggling and fixing her short tube top): Well, I hope my fans see me as a regular girl, who’s had to face hardships just like everyone else. I was always a nerd in high school, I never had boyfriends, and even now, I never run around with guys! [Meanwhile, at this exact moment, Liz Smith is writing her column about how this particular star was seen just last week with Ryan Phillippe, Freddie Prinze Jr., and Nick from the Backstreet Boys.]
Interviewer: So tell your fans a little bit about the real you.
Random Teen Star: Well, like, I completely believe in safe sex, and I think girls should never do anything they don’t want to do because it’s just, like, bad! Oh, and also, OK, my parents gave me a Catholic upbringing, so I know the difference between right and wrong, and I also think that girls who do nude scenes are disgusting because it’s so degrading, and you don’t have to do nude scenes to be considered sexy.
Interviewer: But what about that dress you wore to the MTV Video Music Awards? And didn’t you pose half naked on the cover of last month’s issue of Cosmopolitan?
Random Teen Star: Oh my God, you didn’t like my dress? Anyway, I don’t see the cover as borderline pornography. I did that shoot for the sake of art, for my audience and my peers to appreciate. If nudity is needed to make the magazine great, then, like, sure!
