“Holy crap, is that-?” Right in front of me, in the May issue of Time magazine, was my former parish priest Father Jim, “coming out of the closet.” His picture was part of an article on gay priests who’d made public their homosexuality. I read and reread the article just to make sure I wasn’t confusing him with someone else.
Later that day, I got a phone call from my friend Will. “Man, did you see Father Jim?” Will said. “How could he do that?”
That night, I showed my parents the article to see their reaction. “How shameful,” said my very religious mother. My father echoed her, saying, “You can’t trust anyone nowadays.” They were astonished that a priest they knew could be gay, as if he was a traitor to his parish.
Friends Joked About Jim
The next day, I shared my finding over lunch with my friends who knew him from elementary school. Despite all the good memories we had of Father Jim, my friends seemed to forget the man he was. They acted as if he was “insane” and “disgusting.”
“Man, all of dem cats in the Church are gay,” said one of my friends. “They all live together with no women. It’s almost like prison, man. They find the next best thing.”
“I remember seeing him at one of the school’s basketball games. He was probably thinking of getting with the ball boy,” joked another one.
“Yo, what about Mass? I bet he was checking out the altar boys,” joked yet another.
“That didn’t happen,” I said. But I soon settled with the reality that in their “Handbook of Manliness,” sticking up for a gay guy would, in turn, make me “gay.” Plus I didn’t want to hear ongoing remarks like, “Hey Russell, another priest’s been caught playing with little boys. You going to stick up for him too?”
Wasn’t Sure How to React
Even though I thought their comments were unfair, I wasn’t sure how to react to Father Jim’s revelation. Usually it was no big deal to me to find out that someone was gay. A kid I’d grown up with in elementary school had recently come out and it didn’t faze me.
But this was a priest, one of the guys who was supposed to be committed to God and no one else, especially another man.
For most of my life, I’d had a Catholic education where homosexuality wasn’t condoned. Once when I was 11, someone in class asked a priest about his view on homosexuality.
“A plug and a plug don’t fit,” he said. “An outlet and an outlet don’t fit. But a plug fits into an outlet. Enough said.”
Had Gay Stereotypes
I didn’t agree with his stance, mainly because he didn’t answer why it’s supposedly wrong. Isn’t God supposed to love everyone despite our differences? But I didn’t question it either, not considering the subject to be of much importance.
As I grew older, I learned more about gay people, which disproved some stereotypes I’d had. I’d once thought all gay men were effeminate, loud and overdramatic, but I was wrong.
I met gay people at basketball games and hip-hop poetry slams, and based on how cool they were, I saw there was no reason to treat them differently than others. Plus, I think anyone who’s responsible with their actions should be able to pursue whatever lifestyle they wish.
Should I Condemn Him?
Still, Father Jim’s coming out caught me off guard. I couldn’t help but question whether I should condemn him for being gay. Having friends and family damn his actions made me think, “What if they’re right?”
I began to think that maybe his homosexuality was wrong because priests just aren’t supposed to be gay, just like they aren’t supposed to take advantage of little children.
I struggled with the idea. I hated the thought of people being unfairly treated because of their differences, but here I was questioning whether someone’s sexuality should make me think less of them.
He Was ‘One of the Guys’
Over the next few days, I reflected on what I remembered about him. I first met Father Jim at my elementary school, Our Lady of Lourdes, in Queens Village. He was the associate pastor of the parish.
As children in 2nd and 3rd grade, my friends and I grew to know him as one of the more laid-back priests. Unlike the more uptight, conservative priests I’d come to associate with Catholicism, he was like “one of the guys.”
He gave me my first confession. I was 7 and scared about having to confide my sins to someone I didn’t know well. Sitting down face to face with him, I stuttered, “Umâ uhâ I’m sorry forâ umâ”
Noticing the Syracuse University basketball sweatshirt I had on, he calmly said, “So, how about those Orangemen,” referring to Syracuse’s team.
Cool About Confession
From there, we talked about the Knicks, and I felt relaxed enough to open up about my sins. After first being worried that I’d burn in the fires of hell because I’d flipped the bird and used profanity, I left the confessional relaxed, feeling good that I got my sins off my chest.
Father Jim, with a smile and warm handshake, was cool, not judgmental about my sins like I’d expected him to be. As a result, I felt more comfortable with the confession process and was able to see that not all priests were going to condemn me for every little indiscretion.
Father Jim was also one of the first religious people I’d grown to admire because he provided an easygoing atmosphere to talk openly about anything. If we asked about the significance of a certain aspect of our faith, like Communion, he wouldn’t dismiss our question with a quick, “Jesus did it, so we have to do it too,” as other priests did.
He gave us straightforward answers and even went so far to say that he at times questioned longstanding institutions of the faith. He made me feel that questioning was a healthy way of better understanding religion.
Left Lasting Impression
Unfortunately, Father Jim’s guidance was short-lived. When I was 9 or 10, my friends and I were told that our priest was taking a short break from the trials of being devoted to God. The other priests treated his absence as though he’d soon return.
After reading the Time article, I learned that he’d taken the leave of absence following an encounter that led him to live with his partner. Homosexuality is a very touchy subject in the Catholic Church, and I guess I don’t blame the other priests for wanting to keep the discovery of his sexuality in the closet.
Despite his short time with us, Father Jim left a strong impression on my friends and me. But it’s funny how quickly people choose to forget certain things. My guy friends are all so consumed with holding up a certain image of masculinity that they shun a great human being just on the basis of his sexuality.
Got Over Shock
My parents and other older people seemed to think his homosexuality was a crime. But he hadn’t been accused of sexually molesting any children and didn’t take advantage of anyone. Instead, the man had enough integrity to leave a profession in which he spent most of his life to be true to himself.
Over the next few weeks after the revelation, I stopped thinking about it much. But then I coincidentally came across the same Time magazine that caught my attention, and I thought again about how I’d reacted.
I felt guilty of blowing the issue out of proportion. Enough time had passed for me to get over my shock. He’s gay. So what?
Appreciate His Honesty and Lessons
I felt stupid about all of my previous doubts. Why should I let his gayness overshadow what I took from him? Learning that Father Jim was gay didn’t make me less Catholic. If anything, it led me to develop a greater appreciation for his honesty and what he’d taught me.
Father Jim’s disclosure also brought me to a better understanding of myself, and just how open-minded I thought I was. I try to be accepting of others, but when I think about how I first reacted to finding out he was gay, I see I’m still prone to moments of ignorance.
My eyes have been further opened to the reality that anyone could be gay, and that it doesn’t take away from who they are. Maybe one day I’ll be able to stick up for Father Jim to the other guys without worrying about getting picked on. At least I can still appreciate the times he was with us, before he was the subject of mean jokes, when he was just “one of the guys.”
My Gay Priest
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.