Making Sense of My Sister

A Therapist Helped Me Understand What's Happened to My Twin

Last year my twin sister was diagnosed with a mental illness. Taheerah started to seem depressed when we moved out of our group home and into a foster home. Our foster mom, Ms. Crosby, really tried to make us feel welcome in her home.
I think that having someone care about us was scary to my sister and she began to just separate herself away-so far away that she couldn’t come back to the real world. She ended up in the hospital for a long time. She’s home now, but she still drifts off into another world. I wish I could help her find her way home.
To find out why some people develop mental illnesses-and what you can do to handle yourself if you have one-I talked with Dr. Jill Bellinson, a clinical psychologist.
Her office was cozy, dim, with a long couch. I just wanted to sleep on it. Her personality wasn’t like other psychologists I’ve met. She listened well to my ghetto terms and answered my questions in vivid detail.
Two Words for Trouble
I told Dr. Bellinson, “My twin, Taheerah, was diagnosed with schizophrenia and then bipolar disorder. Why would the diagnosis change?”
“It’s very confusing, but the differences between bipolar and schizophrenia are not so obvious as we’d like them to be,” she said. “Both of those diagnoses mean that your sister is having a lot of difficulty in living life. Things throw her. She’s upset. She’s thrown by life so that it’s impossible for her to learn, to focus, to work. She just can’t keep going.”
When she gave me that description I was scared for my sister and felt really upset that she’s suffering.
Dr. Bellinson asked me, “When she’s upset and she’s unable to keep going-what does that look like?” An image came to me of a time when Taheerah was upset in our room, crying on the floor. She looked so stiff, as if she were part of the floor.
The Demon Inside
I remembered feeling like Taheerah was going away, and thinking, “Is she going to the hospital again? Is she going to fight this demon inside of her?” I wanted my old sister back. The one who laughed at things that were not funny, cried at sad movies, yelled back at me, sometimes spoke up and wasn’t so afraid.
I told Dr. Bellinson, “At those times she’s crying, she’s in the room and I see her on the floor. I say,’Taheerah, get up,’ but I can’t bring her back.”
“Yes,” Dr. Bellinson said, “Both of those categories-bipolar and schizophrenic-mean she can’t be brought back except with medication.”
Confusing Diagnosis
She told me that during the teen years, it’s often hard to tell bipolar, schizophrenia and other mental illnesses apart. The symptoms of bipolar usually become clearly defined: times when the person is energetic, restless and can’t sit still, along with times of crying and despair. Schizophrenia comes with similar feelings, but more disorganized, without such clear ups and downs.
Especially when you’re young, you can go to several different doctors and get several different diagnoses. As you get older the patterns of your symptoms might become more obvious.
Doctors also use medication to verify which diagnosis is correct, she said. “When a med seems to help, that lets us know the diagnosis is right,” Dr. Bellinson told us. “If schizophrenia medications don’t work but the bipolar medications do, then we’ve got it.”
Did Abuse Cause This?
When my sister first got sick, I thought she was just depressed because of the abuse we both went through at home. I asked Dr. Bellinson whether Taheerah could just be suffering from the trauma, and whether it was the abuse that caused her mental illness.
“That’s the million dollar question,” she said. “Answer that and you’ll get the Nobel Prize.” She explained that psychiatrists still don’t understand why some people have an easier time recovering from abuse than others, or whether mental illness is related to abuse.
“Sometimes when people are being abused, they just cut themselves off. Inside their heads they go away,” she told me. “For some people, that helps. For others, it makes it worse, because they can never come back completely.”
“How and why some come back and others have more trouble-I wish we could just figure it out and help others survive well,” she added. “But some kids are really resilient, and some are thrown.”
She said it’s similar with physical problems-two kids might fall off a slide and one kid will break his arm and another won’t.
Strong Enough to Get Through
As with a broken arm, it’s possible to even help kids who aren’t as naturally resilient, Dr. Bellinson told me. The faster you get in a good home and get a good therapist, the better. “If you have a good adult to talk to during the time you’re being abused, even if you don’t tell them what’s happening, it seems like you’re better off,” she said.
Dr. Bellinson said that people who’ve experienced abuse might express their inner turmoil in all different ways-by crying, feeling anxious or angry, not wanting to eat, cutting themselves, or drifting away.
A therapist’s first task is to help people with their symptoms. “Those are all ways of showing that there’s something inside that’s unbearable, and they’re trying hard to survive the inside feeling,” she said. “After the symptom is being handled, then we have to work with their inner state so they are strong enough to get through life without expressing their pain in those ways.”
I’ve been struggling with some of the same feelings as my sister, but instead of going away I’ve sometimes cut myself or stopped eating. I’m not cutting myself anymore, but her words reminded me that I can’t be so bottled up with my emotions or I will explode. I need to learn to ask for help, and remember that it’s OK to do that.
Will It Happen to Me?
I told Dr. Bellinson that I’m afraid I will also develop bipolar like my sister, since I have those unbearable feelings inside, too. And a huge number of people in my family have mental illnesses. I asked her, “If one twin has it will the other twin?”
“Are you scared?” she asked.
“I have some stuff like that,” I told her. “Could I get it?”
“We all have some stuff,” she said. “It’s possible. Usually it’s not a complete surprise. It doesn’t come out of nowhere-poof! It sounds like it was growing for a long time. If you don’t see that growing inside you, you’ll be OK. Some children rise out of their childhoods and thrive.”
I was relieved because I had in the back of my mind that one day I would end up like my mother, who is very disabled by bipolar. I also feel scared and helpless when I see some of my mother in my sister, when she breaks down or goes into a crying spell. I’m still very scared that my sister will end up back in the hospital.
I can’t Bring Her Back
“Will therapy help my sister when she’s crying and on the floor?” I asked Dr. Bellinson.
“No. Therapy can help prevent breakdowns. But at those moments when she’s having a depressive episode, medication is probably the only thing that’s going to help,” she told me.
It helped me to know that when my sister gets into her modes, I can’t feel responsible for bringing her back. She is having a hard time and all I can do is give her space.
After the interview I realized that my sister and I each have our own problems and we’re each dealing with the pain of our past in our own ways. I decided I can’t keep treating her like she is my child, because she isn’t. She is her own person. I also decided that I need to take my own troubles seriously instead of pretending that my feelings are more under control that they are.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.