Listen Up, Minorities!: CUNY Don’t Want Ya!

When he first came to New York City Technical College, Tyrone Wallace had to take remedial courses.
Tyrone had taken off a year from school to work (he needed the money for college), and he had forgotten a lot of the knowledge he learned in high school.
Plus, he wasn’t such a great student in high school.
Now, Tyrone is studying art and advertising, and he wants to get into cartoon animation and comics.
When I asked how he’s doing in school, he proudly exclaimed, “Last report card I got two B’s and an A.”
But what would have happened to Tyrone without remedial courses?
“It would have impeded my going to college,” Tyrone said.
Remedial Classes Teach College Skills
Right now, remedial courses at CUNY are a big help for students who either didn’t get the appropriate education in high school or didn’t take school seriously enough, but are now striving to acquire the education they need to succeed in life.
But for high school students entering some of CUNY’s senior colleges next winter, getting a college education may be much harder.
Let me break it down for you: Right now, students who are accepted to CUNY’s senior colleges take an English, writing and math assessment test.
This is a test of basic skills that students should have acquired in high school. If the student fails an assessment test, she then must take remedial classes until she can pass.
These classes don’t give you any college credit, but they give you the skills necessary to be able to understand college level work. While you take remedial courses, you can also take credited classes in other subjects.
Ending Open Admissions
But on January 25, the CUNY Board of Trustees voted to end remedial classes at its four-year colleges. Instead, students will have to take remedial classes at two-year CUNY schools (community colleges) or at private testing services. Remedial classes will be eliminated over three years, beginning next January at Baruch, Brooklyn, Queens and Hunter Colleges.
“What’s the big deal?” I wondered when I heard about the vote. Why are so many students (especially minorities) and even faculty members angry about this proposal?
Well, many people think that the removal of remedial classes means the end of open admissions and will deny a college education mostly to the poor, minorities and immigrants.
Who Will Be Affected and Why?
CUNY’s open admissions policy guarantees every New York City high school graduate a place at a CUNY school. You might not realize it, but about 40% of NYC high school graduates go to CUNY.
This change is going to affect a lot of people.
According to a CUNY study, ending the remedial classes at CUNY’s four-year schools could prevent as many as 46% of students who plan on entering from being admitted in the first year the plan goes into effect.
Specifically, 46% of Black, 55% of Hispanic, 51% of Asian and 38% of White students would not be able to enroll in senior colleges.
Some people believe the policy is meant to discourage minorities.
“They don’t want to educate Blacks or Latinos,” Tyrone said.
No Place for the Poor
Removing remedial classes in senior colleges will probably affect the poor and minorities most because these are the students who live in ghettos and go to second-rate neighborhood schools.
But poor people are the ones who need a cheap, local college like CUNY the most, said Steven Kleinberg, executive director of the University Student Center, and a graduate of Queens College.
“If you have money, educational opportunities are still available to you,” Steven said. “If you have money you have easy access to other schools.”
Immigrants will be especially hard hit. They are more likely to fail an entrance exam in English, even if they can do an outstanding job in other subjects.
Fran Geteles, a former professor at City College, said that by closing the doors to anyone who needs remediation, CUNY’s senior colleges are being put out of the reach of the people who need these schools the most.
She also said that community colleges will not be able to “absorb the resulting demand for admission.”
Test Prep May Cost More
In addition, community colleges mostly provide vocational training in fields like nursing and office administration. They don’t offer many of the majors, like computer science or philosophy, that the senior colleges offer.
And if remediation is provided by private test prep services instead of the community colleges, it may cost more to take classes, especially without financial aid.
Students who already have many responsibilities-like having to work and take care of families-may not be able to afford the courses.
Why Do They Want To Change Things?
So, is there a good reason to remove remedial courses from senior colleges?
Mayor Guiliani and the Board of Trustees feel that remedial classes are lowering the standards of CUNY colleges.
