Malcolm and Martin: They Both Deserve Our Respect

Three years ago when I came from Jamaica, if you had asked me what Malcolm X or Martin Luther King Jr. ever did for me I would have said, “absolutely nothing.” I didn’t deny them the credit that was due to them-I just didn’t care.
I couldn’t relate to the “Black struggle.” I felt that this fight was for African-Americans only, not for immigrants like me. I wanted to be neutral…I didn’t want to get involved.
But as time went by I began to feel like I too belonged to the fold. I saw some TV documentaries and did some reading and research on Black history and I realized that if I had been in this country at that time I wouldn’t have been judged by my nationality but by the color of my skin.
Black people just a few decades ago were still deprived of equal rights. They could not go to the school of their choice. They had to ride in the backs of buses and they were often deprived of their right to vote. In many cases they were lynched and they were often brutalized by the police. Many were murdered by White people who never got punished. Justice was never on the Black person’s side-no matter what happened it was always his fault.
Fighters Through Thick and Thin
Martin Luther King Jr. and Malcolm X were two people who took a stand against these injustices. They challenged the judicial system and the rest of American society to bring about fair treatment for Black people.
Through thick and thin each one held on to his goals. King was arrested more than 30 times for protesting against injustices like segregation at lunch counters. Malcolm’s house was bombed. But not even these distractions could stop them. Their determination was stopped only when both men were killed.
I decided to ask teenagers how they felt about the lasting contribution of these two men. “If there was no Malcolm X and Martin Luther King, Black people would still be [as] restricted as they were before,” said Baggy General, 19, of Pratt Institute.
Back then, Black people were treated like animals and second class citizens. Malcolm X reaffirmed our status as human beings and demanded that we be treated with respect. In one speech he said, “We declare our race on this earth to be a man, to be a human being, to be respected as a human being, in this society, on this earth, in this day-which we intend to bring into existence by any means necessary.”
Today, 30 years later, Tameka Andrews, 19, of St. John’s University, says the same thing: “We are not inferior, [White people] are not better than us. We all have the same needs and we all live in the same country.”
King Got the Job Done
Both Malcolm and King used their religion as a tool to help fight for justice for Black people. King strongly believed in the Bible and its teaching. He refused to accept any principles that were against the Bible. Whatever he did reflected what the Bible teaches. He lived according to how he felt God wanted him to live and that meant non-violently.
People often say that Dr. King’s method wasn’t effective, that because he let White people beat him up he was too soft. But this is not true. Through non-violent demonstrations, King brought a lot of changes to this society. For example, as a result of the Montgomery, Alabama bus boycott that he organized, Black people throughout the South no longer rode in the back of the bus but wherever they wanted.
“I admire Martin Luther King because he knew what he wanted and he didn’t resort to violence to get it,” said Trecia Grant, 19, of St. John’s University.
Malcolm Wasn’t Violent
There are many misconceptions about Malcolm X, too. Young people see Malcolm X as a violent, aggressive person. “Some teens think that Malcolm X was crazed,” said Andre McKenzie, Acting Dean of St. Vincent College at St. John’s University. “[They think of] the picture of him holding a gun with the slogan [underneath it] ‘By Any Means Necessary.’ For them that’s the guy that hated White people.”
But despite his militant image, after his conversion to the Nation of Islam while he was in prison, no one can say that Malcolm X did anything violent.
These days you find people saying they like or dislike one or the other because he was “too soft” or “too aggressive.” This sort of attitude has created a division within the Black community. Let’s not measure their method, but instead, their accomplishments. Neither King nor Malcolm was greater than the other. Both should be given equal respect and acknowledgement.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.