(All names of people and places have been changed.)
I was on my way home one evening last December, walking slowly with my hands in the pockets of my big purple winter coat. Suddenly, I saw my former friend Patty’s boyfriend running on the opposite side of the street. Then I saw Patty across the street, too.
When she saw me, she smiled and waved as if saying hello to a neighbor. I looked at her as if she were stupid and kept walking. But I had to wonder, “Where did our friendship go?”
I’d just moved to Brooklyn from Jamaica when I first met Patty two years ago at the beginning of 8th grade. She acted as my own personal school compass and made me feel secure. We soon found that we had a lot in common. We were both smart, shy and were usually the first ones to get to class.
A Good Best Friend
Most of all, we could talk about anything. I could tell her how sad I felt about leaving my father and friends in Jamaica, knowing she wouldn’t judge me. And she told me about her parents constantly fighting. I occasionally called her, but usually she was the one who called me, almost every afternoon after school.
About three months into the school year, we were chatting on the phone when out of nowhere she said, “You’re a very good best friend.”
“Thank you,” I said. I felt so special that I began to blush. If my mom had been there, she would’ve thought I was talking to a guy.
“I like that you’re a good listener. I can talk to you about anything. You help me with a lot of things.”
“Thank you. You’re not so bad yourself,” I joked, and told her I felt the same about her. Little did I know, our words wouldn’t be enough to hold our friendship together.
‘He’s So Fine’
A couple of weeks later, Patty and I were walking down the hallway at school, when she said, “Oh my gosh. Look at him. He is so fine.”
I looked at the guy she was pointing at. He seemed average-looking to me. “What? You like him?” I asked.
“Yeah, that’s Robert. I’ve liked him since 6th grade. He always has a girlfriend though. He doesn’t know I like him,” she said, sadly.
After that, Patty spoke to me about Robert all the time. No matter what our conversation was about, she’d find a way to change the subject to Robert. She’d talk about her many attempts to get him and cry every time she failed.
I noticed that my role in the friendship had suddenly changed. We’d gone from comforting and listening to each other, to me doing all the listening.
It seemed as though my thoughts and feelings didn’t matter anymore. I wanted to tell her how I felt, but I refrained because I didn’t want to hurt her. Also, I was afraid one word could end our friendship.
When Robert and his girlfriend broke up that winter, Patty finally got him. I was happy for her when she told me they’d become a couple. I thought it was her reward for all the pain she’d gone through.
But within a few weeks, Patty started spending all her time with Robert. First, the kisses came, then the hickeys showed up on her neck. There were so many that it seemed like he was branding her, saying that she was his. I always felt like I was intruding when they walked home from school together, so I started walking alone.
Afraid to Speak Up
Soon, Robert had made Patty into his own personal dummy. She did whatever he told her to do. he’d say, “don’t go to class now,” and she’d say, “OK.”
I couldn’t believe how much Patty was changing. My trust and respect for her began to fade.
Now, whenever Patty talked about Robert, I usually had an annoyed look on my face. I wanted so badly to tell her how I felt, but I held back because I imagined she’d make me feel guilty for not supporting her.
I don’t know exactly when I knew that I was losing Patty as a best friend. Things just started to change slowly, almost like a thunderstorm. First, the sky turns gray, then drops of rain start to fall, and then the rain begins to pour more heavily. Then it just starts thundering.
You only know that there’s going to be a thunderstorm if you watch the Weather Channel or hear it from someone. Unfortunately, I had no weather report, and no one to tell me.
Soon Patty called so rarely that my mother, who used to complain about all the phone calls, asked me why she didn’t call anymore.
I felt betrayal and anger as I watched Patty slip away. I was the one who’d comforted her every time she cried, and Robert was the one who’d caused those tears. Why would she choose someone who hurt her over the person who helped her?
The New Patty
One day during the summer after 8th grade, Patty’s mother called to see if she was with me, and I learned that Patty had run away with Robert. It was hard to believe at first, but then I realized that this was something the new Patty would do.
About three weeks later, the phone rang. “Hello,” I said.
A soft voice said, “Hey, how you doing?” It was Patty. I was going to give her an attitude, but then she told me her parents were getting a divorce.
I didn’t want her to be sad, so I asked her about Robert. I pretended to be surprised when she said they’d run away for a day. Soon she said she had to go because Robert was coming over, and that she’d call me back. She never did.
Wishing I’d Tried
When we started 9th grade at different high schools and still hadn’t spoken, I knew the friendship was over. I’m sure Patty knew it too, because she never called again.
I was disappointed in her, because she let a boy end a great friendship. But I was also disappointed in me. I could’ve kept calling. I could’ve tried until there was nothing else to do, but I gave up. I’m not sure we would’ve stayed friends, but I wished I’d tried.
For a while, I thought I’d never want to have a best friend again. I didn’t think I could trust anyone. It felt like I’d let someone live with me, and then found out they’d stolen all my belongings. After that, why would I make the mistake of inviting someone to my house again?
But this year I made new friends in my new school and realized that not all people are like Patty. I even made another best friend, Jovanna.
Second Chance
Unlike with Patty, Jovanna and I share the microphone. We always take turns telling stories and talking about how we feel about things.
One recent evening, I was on the phone with Jovanna telling her about writing this story. Suddenly she asked, “Do you consider me your best friend?”
“I don’t know,” I said in an under-the-breath, sing-song way. I didn’t want to tell her that I did until I knew how she felt. I’d feel like a fool if she didn’t think of me as her best friend too. I needed her to say it first.
Then she said, “Well, I do consider you my best friend.”
“I consider you my best friend, too,” I said. We laughed and continued chatting, and I felt as if I’d gotten a second chance.
The Strength to Trust
Sometimes I worry that our friendship could change the way my friendship with Patty changed. But I don’t think I’ll ever be as afraid to be honest about my feelings as I was with Patty. I’ve gotten into uncomfortable situations with Jovanna before, and I’ve told her how I felt.
I’m glad I found the strength to trust someone again. I’ve always loved the idea of having a best friend forever-someone who knows me like no one else does and will have my back, come what may. Hopefully, I’ve found that this time.
Left Behind
How I lost my best friend to a boy
About These Stories
YC runs intensive nonfiction writing programs for teens in New York City, where they’re mentored by a professional editor to write personal stories about their lives and about issues that affect young people. Their stories are then published and read by thousands of teens, educators, policymakers, and other adults who work with and for young people.