In some ways, I understand their point of view. Maybe CUNY would have a better reputation if it weren’t known for allowing anyone with a high school diploma to enter.
Good students sometimes hesitate in applying to a CUNY college because they’d rather go to SUNY or a private college since those schools are a challenge to get into. They want to take classes with other students who are as qualified as they are.
But I don’t agree with Giuliani that all senior college degrees are looked down upon.
Senior colleges do have standards-they require a certain GPA and SAT scores-and the top schools, like Hunter and Baruch, are well respected.
Besides, I don’t think it’s fair to give up on students who aren’t yet “CUNY material.” I believe they can catch up, and should be given the opportunity to succeed. Otherwise, what will happen to them?
They may never be able to rise out of the poverty they seek to leave behind.
No Help for Students
I don’t think New York needs another elite college. What it needs is to provide an affordable college education to citizens who want it.
Many CUNY students and faculty don’t believe Giuliani wants to change CUNY to help students; they think he wants to save money.
Sondra Barios, a senior at Hunter College, said Giuliani has a record of cutting services to the poor.
“He’s always advocating cuts to all sorts of services. Any way they can cut the budget, he will do so,” Sondra said.
In fact, New York state spends less on CUNY now than it did 10 years ago, and the budget cuts have created overcrowded classes and fewer full-time faculty.
And Steven said Giuliani wants to make himself look good to middle-class voters.
“He wants to run for higher office. He makes himself seem like he’s on the cutting edge of reform, making things better, bringing it back to the way it was,” Steven added.
Why Open Admissions Works
The question is: Can students who fail a basic test then rise to working at the college level?
Critics say that many students who are admitted to CUNY senior colleges never graduate. But others succeed in ways they probably never imagined.
Look at Ferentz Lafargue, who chose to go to Queens College over Howard University because CUNY is so much cheaper. He had to take remedial math at Queens.
Ferentz said he was unprepared to take the math exam, because as a student at Jamaica HS, he had been more interested in reading and writing than math.
“Math wasn’t an integral part of my career or future interest,” said Ferentz, who was an English major at Queens.
Ferentz eventually passed the math test, graduated from Queens, and is now pursuing his Ph.D. in African American Studies at Yale University. In the future, he is planning to become a professor.
Obviously, Ferentz’s math troubles did not mean that he was unworthy or unsuitable to attend a CUNYsenior college.
A Chance to Rise Out of Poverty
For many, remediation is an opportunity for students to learn how to spread their wings so they can fly.
If CUNY hadn’t held its educational doors open to the poor, helping them achieve a degree that often seems available only to a select few, I believe New York City would be much worse than it is today, with more poor people dragging hope behind them to low wage jobs.
Instead, CUNY has created more educated workers prepared for careers.
Many of the students who enter CUNY are underprepared. However, they have dreams to rise out of poverty.
Often working, supporting a family and studying at the same time, these students know the value of an education, and are driven to learn.
Should we discourage their ambition, and let the educational doors of CUNY slam shut on their dreams?

SIDEBAR: Keep It Diverse
In the 1960s, CUNY had a great reputation, but it’s students were also very different: 95% White. It wasn’t until open admissions began in 1970 that the school began to reflect the racial and ethnic make up of the city. CUNY is now known for its diversity, and for providing an education to anyone with the willpower to learn. That is what CUNY is all about. For Sondra Barios, who first attended NYU but then transferred to Hunter College, a CUNY education was important because of the diversity of the students and because of its excellent Black and Latino Studies program. New Perspectives on the World “I’d never been to a place with so much diversity. I never expected-besides the quality of the education-the different perspectives of why you get a college education,” Sondra said. “It’s given me a different perspective on the world. I have a more complex view.” Sondra believes that CUNY is distinctive and important because it allows people with different levels of education to gather together in a classroom and learn from one another. “It comes down to what you believe in-what should college be about? Do you want an elite education for a few people, or do you want to bring other people up?” Sondra said.

About These Stories

YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.