About three years ago, I started seeing a 22 year old. I was at the handball courts one day and he asked me to play a game. When he told me his age, I knew that he was too old for me (I was 14). But I blurted out, “I am going to be 18 pretty soon.”
After that we played handball at the courts every now and again and got to know more about each other. Usually I was with a friend who I acted a little crazy and immature with, jumping around and yelling. I hoped that he didn’t think I was too young, so when I saw him, I acted more mature. I guess it worked, because soon we started dating.
I Feel Beautiful
We went to Greenwich Village and to the movies. On weekends we would hang out at his place. Sometimes he’d make me breakfast if I came over early enough. Later in the day we might eat ice cream and go online. We both loved handball, so we played together on nice days.
I looked up to him because he was mature and because he made me feel beautiful. I occasionally get nasty comments about my looks because I have a scar on my face, but he reassured me and told me not to care what other kids think. He told me that in high school he did not fit in either, even when he tried, because he’s quiet and anti-social.
Calm and Safe
As we got to know each other, I told him that both my parents had died and I was in foster care. He told me, “I don’t know what to say,” but added that he’d had a hard childhood also. Then we hugged for a while. I felt calm and safe.
Around him, I felt loved and special. I hadn’t felt that way in years. His attention and affection felt different from the attention that I got from my foster mom or my sister. He held me close and made me feel needed. No one had ever held me like that before.
During our first year together, I never told my boyfriend I was only 14. I didn’t tell him that I’d never had sex before, either, or that I was planning to wait until I was a little older to have sex. I was embarrassed to tell him, because I didn’t want him to think that I was inexperienced. I also feared that if he found out I was 14 or that I didn’t want to have sex, he might leave me.
After we’d been together for 10 months, we had sex. I was kind of surprised that it happened and a little bit scared because it hurt. Afterward, I felt confused but acted like I was OK. Besides, I felt good because he was special to me and I wanted to remember him as my first.
‘Everything Is Confidential’
But later that week, I went to my school psychologist and I told her about it. I’d been seeing the counselor ever since the assistant principal in my school had found that I was in foster care and had introduced me to her. The psychologist told me, “don’t worry, everything is confidential.” I thought, “What could it hurt? I get out of gym and talk about myself and she has candy for me to eat while I talk.”
I felt strange talking to my counselor about sex, but she always said that I could tell her anything, so I did. I told her that I felt surprised that it happened, but also that I knew we would probably have sex again and it didn’t bother me. I felt relieved after I told her. She seemed concerned, even though I told her that I was fine.
Betrayed
A week later, I came home from school and found out that my counselor had told my foster mom what happened. My foster mom had called my mentor, told my sister and called the cops. My foster mom told me the police planned to arrest my boyfriend for statutory rape. That’s when someone 18 or older has sex with someone under the age of consent (17 in New York), even if young person agreed to have sex.
I could not believe it. I didn’t think my counselor would tell my business. I felt so betrayed.
That day, I called my boyfriend and told him what happened. He was surprised that I was only 14, but more upset that I’d told someone about us and gotten him in trouble. He said goodbye to me, packed his stuff and moved out of his mother’s house to escape arrest. I didn’t hear from him or know where he was for months.
That night, my foster mother told me, “You’re punished because you don’t have any common sense.” She put me on lockdown for six months. I had to come directly home every day after school.
Everyone Disappears
That first month on lockdown, I found it hard to concentrate in school. That was the most horrible month I’d had since my mother passed away. During class I kept thinking, “What is going to happen to him?” I feared that he was in jail or suffering and it was my fault. I was also thinking, “There goes another person out of my life.” It felt like everyone who’d ever loved me and cared about me disappeared.
Often I thought about the fun times I had with my boyfriend, like when he would pick me up and throw me on the couch, poke me perpetually or say my name several times until I’d look at him. I remembered how he would button up my sweater or coat when I was leaving the house, and never let me go without giving him a kiss.
Remembering his tenderness made me happy and sad. It felt good to remind myself that he loved me. I kept thinking I’d sneak away and go to the park and see my boyfriend there.
Is He Gone Forever?
My long days alone after school reminded me of when I first came into foster care. My parents had died and I hated coming back to my foster home after school. I kept telling myself that foster care was nothing but a dream, a temporary thing, and that my life would soon go back to normal. I’d think about returning to my family’s old apartment and seeing my mother there. It took me a couple of months to realize that my mother wasn’t coming back.
I knew my boyfriend was alive and that I might see him again in the future, but it felt like he was gone forever. I kept wondering whether he was safe. I cried sometimes wishing everything would go back to normal the next day, but when I woke up it was the same.
