“Hi! Like, my name is like Sharon and well, I’d like to vote for N’SYNC, because like, they’re so hotâLike, OH MY GOD, Carson I love you!”
NOT!
I like to think I am totally against everything Total Request Live stands for-commercialization, the mainstream and teeny-boppers.
Zone of Only Pop
I have nothing against Britney Spears, N’SYNC and the Backstreet Boys; in fact, I think their music is catchy and fun. What I don’t like is that watching TRL, you’d think that theirs is the only kind of music American teenagers listen to.
That’s not true. My musical tastes are very diverse. I like everything from Djama (a French reggae group) to Creedence Clearwater Revival to Bush. But as far as TRL is concerned, nothing exists besides pop.
So I wouldn’t be caught dead on Total Request Live. Or so I thought until the day I walked through Times Square during a taping of the show. An excitement vibrated through the crowd that had gathered outside the studio. It drew me in and made me want to take part, even though I’m not a fan.
Calling for Carson
It was beautiful the way people who’d never met were coming together to share in the TRL experience. Hundreds of strangers stood together screaming, some in matching costumes to draw attention to themselves, many holding signs reading, “Carson, I love you.”
I found myself seeing TRL in a new light. I was ready to sing and dance and run and jump and just have a good time. And when the studio lights and cameras flashed on Carson Daly, I realized he wasn’t mediocre, he was a god. I had the urge to join the crowd and chant Carson’s name.
Artificial and Ridiculous
Watching TRL from the comfort of my own home, there was never any magic. It looked like a normal TV show. Carson just stood in front of the studio audience introducing guests and counting down the videos.
The audience always seemed to be a bunch of 16- to 19-year-olds, wearing the latest denim trends and using expressions like “mad cool” or “phat,” trying to be so cool, but for the most part looking ridiculous.
The videos are not much better. They’re artificial and the images are predictable: flashy and colorful, featuring women in tight-fitting, barely-there clothing and men in either the newest baggy hip-hop gear or boy-band body-clinging outfits. There’s so little variety that it’s boring.
I Joined the Crowd
But if the show could bring so many strangers together so peacefully, I thought it couldn’t be all bad. I returned to the studio the next week, totally psyched; I was ready to conform and join the crowd, which I normally hate doing.
I stood with hundreds of teenage girls in the Times Square audience at 3:30 p.m. trying to get my screams to match theirs, but I couldn’t get my voice to go that high. Every time the camera flashed, I felt my already squashed self get attacked by waving arms and pointy signs.
It was fun, but I also felt like an idiot. Why was I spending my free time getting squashed? To be on TV for three seconds, if I was lucky?
Part of the Set
When I was at home watching the show, I never even thought of the crowd outside the studio as people; it was as though they were part of the set. I didn’t realize I’d actually feel like a part of the set when I was there.
I felt as though I was being used. The people in the studio would signal us to start screaming even though we didn’t know what we were screaming for (we couldn’t even figure out who the day’s guest was); they saw us as just a part of the set too, I guess.
Even though I went because I was attracted to the energy on the street and not to the show itself, once I got there all I wanted was to get into the studio. Inside, the audience was laughing and dancing; they were the ones who seemed to be having constant fun.
Although the energy was high outside, there was disappointment. After all, the more time you spent outside, the less hope you had of getting inside.
Fake Excitement, Too
I realized that the excitement I felt the first time I walked by was fake; it was manufactured by the show’s producers (who want to maintain TRL’s image as a hugely popular show) as well as by the Times Square audience (who want to attract the producers’ attention to get out of the crowd and into the studio).
So I’m back to where I started. If anything, I now feel more strongly that TRL is too commercial, too manufactured, too fake. Because, no matter how it appears on the show, American teenagers are not all exactly alike.
Like Not!
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.