Do you remember the monster in your closet? Once you reach adulthood, you might find that he’s out in the open and taking your money. Actually, you might find you’re handing it over, and that it isn’t just one monster anymore, there are hundreds of them invading your neighborhood. They’re called banks, cashiers, and credit cards.
We recently spoke with Herman De Jesus, a senior program associate for the Neighborhood Economic Development Advocacy Project (NEDAP). His organization promotes economic justice in the city’s low-income and minority communities. He revealed some of the tricky ways in which people are duped out of their hard-earned dollars.
NYC: What does “economic justice” mean?
Herman De Jesus: There are so many people who are taken advantage of just because of the color of their skin, how much money they make, their age, their gender. If you’re very low income, if you’re a person of color, a single mother, or a senior, all the loan products that exist-they don’t favor you. (A “loan product” means any type of loan or credit, like a bank loan to buy a home or car, a credit card, etc.) So what we mean by economic justice is that everyone should be treated the same.
NYC: Are there specific groups that face more financial obstacles than everyone else?
De Jesus: The sad answer is yes. Many years ago, the big banks would circle red lines around neighborhoods of color. That’s what we call redlining, and they would say, “we’re not going to lend in these neighborhoods of color.” So there were a lot of African-American, Hispanic, and other minorities who would want to borrow money to buy a house, but they couldn’t get a loan, either because of the color of their skin or the neighborhood they lived in.
Then there was this other horrible practice called reverse red lining, which is where companies said, “No one is lending in these neighborhoods of color. we’re going to lend here, and we’re going to charge two, three, or four times more than these folks can actually afford.”
So, for example, one of the loan products a bank offers is a mortgage, which is a loan to buy a house. Mortgages are complex, but basically you borrow a certain amount, then pay it back with interest over 15 or 30 years. So, look for example at someone who’s white and doesn’t live in a redlined neighborhood. Let’s say they borrow $200,000 at a 5% interest rate. Then a minority borrower in a redlined neighborhood borrows the exact same amount of money, $200,000, and has the same income, the same credit, and the same down payment. But they can only get a mortgage at a 10% interest rate. So where the non-minority borrower’s mortgage payment is $1,000 a month, the minority borrower has to pay $1,700 a month. That’s totally unfair, but it happens.
NYC: It’s still going on?
De Jesus: There are now laws against redlining, but it still happens. Banks look for reasons not to approve you for financing if you live in certain neighborhoods. Or, if they do approve you, they charge you a higher interest rate.
This problem has existed for years. I used to work for a legal services organization and I represented folks who were in foreclosure. (A foreclosure is when a person falls behind on their mortgage payments to the bank, so the bank takes their house.) Every single person we met with was either elderly or very young, and they were all minorities. When we reviewed their papers to see how they ended up with these terrible mortgages, we realized nine times out of ten, they qualified for something better-a better interest rate and a lower monthly payment. But they were preyed on by certain companies that gave them these horrible loans.
NYC: Are there other loan products or financial services we should avoid?
De Jesus: You guys probably see Magic Johnson and Troy Aikman in commercials telling people to go to Rent-a-Center, where you can get furniture and appliances in this rent-to-own deal? Well, Rent-a-Centers set up shop in predominantly low- and moderate-income neighborhoods where minorities live. They know people in those neighborhoods don’t have the cash reserves to buy things up front. But when you go to one of these shops, sure, you can rent a toaster for a few bucks, but with monthly payments and penalties, you could end up paying $200, $300, or $400 for a toaster worth $30!
Also, pre-paid debit cards: You get this card with a Visa or Mastercard logo that you can use as a debit card. But what happens when you use it as a debit card? You get charged a fee. How do you check your balance? You go to an ATM and there’s a fee. There’s a fee for activating it; there’s a fee for drawing money on it. There’s a fee for everything and who do you think it’s pitched to? Minorities and poor people.
In a lot of instances, these products are sold by minorities to minorities. This happens because they know there’s this distrust of banks in minority communities. They say, “The bank is going to say no, we’re going to say yes, so come to us.” But they don’t tell you that they’ll charge you four or five times more than banks would have charged.
NYC: Some people blame the recession on individuals who took out mortgages they couldn’t afford. Others blame the banks for giving out those mortgages. Who do you think is responsible?
De Jesus: I think everyone is responsible. Yes, people are responsible for the mortgages and loans they’re getting into, but-and this is a big but-people rely heavily on so-called professionals to explain to them what they’re getting into, and sometimes those professionals lie to them! That’s true of a lot of mortgages, rent-to-own places, and every sort of lending that exists.
NYC: Why hasn’t the government stopped these unfair practices?
De Jesus: The government says it’s regulating these companies, but our elected officials are not doing their jobs because they’re getting money from the big banks. The problem is the more money you have, the more influence you have, and the banks have the money.
NYC: Is there anything that we, as individuals, can do to make things better?
De Jesus: You’ve got to put a lot of pressure on your elected officials to do what’s right. There are a bunch of advocates, including NEDAP, pushing for a bill that would create a Consumer Financial Protection Agency that would be able to stop companies from creating certain loan products. But the banks are trying to stop this bill, so you have to tell these companies and your elected officials that this isn’t fair, and changes need to happen. If we don’t do anything, it could get worse. In a couple of years, a lot of people are going to be out on the street. People will be even poorer than before. If you don’t want that to happen, you need to stand up now.
In the meantime, you should protect your own financial future. It’s all about knowing what you’re getting into. No one reads the fine print. Most of the time people rely on the experts, the person at the bank who’s helping you open your account or whoever. But it’s your job to figure out, “Is this person lying to me or not?” If it sounds too good to be true, it normally is.
Monsters, Inc.
How big, bad business caused the housing crisis
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.