‘He’s Using You’
I also felt alone because it seemed like everyone who cared about me-my sister, my foster mother, my close friends, my mentor, my psychologist-acted like I was a disappointment to them for having sex at a young age and for dating an older guy.
My sister told me she thought my boyfriend was wrong for having sex with me because I was so young. She said, “He’s using you for sex, he should have known you were that young.”
I started wondering, “Is he a bad person? Or were we in love?” I didn’t think my close friends should judge him, and I wanted to prove to everyone that he loved me and that I was right to trust him.
I stopped talking to my psychologist because I didn’t trust her anymore. What happened to “It’s confidential?” But to have all of these emotions running inside me and to have no one to truly confide in felt weird. I’d never felt so confused and angry.
After a few months on lockdown, I started to feel trapped. Being alone in the house all day after school felt like torture, so I started cutting classes. I’d done that occasionally before, but now it became a habit to leave 8th period, or even 6th period sometimes, to go play handball.
I wanted to be at the handball courts hanging out with my crazy and immature friend again, or anywhere but home. After a while, I started cutting whole days of school. I take pride in being a good student, so I’d tell myself, “I am going to stop this,” but I’d always wind up leaving.
Handball gave me a little time each day to stop dwelling on my past and feeling depressed. Keeping busy had helped me forget the pain of losing my mom, too.
Ready to Go Mad
Those afternoons when I cut school, I wished I could explain to my foster mother that being on lockdown was too painful for me. But I never talked to her much, and I didn’t think she’d understand my feelings. She’d probably tell me, “It’s your fault you’re on punishment and cutting classes is your decision.”
Finally, I started telling my friends that I felt scared for my boyfriend and bored and depressed. They were more understanding than I thought they’d be. I noticed that if I held my feelings inside, I felt ready to go mad. If I talked, I felt cleaned out and better.
Six months after he disappeared, I heard through a friend that the police dropped the charges against my boyfriend. I emailed him. Although he was nervous about seeing me, we agreed to meet at the Staten Island Ferry. When I saw him on the steps, I just wanted to run to him and jump on him. We hugged, and it was great. I felt fulfilled and loved again. I never wanted to let him go.
We went to Starbucks, where he bought me my favorite drink and we talked a lot. He told me he still wasn’t supposed to see me, but I was glad he took the risk.
Still Fearful
That day, I was so happy. We decided to see each other again, and he started taking me out on dates. We had to be cautious about where we went together so no one we knew would see us and tell my foster mother.
We talked a lot in those first few months about our feelings for each other. He told me he loved me unconditionally and that, no matter what might happen, he’d be OK as long as I was happy.
Those months were difficult for me, though, because he was busy looking for a job and couldn’t see me more than once a week or so. In between seeing him, I still felt depressed the way I had when he was gone, and even now, two years later, I struggle with my fear that he’ll leave me and I’ll be alone and depressed again forever.
This experience has made me scared to get attached to someone who might disappear into the air like my mother, my father and my grandmother. I don’t think I can take someone else leaving me.
Should’ve Been My Choice
Looking back, I’m angry about how the people in my life reacted to my boyfriend. I wish my foster mother had just talked to me about being honest and helped me decide whether I was ready for a relationship with someone older than me. I wish she had talked to me before calling the police. I wish she’d thought about how painful it might be to be isolated from all my friends after losing someone so important to me.
I wish my psychologist had kept her word that everything that happened in her office was confidential, and had discussed my feelings about sex without being judgmental. Now, three years later, I think I was ready for a relationship at 14 but not a sexual relationship. If she’d been willing to keep my confidence, I might have made that choice for myself.
I also think I could use a psychologist’s help understanding why I was attracted to an older guy and why I get depressed when he’s out of my life for even a few days. But because my counselor betrayed me, I don’t believe I can trust a counselor as long as I’m in care.
He Was Right for Me
This experience also helped me realize how much I’m still grieving for my parents. If I didn’t hold in all my sadness about losing them, I might not have gotten so depressed or felt so closed in at home.
When I ran into trouble, I cut school, which is important to me. I hope that in the future I’ll find other ways to deal with the sadness I feel about my parents and the fear I have of losing someone close to me.
But I don’t feel bad about trusting my boyfriend or falling in love with him or even having sex with him. He’s stood by me for three years, and he’s been there for me when no one else has. Maybe it’s not right for a 14 year old to date a 22 year old, but it feels right for me to date him.
Reprinted from the July/August 2005 issue of Represent.
Not Too Young
The Law Says He's Too Old, But I Love Him
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.