Walking into the movie theater with my editor and two fellow NYC writers, I was excited. Documentaries have always been my favorite type of movie. Watching Michael Moore’s documentaries in school, like Sicko and Fahrenheit 9/11, only fueled my craving for them. So when I got the chance to review a new documentary about religion, I jumped at it. I wanted to learn more about different religions and I’d also heard the movie was funny.
Outside the double doors to our movie was a poster featuring three chimps sitting in a sort of heaven-like place. They were doing the “see no evil, hear no evil, speak no evil” stance. One of the chimps was wearing the headgear of the pope. The image perfectly represented the theme of the documentary I was about to see, Religulous. A mixture of two words, religion and ridiculous.
In this satirical documentary, Bill Maher, a comedian and political commentator, visits all corners of the earth to try to answer the big question: “What is the point of religion?” The entire movie revolves around mocking the concept of religion and showing the problems that occur because of it. And that’s what made the documentary incredibly funny and informative, but also mean-spirited.
Mocking My Beliefs
Maher dishes out questions to religious leaders and people who feel strongly about their religion. We hear from many religious groups, like Jews for Jesus, Muslims, Hasidic Jews and Mormons. One scene I found interesting was when Maher interviewed two former Mormons. They told him that Mormons believe Jesus had sexual relations with Mary Magdalene and that hell is here on Earth.
This stood out for me because I’ve always wondered what made Mormons different from other Christians. But their answer made their religion seem ridiculous to me. And I think that’s the whole point of this movie. If it’s not our religion, we think it’s wrong or strange, Maher tries to convey to us. Would our own beliefs seem just as ridiculous to other people? Yes-as I found out in another part of the movie, when Maher mocked one of my religious beliefs.
He was interviewing truckers who had created their own church for when they need an ounce of hope while on the road. Maher kept asking them condescending questions, as if he wanted to prove them wrong. One topic he kept shutting down was the Rapture, which, the truckers explained, is how God is going to take his believers to heaven with him.
This particularly upset me because it’s something I believe in. It made me realize that if Maher were to interview me about my religion (I’m a Seventh-day Adventist), he would probably try to rip me to shreds as he did to the people in his documentary. But, like many of the people in the film, I would still stand my ground and speak about my religion truthfully, even if he thinks it’s strange and crazy.
A Negative Vibe
Although the documentary was funny, I felt that Maher went into it with a negative mindset. It was as if he just wanted to prove his own belief that there’s no reason for religion and that they’re all extreme and overrated. This was sort of a turn-off for me. I felt he wasn’t making the documentary to search for more clarity, but only to show everyone else that religion and faith are pointless.
To do that, he picked people who were the most extreme examples of a particular religion, like Jose Luis de Jesus Miranda, a Puerto Rican man who says that he is Jesus Christ in the flesh and claims to have 100,000 followers.
I would have preferred Maher to be inquiring in an unbiased way. If there had been another interviewer who had more of a curious and open mindset along with Maher, it would have been the best of both worlds. Then viewers would be able to make decisions for themselves and not be influenced by the negative vibe of the documentary.
I hope the film broadens viewers’ horizons on religion and faith and makes them walk away wanting to think more about religion. But I worry that because of Maher’s approach, those who come to the theater with a negative view on religion already will only leave with more of a reason to have that mindset.
Movie Review: Making Religion Ridiculous
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.