I am far from alone in my experiences with the police. In fact, I am lucky compared to other artists and performers who have been arrested and had their work or instruments confiscated while trying to earn a dollar in the streets and subways.
Susie J. Tanenbaum devotes an entire chapter to the subject in her book Underground Harmonies: Music and Politics in the Subways of New York (Cornell University Press, 1995). She reports that, beginning in 1990, formerTransit Police Commissioner William J. Bratton waged an aggressive campaign against “panhandlers, unauthorized merchants…people sleeping in corridors,” and anyone “obstructing free movement or transit operations.” In a one-year period, the number of summonses issued for this type of “rule violations” increased by 53,000 or 35 percent and nearly five times as many subway riders were ejected from the system.
Teens Playing Plastic Buckets
The following is an excerpt from the book:
In March 1991 I witnessed and experienced an extreme example of police harassment directed against musicians and riders. Larry Wright and a friend, both teenagers, were drumming on plastic buckets on the 42nd Street and Eighth Avenue (Port Authority) mezzanine, surrounded by a large audience circle. When a young white officer walked across the ‘stage’ with a German Shepherd, the drummers stopped immediately. The canine officer then directed the musicians to a corner of the mezzanine. Many of us promptly formed a circle around the officer, the dog, and the musicians. Riders called out questions about constitutional and civil rights in subway space, including ‘What are you going to do to them?’ ‘Since when is music illegal?’ and ‘Isn’t this a public space?’ Apparently, the canine officer was intimidated by this collective reaction. He tried to gain control of the situation by asking, ‘Are you trying to incite a riot?’ and by giving the dog slack to bark and lunge at us.
Police Intimidation
When we did not leave, the canine officer called for backup support. Six more officers arrived, including two white women and one African American man. In a matter of minutes the canine officer and his African American colleague pulled two young African American men out of our circle, then frisked and arrested them. ‘This is not fair!’ a Caribbean woman called out. ‘If you arrest them, you should arrest all of us!’ Instead, the officers physically disbanded us. When I asked a female officer a question, she shoved me. The African American officer dragged one man off by his collar. As they walked away, other riders wondered how police could deny teenagers a social outlet that might keep them out of the kinds of trouble that, ironically, require police intervention.
Tanenbaum says she filed a formal complaint with the transit police Civilian Complaint Unit and received a written reply that stated that an investigation had determined that “the [canine] officer’s conduct was not improper.”
I don’t want to give all police officers a bad name by recounting these experiences. During my run as a subway musician, many of them passed me by without even acknowledging my existence. A few even went as far as smiling at me.
Cops Aren’t Properly Trained
A September 1996 article in The New York Times tells of one young officer whose beat put him on the corner of West 49th Street and Seventh Avenue-a popular spot for (unlicensed) portrait artists. The officer “all but begged for them to stay away until his shift was over,” the article states. ” ‘I don’t want to arrest any of you guys,’ he pleaded. ‘Do me a favor. It’s 11:30. I get off at 12.’ “
Tanenbaum’s book describes the runaround another officer got from his superiors when he tried to clarify what the rules actually say. “You get conflicting orders from different people,” she quotes him as saying. “One boss tells you one thing, one something else…So you pick the brains of those in the know. You call the Legal Bureau. They don’t have a clue. ‘Oh, we’ll get back to you, we gotta research that.’ So what do you do in the meantime?…I just try to maintain order.”
Notes from the Underground
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.