Moving the Mountain is a new documentary about the 1989 student protests against the Chinese government and the thousands of people who died. Li Lu, one of the student leaders, narrates most of this account of what has become known as the Tiananmen Square Movement. (Tiananmen Square was where the students camped for several weeks calling for democratic reforms in government policies.)
Using interviews, re-enactments of events in Li Lu’s life, and footage of students marching in the Square, the documentary shows how the democracy movement not only changed the relationship between the Chinese people and the government, but gave the younger generation a chance to be heard.
A Movement For Freedom
As Western influences entered China in the 1980s, through books and television, the ideas of many Chinese students changed. These new ideas showed students what kind of place China “could be.” China could follow a democratic system in which people would not be arrested for criticizing the government. Students saw the freedoms that citizens of other countries had and soon they wanted the same. They felt that it was time for government reform in China.
The student movement reached a turning point in April 1989 when a group of students went to Tiananmen Square to mourn the death of a government official who had supported them. Among the things that the students wanted was open dialogue with the government. They also asked for freedom of speech and demonstration as stated in the Communist constitution.
Tense Moments,Then Tragedy
The movement steadily grew, and on May 17, 1989, nearly three million people “of all ages…of all walks of life joined the demonstration.” This may have been one of the largest demonstrations in Chinese history. According to Li Lu, most people felt powerless at home and so they took to the streets. “People tasted freedom and they just wouldn’t let it go so easily,” he says.
Martial law was declared on May 20, 1989, and afterward 2,000 troops were ordered into the Square. There were helicopters and armed soldiers. The students asked the soldiers not to fire and the soldiers withdrew.
Many of the students then left the Square, but 5,000 stayed on, anticipating the government’s next move and aware that they were in a risky situation. And on June 4, troops once again entered the Square. This time they opened fire, and only 3,000 students survived. Thousands more were arrested and many went into hiding. Li Lu and Chai Ling, another student leader, were both placed on the most wanted list in China and fled to the United States. (If they returned to China, they would be arrested.)
Looking Back and Wondering
Today, Li Lu studies law and economics at Columbia University. He believes that democracy is still possible in China and that “a great movement will never die.” Chai Ling, who now lives in Washington D.C., is more ambivalent. She says she is caught between two worlds. “I don’t belong in this country and I don’t belong in China either.” Another student leader, Wang Chaohua, now a professor in California, says she can’t help but feel that the deaths were useless.
But Wei Jinsheng, who participated in an earlier non-violent democracy movement and remains in China, says that democracy “will be a very long, very difficult, and very bumpy process.” (He was sent back to prison after talking to the filmmakers.) Along with several other people, Wei believes that neither the students nor the government were level-headed enough in 1989.
Moving the Mountain is definitely an intense film. Although it is a bit one-sided in favor of the students, the documentary made me think about the importance of freedom and how students today can make a difference. It provides you with the information to weigh the consequences and decide for yourself if the massacre was worth it or not.
“Moving the Mountain”: Remembering Tiananmen Square
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.