“Not Without My Daughter”: A Movie That Promotes Ignorance

Movies can help shape our understanding of other people-and our-selves. They can be tools for exploring foreign cultures and give us rare glimpses of life in exotic countries. Unfortunately, they can also be the weapons of ignorance, especially in times like these.
Such is the case of “Not Without My Daughter.” It is the story of a Michigan housewife whose Iranian husband takes her and their daughter to visit his homeland and holds them captive there for a over a year. The movie is the story of their nightmare experience and, though most of it takes place in Iran, it does nothing to help us understand the husband or his people.
Moody Mahmoody (Alfred Molina) is depicted as a cruel, heartless alien who beats his wife for little things like using the telephone. While Betty Mahmoody (Sally Field) might be justified in hating her husband, it would have been nice to see what attracted her to him in the first place.
Only One Side of the Story
At the same time that it showed her struggle to rescue her daughter and escape to America, a more responsible film would have also tried to show us what he was trying to escape from-and to. It could have shown us a man torn between his homeland, family and religion on the one hand, and his wife and daughter on the other. It could have told the story of a desperate man trying to hold on to two radically different worlds and failing miserably.
Except for one tiny scene where two of Moody’s colleagues tease him for reading a Persian newspaper, we get no clue as to what it might have been like for an Iranian living in middle America in 1984. Just a few years earlier, Iranian students had taken 63 Americans hostage and made many more hate Iran and everything it stood for. It would have been hard for any Iranian living here not to suffer from those prejudices.
In the absence of more developed Iranian characters, Moody comes to misrepresent an entire religion and culture. (There are, of course, one or two token good Iranians, but they are the exceptions.) In her desperation to find a way out of Iran, Betty goes to her father-in-law and tells him how his son swore on the Koran, Islam’s holiest book, that she and her daughter would return safely to the United States after two weeks. She begs him for an explanation but, like the movie itself, the old man chooses to leave her (and us) in the dark. What we are left with is the image of a young man who takes a sacred oath and then just changes his mind. We are forced to conclude that for these people nothing is sacred.
Nothing Is Ever Explained
People of all religions have their contradictions. Moody is certainly a devout Muslim; breaking his oath on the Koran (an unforgivable sin) doesn’t necessarily change that. But he is also a human being. He hadn’t seen his family for ten years. Once back in Iran, the tug of his homeland becomes so strong that it overpowers his religious commitments. His father backs him up, perhaps because he doesn’t want his son and granddaughter to leave him. Just as Betty feels her anguish, so do they.
Throughout the film, all we see are scattered and deceiving images of life in the Middle East: Muslims praying before dawn, men eating on the floor, women dressed from head to toe in all-black ‘chidours.’ Without actually sitting us down to eat or pray with them, how can the film hope to give us any other impression than that these are primitive people who live like animals?
In the end, the average viewer leaves the theatre having learned nothing about Islam or the Middle East. She leaves with the perception that even an average Iranian (or Arab, it is the same in her mind) on an average American street is destined to take women and children hostage as soon as he has the chance.
It doesn’t matter that this movie is based on a true story. Choosing such subject matter and presenting it in such a way in the middle of the Gulf crisis preys on Americans’ worst instincts and does nothing to promote the kind of insight and understanding of which movies are, at their best, capable.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.