Nine Inch Nails, Full of Pain

Nine Inch Nails is a rock band that many people have listened to since the 1990s. I like hard rocking acts like Korn, Metallica and Marilyn Manson, but I wasn’t very familiar with Nine Inch Nails’ music.
Still, after hearing the 16 songs on their new live album And All That Could Have Been, I think Nails’ music is pretty good and interesting, even if the lyrics aren’t always that great.
Nine Inch Nails (live) is composed of four musicians and Trent Reznor, who’s the vocalist and main songwriter. The album’s a concert recording, so you hear the crowd cheering the band.
It’s tricky to keep track of which songs are which because there aren’t many pauses between the songs. For example, “The Frail” blends into “The Wretched,” so it’s difficult to notice when “Frail” is over until Reznor starts singing.
All 16 songs deal with painful emotions like hatred, confusion, desperation and anger. For example, in the song “Wish,” Reznor sings: “This is the first day of my last day/ Built it up/ Now I take it apart/ Climbed up real high/ Now fall down real far/ No need to stay.”
The electric guitar, drums and a weird noise which sounds like a modem making a connection creates a powerful and exciting intro for the track that stands out from the rest of their songs.
In “Wish,” Reznor uses “f-ck” three times. (He curses a lot on the album.) But I don’t mind listening to it, because many other rock bands use this type of language or worse in their songs. It’s not like this is the exception.
Unusual and Unsettling ‘Closer’
Another favorite of mine is “Closer.” The rhythm’s unusual and the high-pitched, whining sound of a synthesizer stands out. Then singers come in, saying in a soft and low voice, “Help me.”
The lyrics are also unusual. Reznor sings forcefully about wanting to have sex with someone “like an animal.” At first, I felt uncomfortable listening to this. But even though these words come on strong, Reznor sings them calmly for the most part.
Plus, as I kept listening to “Closer,” I didn’t pay as much attention to the lyrics; the unearthly rhythm grabbed more of my attention. The rhythm helps the lyrics feel less violent.
I wish they’d finished the song sooner though. The instruments go on at the end for about two minutes without Treznor’s voice.
Overkill With ‘Piggy’ Lyrics
The album has other weak moments, like “Piggy,” which is about a person who Reznor blames for his wretched state. The lyrics are repetitive and boring. Reznor sings “Nothing can stop me now” 13 times in a row, which takes away from the song.
And the piano playing at the end of the song doesn’t make sense because it doesn’t reflect the track’s harsh words. It seems better suited for a classical music concert than a rock concert.
I do like the piano playing on the previously mentioned “Frail” (it reminds me of a song I used to play on my flute), but I found the track boring as well because it’s an instrumental.
This album serves as an OK introduction to the band, but I hope their old albums are better than this one.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.